Could Nathan MacKinnon Finally Get His Wish Of Playing Alongside Sidney Crosby

Crosby skates as trade rumours swirl around Pittsburgh star© X(formerly Twitter)/@penguins
Sidney Crosby has spent more than two decades in Pittsburgh, won three Stanley Cups, and never once seriously entertained the idea of leaving. But the 2026-27 NHL season is shaping up differently. Penguins GM Kyle Dubas met the media this week and confirmed the team will be future-oriented on the trade front, holding direct conversations with Crosby, Evgeni Malkin, and Kris Letang about where things stand. Crosby, now 39 and in his 22nd NHL season, acknowledged to reporters this week that trade rumours become more realistic when the team is losing. Colorado, where his close friend Nathan MacKinnon plays, keeps coming up as the most logical destination.
A Door That Was Once Shut Is Slowly Opening
A year ago, this conversation had a short shelf life. When trade rumours surfaced during the 2025 draft, MacKinnon shot them down directly with a sharp two-word Instagram comment: “Fake news.” That put the matter to rest quickly.
Now, though, the framing has changed. Josh Yohe of The Athletic laid it out plainly: “The truth is, everything is in his hands. If Crosby wants to keep playing with the Penguins after this season, they will naturally accommodate his wishes. If he wants to retire after this season, he will retire. If he wants to be traded, Dubas will trade him.”
That is a remarkable statement about a franchise player who has never worn another NHL jersey. Crosby himself has not changed his public stance. He said his plans haven't changed and he is not about to ask for a trade, nor does he specifically want one. But what players say in November and what quietly takes shape over a long season are two different things.
Yohe added that most people within the organisation believe Crosby will return to Pittsburgh next season, though no one truly knows because Crosby himself does not appear to know what he wants to do. That uncertainty alone keeps the conversation alive.
Why Colorado Keeps Resurfacing
The Avalanche are not in ideal shape right now. MacKinnon and Cale Makar have both picked up injuries, which has created some urgency for Colorado to add pieces and stay in the mix among the NHL's top teams. That is precisely the kind of situation where a Crosby trade starts making more sense for both sides.
The salary piece is workable, though the mechanics are tricky. Moving Martin Necas and his $11.5 million cap hit would easily clear room for Crosby's $8.7 million expiring deal, but Necas holds a full no-movement clause and is coming off a 100-point season as Colorado's top healthy offensive driver, making him an unlikely trade chip.
Crosby and MacKinnon share a well-documented friendship, and if Crosby ever submitted a preferred destination list, the Avalanche would almost certainly be on it. He holds a full no-movement clause, which puts him firmly in control of whatever comes next. Pittsburgh, for their part, has made it clear they will treat him differently than any other player in a situation like this.
Nothing is happening imminently. But the fact that Dubas is openly discussing a future-oriented direction, while Crosby refuses to rule anything out, is a sharper signal than anything that surfaced last summer. The window for this NHL team-up to happen is narrower than it used to be, and both sides know it.
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.