Inquirer EntertainmentJC Santos plays abducted priest in ‘Romano,’ highlighting plight of missing activistsThe Jerusalem PostWhat is the ICJ, the UN body that just ruled Myanmar committed genocide? - explainerInquirerLTO suspends lady rider’s license over ‘dangerous stunt’ in CaviteDaily MaverickCommunity Innovation: From polluted canals to new horizons — imagining Gqeberha’s futureZDF heuteEntdecken Sie das ZDF-NachrichtenstudioPremium TimesFormer NUJ Abuja chairman, Abdul Jelil Adebayo, dies at 62VanguardTinubu: First 100 Yutong CNG buses to arrive DecemberCBS NewsAnthropic set to start trading after completing largest-ever IPORai NewsStorico verdetto della Corte internazionale di giustizia: "In Myanmar contro Rohingya fu genocidio"NumeramaUn mois après le chaos PHP2Shell, que vaut vraiment la nouvelle alerte critique de PHP ?RMF24Najdłuższy tunel drogowy w Polsce. To oni zbudują maszynę, która go wydrążyDW DeutschUN-Gericht: Myanmar verantwortlich für Rohingya-Völkermord
The Daily Newsstand · Free, Always
Thursday, November 19, 2026

CFP selection committee has officially discredited itself with latest rankings | Ian Miller

Translate

Rarely, if ever, are college football fans united about anything. Regional allegiances, conference alignment, alma mater, even cities, all of it is cause for disagreement and argument.

But the College Football Playoff selection committee may have accomplished the impossible and brought the vast majority of the sport's fandom together in anger and frustration. And for good reason. Since the release of the first top-25 poll of the season, there's been controversy building around the committee and how they've handled this process. Controversy that boiled over in the aftermath of Tuesday's televised event.

This page may contain affiliate links to legal sports betting partners. If you sign up or place a wager, FOX News may be compensated. This content was created by a team that works independently from the FOX newsroom.

Week two did little to assuage anyone, instead adding several major controversies. SEC teams were consistently overrated, even when evaluated against objective metrics and not subjective "measurement." Then there's the treatment directed at the defending national champion Indiana Hoosiers.

NEW COLLEGE FOOTBALL PLAYOFF POLL PROVES THE SELECTION COMMITTEE IS JUST MAKING IT UP AS THEY GO

Indiana had a bye between week one and week two of the poll, entering at No. 4. After, you know, not playing, they dropped a whopping five spots all the way down to No. 9. So the committee believed they were the fourth-best team in the country, they sat at home, and suddenly were the ninth-best team in the country. That's bad enough, but what made it worse was the explanation committee chair Hunter Yurachek gave for its "thought process."

"Indiana was probably a victim of having a bye week at the wrong time with seven games between Top 25 teams," he said. "The committee is really impressed with what UCLA, Texas, and Notre Dame did as well as Alabama and LSU."

"Every team that Indiana had played to date in the Big Ten all lost and that affected their strength of schedule rank and the committee's review of Indiana," he continued. "The quarterback play in general and the offensive play in general is kind of a discussion point of Indiana ... They've won games because of their defense and not their offense."

Absurd comments about offense and defense aside, as if winning games with a quality defense is somehow bad, Yurachek laid out a clear standard the committee was apparently following: if all your opponents lose in the same week, it hurts your perceived strength of schedule.

Okay, fine. You may or may not agree with that "logic," or obvious lack thereof, but sure, if that's the standard the committee wants to have, at least it's a standard. Right?

Well, the thing about standards is that you have to actually enforce them consistently, or you're going to embarrass and discredit yourself if you don't. The College Football Playoff selection committee had a golden opportunity in week three of their rankings to show fans and analysts that they were, in fact, unbiased, and willing to enforce their newly-created "standards" equally, regardless of which team they applied to.

They did the exact opposite.

Indiana Hoosiers head coach Curt Cignetti walks onto the field before a college football game between the Michigan State Spartans and Indiana Hoosiers on Oct. 18, 2025, at Memorial Stadium in Bloomington, Ind. (Icon Sportswire via Getty Images)

For some inexplicable reason, maybe a misguided belief that Nick Saban is still the head coach, the committee's obsession with the Alabama Crimson Tide has now stretched on for multiple seasons. And it's Alabama, yet again, that obliterated whatever shreds of credibility they had left.

HERE'S HOW BAD THE COLLEGE FOOTBALL PLAYOFF'S SELECTION COMMITTEE RANKINGS ACTUALLY ARE

All five of the Tide's five wins in the SEC lost in the last week, several in humiliating fashion. Four of them lost at home.

  • Kentucky, lost 21-14 at home to Florida
  • Mississippi State, lost 41-9 at home to Auburn
  • LSU, lost 22-21 at home to Texas
  • South Carolina, lost 34-6 at Arkansas
  • Texas A&M, lost 22-7 at home to Tennessee

Kentucky has now lost two games in a row. Mississippi State is under .500 and arguably one of the worst defensive teams in the country. LSU is now 3-4 in the SEC. South Carolina got blown out by an atrociously bad Arkansas team, and Texas A&M ranks 13 spots behind North Dakota State in the latest SP+ ratings. There is no question, no debate, that Alabama's resume looks worse now than it did last week.

Perfect time for the committee to drop them and maintain that intellectual consistency, right? Wrong.

Alabama, despite playing an awful football game against a bad Vanderbilt team, stayed put at No. 3, while Indiana moved up just one spot after beating the No. 18 team in the country, USC. It's enough to make you tear your hair out. When asked about it by ESPN's Rece Davis in the post-release interview, Yurachek gave one of the most ridiculous answers he’s trotted out yet.

"Alabama faced a similar circumstance where five of their SEC opponents all lost, but it didn't have the same impact on their strength of schedule that it had on Indiana's strength of schedule," he said. "Actually, it is very minimal for Alabama because of the quality and the strength of schedule of those five teams that lost."

WHAT. What? WHAT ARE WE DOING HERE?!

This is insane. Why did it not have the same impact? Why did it not have any impact? South Carolina getting obliterated by a very bad Arkansas team didn't matter to Bama's resume? A&M falling to 1-6 in the SEC and in a tie for dead last didn't have any impact on their strength of schedule? Is Mississippi State going to be treated as a patented Impressive SEC Quality win forever because their quarterback got hurt? No consideration to the fact that the Bulldogs have given up an average of 35 points per game as they've lost five straight? That doesn't matter? Does it matter that Kentucky lost again, that their offense has scored just 20 combined points in two weeks? Doesn't impact the strength of the schedule, even though Indiana's offense does?

Then there's how they played on the field. The Tide looked awful against a Vanderbilt team that's 1-6 in conference, needing a gift penalty to take a 7-3 lead into halftime. They averaged 3.5 yards per play outside of three big plays. Somehow, Yurachek and the incompetent committee gave them credit for that too.

"Alabama went on the road, didn't play their best, especially on the offensive side of the ball, but found a way to win 21-6 at Vanderbilt," he said. "And we've seen throughout this college football season, after a big win like Alabama had at LSU, a team let down and lose those games. Credit to Alabama, not playing their best in Nashville on Saturday, but finding a way to win."

That is indefensible. It's insulting. It's offensive. It's enough to shut the whole thing down.

And we're not done there!

CLICK HERE FOR MORE OUTKICK SPORTS COVERAGE

Quarterback Keelon Russell #12 of the Alabama Crimson Tide

Quarterback Keelon Russell #12 of the Alabama Crimson Tide celebrates a touchdown against the East Carolina Pirates during the first half of a game at Bryant Denny Stadium on September 5, 2026 in Tuscaloosa, Alabama. (Photo by Butch Dill/Getty Images) (Butch Dill/Getty Images)

The committee ranked four teams with four losses in this week's top 25. You'll never guess which conference they all came from. It rhymes with SEC. No other conference received that treatment with a 6-4 team, even Illinois, which won four in a row, including a win over now-No. 13 Oregon, then lost to the undefeated No. 4 team in the country on the road by one score.

When the No. 1 Miami Hurricanes lost to a top-10 Notre Dame team by one possession, on the road, without their best player, in a game that came down to a contentious incomplete pass call, the committee dropped them six spots.

South Carolina? Well, they only fell four spots after losing by 28 points to Arkansas. Why? Because they're in the SEC. Which means they're good, 'cause they're in the SEC. Which means they must be ranked, 'cause they're in the SEC. Which means the SEC will have ranked wins, 'cause it's the SEC and all the teams are good, cause they're ranked. 'Cause they're in the SEC.

SIGN UP FOR THE DAILY OUTKICK NEWSLETTER

That's how it works. That's the level of "reasoning" and evaluation and analysis we're dealing with here. Losses don't matter in the SEC, just because. Wins matter, but losses don't. Unbelievable.

OUTKICK IS NOW AVAILABLE ON THE FOX NEWS APP: CLICK HERE TO DOWNLOAD

SEC Commissioner Greg Sankey speaks to reporters at a press event.

SEC Commissioner Greg Sankey speaks to the press during SEC Football Kickoff Media Day at the Tampa Marriott in Tampa, Fla., on July 20, 2026. (Nathan Ray Seebeck-Imagn Images)

Why is Texas behind Alabama? Why is Indiana No. 8 when their one loss was to a top 2-3 team with their star quarterback healthy? The exact thing Alabama is rewarded for with Mississippi State? Why is an undefeated Big Ten team behind a two-loss SEC team that saw its strength of schedule take a nosedive? USC lost and didn't move, bizarrely, apparently because the committee couldn't find a three-loss SEC team to take their spot. What does Wake Forest have to do to be taken seriously?

THE CRAIG CARTON SHOW–UNFILTERED, UNAPOLOGETIC AND UNMISSABLE. DOWNLOAD HIS DAILY PODCAST NOW!

It's like, as Joel Klatt said, we need to "take the crayons away" from the committee, because they're not even trying anymore. Every week is just a clinic of circular reasoning leading to their preferred outcomes; the SEC gets rewarded for existing, and results don't matter.

They had a chance to show they were a serious group of people taking this process seriously. Instead, Yurachek made up a bunch of nonsense, then rattled off some absurdities about Alabama's margin of victory in SEC wins, as if that matters. Crayons might be too generous, this group may not even know how to read and write at all.

View the original on Fox News →

KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.