Adiong: Defense reeks of desperation in citing dead personalities


MANILA, Philippines — The decision of Vice President Sara Duterte’s lawyers to cite deceased individuals to support their arguments reeks of desperation, according to Lanao del Sur Rep. Zia Alonto Adiong, who added that the move signals that the defense’s arguments are also nearing their death.
During a press briefing on Thursday, held during a break in the impeachment proceedings, Adiong questioned whether the defense’s use of video clips of former Senator Miriam Defensor-Santiago and former Chief Justice Renato Corona showed desperation and a lack of witnesses who could explain the allegations against Duterte.
READ: Late Sen. Santiago’s remarks played in VP Duterte impeachment trial
Article continues after this advertisement
The lawmaker, who serves as spokesperson for the prosecution panel, urged the defense to let the dead rest.
FEATURED STORIES
NEWSINFO
NEWSINFO
NEWSINFO
“Hindi na ho natin sila ma-cross examine, hindi ho natin sila mapatawag dahil namayapa na nga po sila. So ‘yon na nga po, why can’t we not rest these people who have already rested for a long time, and then (not) drag them just because you want to serve the very purpose by which the defense could not give evidence to clearly refute the allegation of the prosecution?” Alonto Adiong asked.
(We can no longer cross-examine them; we cannot call them because they have passed away. So that’s it, why can’t we not rest these people who have already rested for a long time, and then (not) drag them just because you want to serve the very purpose by which the defense could not give evidence to clearly refute the allegation of the prosecution?)
“Gano’n ba talaga ngayon sila ka-desperado? Mukhang desperado na sila, pati ‘yong patay eh pinapasalita pa nila,” he added.
(Are they that desperate? They seem to be desperate, they are letting even the dead talk.)
Article continues after this advertisement
Alonto Adiong said they believe it is unethical to drag both Defensor-Santiago and Corona as the clips that the defense showed were in relation to Corona’s impeachment trial, which does not involve the current topic — Duterte’s own trial.
“It is also an ethical question; to us, it is unethical to present video clips of those who have already departed, and their supposed statements have nothing to do with the current impeachment trial of Vice President Sara Duterte,” he said.
Article continues after this advertisement
“No’ng nakaraang araw po, ang nai-presenta po nila ay mga hindi alam, mga sagot, hindi maalala, I prefer not to answer that question. So nakita po natin ng weakness ng depensa […] Now that they have presented na mga namayapa pong tao, I think this also speaks about, patay na po ang kaso ng depensa,” he added.
(During the past few days, they presented witnesses who do not know the answer, or those who responded by saying that they cannot remember things, or that they prefer not to answer that question. So we saw the ‘weakness’ of the defense […] Now that they have presented dead people, I think this also speaks about the death of the defense’s case.)
During the trial, defense counsel Mark Vinluan presented remarks from late Senator Miriam Defensor-Santiago during the Corona impeachment trial, particularly her criticism of the prosecution team who decided to withdraw several articles of impeachment.
However, Vinluan was also questioned by senators-judge, particularly Senators Erwin Tulfo and Panfilo Lacson, as to the relevance of the late former senator’s statements to Duterte’s trial.
Senator Erwin Tulfo, in particular, urged the defense to let the departed rest. Senate Impeachment Court Presiding Officer Escudero then said he agrees with the observations of Tulfo and Lacson.
After this, Vinluan also showed clips of Corona complaining about the treatment he and his family received just to remove him from his post—claiming they had been harassed by different government offices probing his alleged ill-gotten wealth.
As the prosecution questioned the relevance of these clips to the case, Senator-judge Raffy Tulfo and Escudero reminded the defense that Corona was convicted after his 2012 trial, despite his grievances.
READ: Tulfo, Escudero remind defense on showing Corona video: He was convicted
Corona passed away in April 2016 due to cardiac arrest — four years after his conviction and removal from office. Defensor-Santiago, meanwhile, died in September 2016, after years of battle with lung cancer.
READ: Former SC Chief Justice Corona dies; he was 67
After the defense panel presented seven witnesses since November 9, different members of the prosecution have been adamant that these testimonies and arguments have failed to counter the evidence showing that Duterte allegedly has unexplained wealth and that she failed to disclose these in her SALN.
Alonto Adiong previously said that the allegations raised under Article II have not been disputed — adding that in some ways, the testimonies of defense witnesses even bolstered the prosecutors’ arguments.
Then last Friday, lead public prosecutor and Batangas Rep. Gerville Luistro said Duterte’s yearning for a bloodbath in her impeachment trial came true, but not in the way she wanted.
Your subscription could not be saved. Please try again.
Your subscription has been successful.
Instead, Luistro said that the bloodbath happened within Duterte’s camp, or the defense panel, as the testimony of their witnesses favored the prosecution. /jpv
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.