Billy Evans Fires Back at Amanda Seyfried and Nathan Fielder: “It’s My Life and I Love It”
The whole point of participating in Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim’s You Can See Everything, says Billy Evans, was to change the world’s perception of Elizabeth Holmes, the 42-year-old founder of Theranos currently serving out an 11-year sentence for defrauding investors.
Their young children were already beginning to feel the repercussions when filming began, Evans says, being uninvited to playdates. But in the weeks since the film’s release, he finds himself facing a host of new problems, with strangers picking apart everything from the appearance of his genitals to how the couple makes scrambled eggs.
Evans, 34, is an MIT grad whose latest business venture — a company similar in ambition to Theranos called Haemanthus — is also raising eyebrows.
He broke his silence first with a Nov. 2 “Ask Me Anything” on X, where he addressed speculation about cocaine use (he said his drugs of choice are coffee and nicotine and that his persistent screen sniffles were the result of cedar allergies). He also denied being gay (“In 2026, being gay is considerably more socially acceptable than being in love with Elizabeth Holmes,” he wrote).
He then gave a sitdown with CBS Sunday Morning over the weekend, saying he in fact loved You Can See Everything, had not consented to his nudity being shown and did not currently have plans to sue studio A24 over his depiction in the film.
But Evans has a lot more to say. In his first print interview about the film, he wants to respond to Amanda Seyfried, 40, who recently told Rolling Stone that making the film, “I became this weird Billy Evans detective because I had gotten such strong negative feelings from him in the footage.” After filming their contentious dinner together, her opinion of him “only got worse.”
He also disputes one of the documentary’s most consequential scenes, in which Fielder and Oppenheim depict Evans holding up production over a cut of the profits. Evans says the financial terms were agreed upon two days before filming began and appearance releases were signed shortly after.
Below, Evans addresses all of that and much more, including that much-debated bag of turkey jerky, Holmes’ own thoughts on the shower scene and what, exactly, he and Holmes mean by “monuments of love.”
You ready, Billy?
No.
Fair enough.
That’s an honest answer, but I did not prep for this at all.
Do you ever worry that the movie will be something your kids will have to carry for the rest of their lives?
No, I don’t.
Why not?
At the time in which we were thinking about doing this movie, which was in February of 2023, already things were happening [to my kids], like they’d be uninvited from a play date or when we were looking at the first preschools or something. And I felt like the world had created a narrative about who their mom was that was untrue.
The goal with this film is really to let people just see her and make up their own mind, which was kind of in part why we chose Nathan. He’s a genius filmmaker. He’s insanely creative and he tells a story that only he could tell.
And your gut reaction after the first time seeing it — did you feel it helped or hindered your cause?
I’m so biased. So I think I’m really kind of the last person whose opinion matters on the subject. But to me, when Liz is on screen — and I think it’s an important distinction to make compared to recreations or reenactments — that’s just who she is. That is Elizabeth Holmes. It’s the same Liz I saw the first day I met her and it’s the same Liz now that she’s in prison. She’s insanely trusting and kind, compassionate, a bit naive, but that’s who she is. Now the problem is that people see that and they have a hard time believing it’s real. That’s been my experience for the last decade. That’s who she really is.
And what about the depiction of you?
I really didn’t like it. It’s hard to see yourself depicted in a way that frames things so intensely negative, having people scrutinize the smallest of actions, like helping your wife make eggs and it being turned into some condemnation of toxic masculinity or some controlling nature. Control is a word that I’ve never really considered in my relationship with Liz. We just infinitely trust one another.
Is she generally inept in the kitchen?
You have to remember she was running a company for 16 years. She didn’t cook at all, at all. There’s a reason why she just had green drinks. She was unable to cook. Liz could burn water. And I grew up working in kitchens. My first job was in a kitchen, so I love cooking. When Liz was pregnant, I cooked every single meal for the two years she was pregnant for us. I’d make meals for 10, 15, 20 people every night of the trial. I love cooking. She doesn’t like it at all.
There’s an expression from reality TV: “Blame it on the edit.” Do you feel that you were the victim of the edit?
I actually interpret the scene very differently than everyone else because I just don’t even think about control. So that’s not how I saw it at all. I think the criticism of it and the creepy music and then the focus on it later and Amanda’s reaction to it was different than how I interpreted it.
The one thing that everyone brings up first about you is the shower scene. I saw the New York Times did a whole story on it.
Oh, really? Yeah. I don’t read all this stuff. Look, so much of this stuff can really just be chalked up to my naivete. I always heard about you have to sign some nudity waiver. I just assumed you can’t show people naked on screen without them consenting to it. So yes, I absolutely consented to them filming me showering, but my understanding is that they wouldn’t show [my penis] in the film. It was not like I wanted to show the world myself naked.
I’ve seen people saying it was an example of you peacocking.
I’m with a bunch of dudes. There was no woman on the entire production. You grow pretty close with a group of guys.
Why do you think they chose to include it?
You should ask them. It wasn’t my decision. I wasn’t part of the process. We had lawyers reach out to them after I had heard that it had happened, pleading for them to remove it. If it was the case that I was peacocking, I wouldn’t have asked them to take it out.
And what’s Elizabeth’s opinion of that scene?
She hasn’t seen the movie, but she felt strongly about it. She’s a pretty traditional person and felt that it’s a violation of our intimacy. But for me, there’s a lot of embarrassment associated with everyone you know and their moms and the kids’ parents at drop-off having seen this.
Did I consent to them filming me? Yes. Did I consent to them showing it to the world? No. I would expect them to blur things.
But as the film goes on, there are other scenes that are harder to explain away. Are there any that really horrified you?
They were really circumstances of the situation that I’m going through. I’m not a single parent, but I am the only person that is physically with my kids five days a week and I’m raising them more or less alone. And Liz is the most incredible partner given the circumstances. She wrote two letters a day to the kids every day for the first two years she was in prison, two letters to me every day. She’s written over 3,000 letters over the course of the time she’s in prison. They are really intricate. She’ll cut up nature magazine articles that are relevant for the kids and then do these beautiful illustrations and teach them lessons through them and we read them every night.
But I’m the person who’s carrying the load here and driving them out every weekend and building a business. And I moved them away from my family in San Diego to Texas so we could all be together. So I think [people need] to understand the frustrations or the anger, which certainly exists at a system in which I feel like my wife is 100 percent innocent and wrongfully incarcerated. I certainly have frustrations.
Where I did start to get a little, I don’t know, concerned about you is a sequence where you talk about, first of all, always carrying a gun with you. Then you say that you “have vengeance in your heart.”
I think that’s not true.
What was going on when you said that? Why did you say it?
Look, there’s many things that I said over the course of three and a half years that I would word so differently. There’s things that I’m embarrassed about saying or that I wish I had not said altogether. But I wasn’t thinking [at the time] about everything I said on camera. I was trying my best to open up all of me, including the bad parts in those moments of anger, sadness and frustration.
The start of filming was April 24, 2023. That was a long time ago, and I’ve grown a lot as a person over that period of time. If there’s things that I’m not embarrassed about having said three and a half years ago, then I haven’t grown enough.
Where did you see the movie, by the way? Were you with an audience?
I was, yeah. They refused to show it to me before it came out.
Did people in the audience recognize it was you?
No. No, they didn’t. I came in right before it started. I went to the opening showtime of opening day here in Austin with a friend and her mom.
I happened to be in Chicago on opening weekend, and I went to see it. It was a packed theater, and they were quite vocal.
Yeah, it was strange to see people laughing at things that I didn’t think were particularly funny. It was strange to be part of an audience where there’s an audience sentiment about something that you don’t also share, or [about which] you have more context and understanding.
In the film, when Amanda Seyfried, whose name I now know how to pronounce because of the film…
I learned it there, too.
But before she even meets you, based on the footage she sees, she’s very vocal about the fact that she doesn’t like you, she doesn’t trust you, and she thinks you’re a bad influence on your wife.
Yeah, that was very strange to see.
I heard women behind me in Chicago cheering her on and clapping and saying “exactly,” as if she voiced what they had been thinking all along. Amanda becomes an avatar for everyone who doesn’t like you while they’re watching the movie. She recently doubled and tripled down on that, telling Rolling Stone that when she finally met you, she thought worse of you. How do you respond to that?
I’ve heard she was going through a lot in her life at the time in which this was being filmed, so I can understand why she’d view our relationship through a different lens than reality. I’d also say that she’s never spent any time with me and Liz together, and what she saw was not raw footage. She saw the edit that the audience saw.
And by “going through” things, you mean her own divorce?
I don’t know. I see a lot of headlines. I’d rather not comment on specifics. What I can say is Elizabeth and I have been through enormous challenges that people have read about — and some harder things that nobody knows about. Through that process, our relationship has only become stronger than it’s ever been. That’s a great testament to the love that we do have for each other, and it doesn’t matter much to me what other people think about it, because they don’t see it. They see small vignettes stitched together with music, being told by an A-list or B-list celebrity what to think about it.
But it’s my life and I love it. I’m super happy. I’ve got this incredible family. We’ve got this amazing tribe of people who have been through hell and back with us, who support us through every one of those challenges. And I’ve got two beautiful children that I get to spend every day with. If other people are unhappy about our relationship, I suggest that they invest more time in their own.
What’s your version of how it went down, what we saw on screen, where it gets quite contentious across the dinner table?
It made more sense to me after seeing the film, and hearing her say, “I want to break them up.” I didn’t understand her intentions [when she came over]. I thought we were extending an olive branch and saying, “Look, we’re not angry with you. We’re happy to engage. We don’t blame you for your portrayal of Liz [in The Dropout]. You’re an actress, you didn’t write the script, you didn’t develop the story, you didn’t do the research or lack thereof.”
What about this notion that she has something to gain personally from portraying Elizabeth? She won an Emmy for The Dropout, and they’re now saying she’s up for an Oscar for You Can See Everything.
Yeah. It seems there is an unwillingness to confront the reality of the consequences of playing a living person, especially when you readily admit 80 percent of it was made up. Then you say, “Well, but I’m really good at playing her and people can’t distinguish the difference between me and her.” Which is it? When confronted, you say it’s just a story, it’s entertainment, it’s just made up. Then when trying to convince Nathan to [cast you in a role], you say, “People can’t tell the difference between me and her.” I think that’s kind of an interesting and very fluid interpretation.
But back to the dinner. You’re saying when you saw the film, you realized she came in with the intention to break you two up. What prompted your remarks about Charlie Kirk and her career?
I’m not going to be able to recreate the exact exchange from years ago for you. I can tell you that this was not just a random burst of frustration. She clearly states her intention in the film and she lived up to that intention, but it obviously didn’t work.
She had a theory that you were controlling Elizabeth through — what’s the legal term that you had over her?
Power of attorney. Yeah, I think it’s important to talk about that for a minute. It shows her complete lack of understanding of the legal system. She’s like, “But she’s still alive!” Yeah, power of attorney is not relevant if somebody is dead. That is called a will. Power of attorney is unfortunately a requirement of being incarcerated, in our case. We’ve got two kids, we’re not married. If I need to make big decisions, that’s a way in which I can do so. I’ve got no ability to contact Elizabeth immediately when a decision or something needs to be made.
There’s decisions, like picking a legal team, in which she cannot meet with them until we set up the first conversations. And I need to be able to talk to them to understand, is this somebody that we want to work with or not? And there’s other examples — like her cell phone number. If I didn’t have access to her bank account or her cell phone bill, I wouldn’t be able to make the payment on her behalf.
That decision was made between Elizabeth and I over the course of months. Like the idea of being on X. The film criticizes me for speaking on her behalf, but I would point to the fact that Nathan is speaking on her behalf through the reenactments that he makes. Amanda is speaking on her behalf by voicing those words and has done so in the past. I am a third person doing it, but I’m the only person with her explicit authority and consent and knowledge. They don’t have that.
Well, once we’re on this topic, what about the whole tweet thing?
Well, that’s in part what I’m talking about. Liz and I talked about this. If you look at Liz’s profile on X, it’s remained unchanged since the first day we relaunched her X account in October of ’25. It says “founder of Theranos,” and then at the bottom it says, “mostly my words posted by others.”
We’ve been very clear about the fact that everything posted on our X account is not just her words from the very beginning. And that was a decision. We worded that purposely together.
That in itself wouldn’t bother me. But then they start showing these hostile tweets with swear words in them. And then it’s like, well, that’s a little weird. Did it strike you as weird?
Yeah, but it’s Twitter. This isn’t a State of the Union address. And you look at the examples that are given, it’s like in response to somebody asking for the 10th time if you can show them your feet and if you’re starting an OnlyFans account or if you’re going to start a crypto token.
Right. But you could just ignore that. Especially because she is a former CEO and is currently incarcerated.
I am not an expert at this stuff. Do I wish I would have hired some masterful team to help do this properly? Absolutely. But I was doing the best I can. I certainly made mistakes throughout the process.
There’s some element of shitposting and joking about these things. You have to remember the environment on X is where politicians and the White House press secretary or White House chief of communication or lots of powerful people who have really important positions are using similar language because of the audience and because of where it’s being said. They would not say that in a press conference. They would not say that in a shareholder letter. I think the context is important to remember.
I think it’s kind of ironic that there’s so much of a focus on me saying “F— you” to somebody. And then in the film, they’re recreating something that absolutely did not happen categorically, recreating a scene suggesting that Elizabeth and I are jumping up and down saying “we got the fucking money.”
[The interview pauses for Evans to take a call from Holmes.]
What’s the frequency of her calling?
She has 500 minutes a month on the phone, which is split between me and everyone else. If you go one second over, then it takes a whole minute from you.
Before she called, you had brought up the recreation of the pizza party negotiation with A24. So tell me, what were we misled with there? What didn’t happen?
The entire thing. Nathan says something in the film to the effect of “we had to move quickly, so we started filming before they had signed an appearance release and they refused to sign anything before we had this meeting in Los Angeles at one of his friends’ houses.”
Was there any meeting with any A24 executive?
Yes, there were. There were two senior people from A24.
Was one of them [A24 CEO] Daniel Katz?
No, not that senior. We’re not that big of a deal. It was at my friend’s house, but it was a one-story house. So this whole idea that Liz goes upstairs or something, I know it seems like a small detail, but I was at the house the other night. There’s no pretending like you’re in a completely separate room or hiding behind doors. That’s completely fictitious.
The way it’s depicted in the film is that it’s not clear when she stepped away from the table if she knew or didn’t know that you were about to ask for a percentage of the film’s profits.
On April 16, 2023, Nathan and Lance came down to San Diego. The way in which we had connected with them was through one of the producers on the project who went to high school with some of my friends. I knew him from college. His name is Jack Davis. It’s not a mystery.
It was my idea to make a movie. This was not something that she was planning to do or was really thinking about. I had spoken to a lot of different people about this — maybe 10 different documentary filmmakers and people that I thought could help tell the story. A24 was one of those groups. That introduction had come through Jack.
So Nathan and Lance then come down to San Diego on April 16, which is depicted in the film as a recreation in which Nathan is talking about David Blaine. That actually happened. On April 18, A24 made its first financial offer. On April 19, we met again in Los Angeles at my friend’s house. I wanted Nathan and Lance to know that that was on the table. On April 21, that’s the first documented transmission of an appearance release. On April 22, commercial terms, including the backend, were agreed to. Then it was handed over to the lawyers. We signed the releases a few weeks later.
So there was never a conversation where Fielder objected and said, “You can’t make a proper documentary if you’re getting paid?”
I do recall them saying, “This is atypical,” but it was not a big deal. I mean, the entire conversation maybe lasted two minutes, and they immediately said, “OK.” And then from there, it was just handed off to the team. And then we started filming on April 24.
But this idea that we were “holding up” signing an appearance release and they had already started filming is completely made up. If they didn’t think it was ethical or if they didn’t think it was fair or if they thought it was improper, they could have walked away from it.
A big thing is made in the film of her saying, “I’m not getting paid for this.”
She was not. I was. So what Liz said was true. What she said is, “I am not profiting in any way from this.” We are completely financially distinct. We are not married. We keep our assets separate.
It was the most stressful period of our life by far. [When they brought it up again three years later,] it was really hard for me to remember what Liz knew, what I knew, what the lawyers handled, what they told me after the fact. I couldn’t remember clearly, and I still don’t. I answered to the best of my ability.
They could have very easily just not made the movie. Instead they attempt to villainize me in that negotiation and recreation, and I think it takes up way too much of the movie, and I think it’s just so uninteresting.
There’s a title card at the end, a chyron, that says you relinquished your piece of the backend. Is that true?
That is a true statement.
When did you relinquish it?
They said “shortly after filming.” I can check the exact dates, but it was maybe five months ago. It suggests that I knew filming was completed. I didn’t. I thought that they were going to continue filming [past Elizabeth’s release].
Why did you do that?
They said that it would help the project. Time and time again, when there’s things that I really didn’t want to do that they said would be helpful for making a better movie and helping people see Liz more clearly, I made those sacrifices or decisions to help the project.
I have to be honest, I’m surprised you capitulated to that. You seem like a stubborn guy.
I am totally stubborn, but if there’s anything that I can do to help Liz regardless of the cost, I will do it.
Did you consult with her before you made that decision?
She was OK with neither of us getting paid from the very beginning. I mean, she didn’t have a strong opinion one way or another. Her problems are so much bigger than this and she really doesn’t care about money. I’m a little bit more of a realist. At the time in which these things were negotiated, I’m a single dad with two kids whose best friend’s about to be sent to prison. And at that time I didn’t have a job. I’m trying to provide for my family and I’m really scared about what’s to come.
Could we talk about the prison sequence at the end of the film? Let me ask about something kind of silly, but that I’ve seen debated, which is in the last shot of the film you’re seen sharing or eating from the bag of turkey jerky that Nathan supposedly bought for her. I’ve seen it interpreted in different ways. One is that you’re eating her turkey jerky and how selfish could you be?
That just shows how people want to see me. The machines have a lot of every item in them. I’ve got a credit card and I’ve probably spent tens of thousands of dollars on nuts and snacks over the course of the last three and a half years that we were there. I can tell you what I think happened, which is ironic because the turkey jerky’s name is Think. I actually got reached out to by the CEO of the turkey jerky company telling me, “Thank you. Our sales have increased so much and this is awesome. I really appreciate it.” And then they tried to drop off a big box of turkey jerky at a place that used to be our office.
She loves E0 on the vending machine all the way to the left, and she loves the nuts, which are E9 all the way to the right, because they have banana chips in them. I can remember a handful of times over that period that Liz requested turkey jerky, just a handful.
What’s E0?
E0 is a different type of trail mix that has some pieces of dehydrated fruit in it. So I know the system well. Another important detail is none of the vending machines have clocks on them. I checked again last weekend. None of them have clocks on them. Nathan says he saw the time on the vending machine. That’s impossible.
My guess is I got turkey jerky for myself. Nathan added that detail into their reenactment scene together to create continuity in the film.
And there’s this other theory that Nathan is depicting a romantic rivalry, because then it cuts to them frolicking in the surf. Could he be that devious?
I think devious is the wrong word, but I think Nathan’s an excellent storyteller and a lot of this film is different than the truth. A lot of it’s to create an entertaining product that drives ticket sales, and they’ve been incredibly successful at that.
They sort of crafted the perfect Reddit entertainment.
Yeah, they did a phenomenal job of it. But the truth is they could have made a very similar movie about many different people.
One thing I came away with is that you hoped that the movie would recast Liz from a villain in prison to what you see as the loving, compassionate woman that is mother to your children. And in that sense, it kind of worked. Because look what we’re talking about. You’re the bad guy now.
I’m willing to take any arrows for people to see her. I just wish that more time had been spent with her and on her rather than on my negotiation with the filmmakers or picking apart a word from three years ago or making eggs.
Nathan and Lance made a beautiful film and they told a really compelling story. It just really differs from the reality that I experienced. I think in the parts in which Liz is on camera, they do a beautiful job of depicting her.
You speak in the film of building monuments of love to each other. That’s a new phrase. I’ve never heard that in my life. What were you referring to?
Nathan asked something to the effect of, “Well, what would she say if she was here right now?” And what I say is, “If she was here, she’d tell you that in 500 years she’d be remembered for this love story and that she’ll dedicate her life to building monuments of love to me.”
When I say it, it sounds like the most narcissistic and self-serving thing on the planet, and it looks crazy. And then he goes and sees her and she repeats it nearly verbatim. That’s just how she describes us.
I’m just asking what it means.
That we are deeply in love and deeply connected and really plugged into one another.
But what’s a monument to love? That’s my question. What does that mean to you?
We have all these ideas of things that we want to do with our life to come. We’re deeply committed to improving human health and reducing suffering. Liz and I watched this Anthony Bourdain episode on the Democratic Republic of the Congo, and Anthony’s going down the river and slaughtering a chicken trying to clean it. He’s just getting eaten alive by mosquitoes, and he eventually shows up to this kind of abandoned banana research and fruit research farm that was built by the French in the ’60s or something, and it’s completely falling apart.
Liz and I have talked about building an infectious disease research station there and dedicating it to one another. That’s a monument to love.
I’ve seen a lot of discussion regarding Elizabeth’s father, Christian Holmes IV, and a revelation about her which you interrupted.
Her parents are some of my best friends. I’ve spent an enormous amount of time with them over the course of the last nine years. In the film, they make it look like her parents are disgusted with me or with Liz and what we’re talking about before she goes. They’re just scared. Their daughter’s going to prison. They have no idea how to handle this.
There’s a part in the film in which they’re talking to Liz’s dad and he says, “I’ll tell you where something went wrong or where everything changed: It’s when she was raped at Stanford.” Then the film just drops it and never engages with it again. I’ve even had friends ask me, “Well, why did you cut them off?”
Liz had two days before she went to prison, and we were trying to find a balance between access and preserving time with family, and there was no perfect balance there. Lance and Nathan spent significant time with her parents interviewing them and going through high school video and teacher reports from middle school trying to understand who Liz was. If they wanted to know what Chris meant in saying that, they had an infinite opportunity to explore it, but they didn’t put it in the film because they chose not to.
It’s funny though, because you never fully condemn Nathan and Lance. You often say they made a beautiful film, they did this, they did that, they’re brilliant. But then at the same time you say it was deceptive and they had bad intentions.
I don’t know if I said they had bad intentions.
Well, bad in that they were creating a narrative at your expense.
I think it shows the frailty of memory. [In the reenactments] I think he’s just trying to convey it to the best of his recollection. But I think those memories aren’t that great, man.
Has Liz relayed to you how the success of this film is affecting her life in prison?
Yeah, but I’d have to go off the record and tell you about that. I think what I can say on record is that it’s been really hard since the film has come out.
Does it feel weird to be in the movie of the year that’s in Oscar contention, maybe even front-runner status, and being the most compelling character in that film?
It is so weird. It’s hard to describe to you, and I think I’m still trying to work through how I feel about it. If you ask me the same questions in six months, I might have different answers for you about how I feel about things. I’m willing to take on new information, make a new opinion. I’m trying to explain to you how I feel in this moment, and it’s a really strange moment.
And it’s kind of exacerbated by the fact that I can’t talk to my best friend about it because she hasn’t seen it. That’s the weirdest part in this to me. I’ve described things to her, but she hasn’t seen any of it.
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.