Insurer can’t escape liability over dead policyholder, appeals court rules

An insurance company cannot avoid liability to an innocent road accident victim merely because the registered policyholder died before the motor insurance policy was renewed, the Court of Appeal has ruled.
In a unanimous decision delivered by Justice Leonard David Shim, with Justices Zaini Mazlan and Aliza Sulaiman on the panel, the court dismissed Liberty Insurance Bhd’s appeal against a High Court ruling refusing to declare its compulsory third-party motor insurance policy void.
The case arose from an accident on Feb 22, 2023, involving a lorry insured in the name of Koay Kuan Liong, who died in July 2018.
The lorry, driven by his son Koay Ghee Seong, collided with a motorcycle ridden by Munir A Hasan, who suffered serious injuries and was paralysed from the waist down.
Liberty sought to invalidate the policy on grounds of non-disclosure of the policyholder’s death, breach of utmost good faith, lack of contractual capacity and absence of insurable interest.
However, the court held that such contractual issues could not defeat an innocent third party’s statutory right under the Road Transport Act 1987.
“The mere fact that the registered owner has died and the policy continued in his name did not, without more, render the compulsory third-party insurance unenforceable against the innocent third party,” Shim said in his grounds of judgment dated Oct 29.
The court also relied on Section 101(2) of the Act, which provides that a policy remains in force and available to third parties notwithstanding the death of an insured person.
Shim said the third party’s statutory rights to compensation could not be defeated by contractual requirements.
The court also found that Liberty failed to make proper enquiries when renewing the policy. The proposal form was unsigned and incomplete, but the insurer accepted the premium and issued the policy.
It agreed that the insurer was deemed to have waived compliance with the duty of disclosure under Schedule 9 of the Financial Services Act 2013.
“The statutory rights of the third party to recover compensation from the insurer under Section 96(1) of the Road Transport Act 1987 are not defeated by contractual obligations or requirements such as utmost good faith, non-disclosure, no capacity to contract and insurable interest,” Shim said.
The court dismissed the appeal and ordered Liberty to pay Munir RM40,000 in costs.
Razlan Hadri Zulkifli and Ahmad Naqiuddin Ramli appeared for Liberty, while S Parameswaran and G Thinagara Pothuval represented Ghee Seong, the administrator of his father’s estate, and Munir.
Subscribe to our newsletter and get news delivered to your mailbox.
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.