Matthew Schaefer Overtakes Two NHL Legends In Remarkable Teenage Run

Islanders defenceman Schaefer climbs NHL teenage scoring charts© X(formerly Twitter)/@NHLPR
Matthew Schaefer keeps rewriting the record books, and at this point it barely registers as surprising. The New York Islanders defenceman recorded his 53rd career assist in his latest outing, moving past Larry Murphy for the sixth most by a teenage defenceman in NHL history. And then, in the same breath, his 85th career point pushed him past Rasmus Dahlin into second place on that all-time teenage points list. Add to that his 18th career multi-point game, which now puts him second behind Phil Housley's 34 — ahead of Ray Bourque's 17 — and the picture becomes hard to ignore. At 19, Schaefer is not building toward something. He already is something.
Climbing A List Nobody Expected Him To Reach So Fast
With his 17th career multi-point game on Tuesday, Schaefer had already passed Larry Murphy and Rick Hampton and tied Ray Bourque for the second most multi-point games by a teenage defenceman, trailing only Housley's 34. Saturday's performance then broke that tie with Bourque outright.
What makes this more striking is context. Through 22 games of the 2026-27 season, Schaefer has recorded 26 points — nine goals and 17 assists. He is not coasting on a historic rookie year. He is accelerating.
His 77 total career points after 100 games had him fourth on the teenage defenceman list, two behind Ray Bourque for third, with Dahlin second at 84 and Housley first at 132. He has since pulled past both Bourque and Dahlin with his 85th. Housley remains the gold standard at 132, and Schaefer is now targeting first.
None of this was supposed to happen this quickly. Even the most optimistic projections had him developing over seasons, not months. But last year he won the Calder Trophy, set the record for most goals and points by an 18-year-old defenceman in a single season with 23 goals and 59 points, and now he is hunting legends in only his second NHL campaign.
The Distance Still To Cover
The other teenage defencemen with 15 or more career multi-point games are Phil Housley (34), Ray Bourque (17), Larry Murphy (16), Rick Hampton (16) and Rasmus Dahlin (15). Schaefer now sits at 18. That is not a coincidence or a statistical quirk — it is consistent excellence across two seasons, and he still has the entire 2026-27 campaign to run as a teenager.
He is 47 points behind Housley's teenage record of 132. That gap is not small, but neither is the amount of time he has left. If his first 104 games are any indication, the Islanders have a defenceman who may not stop until he reaches the top of every list in front of him.
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.