CBS Officially Redeems Marshals' Secret Villain

Published Oct 14, 2026, 9:00 PM EDT

Sean is a senior writer for ScreenRant and has been writing about new TV releases since December 2023. He has received multiple advance screenings of popular shows and ideated his own coverage read by hundreds of thousands of readers.

Sean is a self-published author of a Western novel. Sean has also written award-winning opinion pieces related to local politics while getting his Bachelor's degree in journalism.

After just two episodes, Marshals season 2 has already begun redeeming the show's secret villain. Though Tom Weaver is by far the most villainous character in the cast of Marshals, the Yellowstone spinoff show also has no shortage of antagonists besides him. Most of those secondary antagonists are the criminals Kayce Dutton and his team hunt down every episode, but the show also has a more secretive antagonist throughout the whole series.

That secret secondary antagonist is none other than Harry Gifford, the head of the Montana division of the U.S. Marshals and Kayce's boss. Throughout Marshals season 1, Gifford had a bone to pick with Kayce, and he generally made life harder than it needed to be for him. Now, however, Marshals season 2 seems to be giving Gifford a chance to redeem himself, and he's already started down the path to becoming one of the show's many heroes.

Marshals Season 2 Sees Gifford Redeeming Himself

Though he hated Kayce throughout the first season, Harry Gifford finally got a chance to redeem himself in Marshals season 2, episode 2. In the first season, Gifford mentioned that he had 40 years' worth of history with the Dutton family, which left him with the opinion that all the members of the Dutton family are criminals "born with dysfunction in their blood." In the rest of his appearances, Gifford continued to be a jerk to Kayce because of the grudge he had against the Duttons.

Now, however, Gifford seems to have changed. At the end of this week's episode, while talking to Calvin, Gifford mentioned that Kayce had proven to him that "the poison apple don't always fall from the poison tree." Clearly, Gifford still has some resentment towards the Duttons, but he's a big enough man to set that aside and judge Kacey as an individual. It's not necessarily heroic, but it's a major step forward from the character he was in Marshals season 1.

Gifford also spends most of Marshals season 2, episode 2 being a stand-up guy. He looks out for his team, he clearly cares very deeply about the law enforcement officers who were being killed, and he even takes a bullet at the end of the episode. Then, Gifford comes clean about his connection to Plummer and the fact that he prevented Wayne from joining the force. He's not a perfect man yet, but Gifford is making great strides towards redeeming himself, especially in comparison to his semi-villainous depiction in season 1.

What Gifford's Character Change Means For Marshals

Gifford's character change is big for him as a member of Marshals' cast, but it also has some implications for the show at large. Mainly, Gifford's redemption means that Marshals season 2 won't have the same team dynamic that season 1 did. In season 1, Gifford was basically against the team and acted as a secondary antagonist. Now, he's fully supportive of all his agents, including Kayce. That should make the team more effective, but it should also mean there's less internal drama for Marshals to latch onto.

If Gifford continues to bury the proverbial hatchet with Kayce, it will also mean that a promising storyline from season 1 will be dropped. Some fans wanted to know more about the 40 years of bad history Gifford had with the Dutton family and believed it would have a big impact on the show. Now, however, Gifford seems to have put his differences with Kayce aside, for the most part. There's still a chance that Marshals will reveal more about Gifford's past, but it probably won't be a source of tension between him and Kayce anymore.

Somewhat indirectly, Gifford's change in character should also help Marshals season 2 find its footing. As interesting as it was to have Gifford be in opposition to the team and Kayce, there's simply too much going on for it to continue being a big plot point. Marshals has bigger and more interesting stories to focus on, like Tom Weaver and Kayce's worries about becoming his father. Gifford is being sidetracked, which should be a net positive for Marshals.