The Jerusalem PostBritain sanctions Israeli settlement firms in push to protect two-state solutionInquirerEx-UPLB school paper editors condemn student journalists’ arrestSky TG24Gerico, coloni aprono il fuoco: un morto e diversi feritiStraits Times SportDeChambeau to join DP World Tour after LIV collapseZDF heuteEntdecken Sie das ZDF-NachrichtenstudioRapplerLIVE UPDATES: 49th ASEAN Summit in Manila7sur7Pourquoi Robert Pattinson est sans doute le meilleur choix pour incarner James Bond (malgré les critiques)Capital FMStanChart funds receive five-star Morningstar ratingsRTL BoulevardPaus krijgt rozenkrans in zijn gezicht, maar reageert met humorThe South AfricanEllen DeGeneres weighs in on Cape Town’s baboon relocation war (watch)Rai NewsATP Finals, stasera in campo il nuovo numero 1 Zverev contro SheltonSBS 뉴스이 대통령 "부정행위는 중대범죄…수능 신뢰 절대 흔들려선 안돼"
The Daily Newsstand · Free, Always
Tuesday, November 17, 2026

India must stop treating Rohit and Kohli as a package deal

Translate
Despite often being bunched together, Rohit Sharma (left) and Virat Kohli (right) find themselves in different positions heading into the 2027 ODI World Cup.

Despite often being bunched together, Rohit Sharma (left) and Virat Kohli (right) find themselves in different positions heading into the 2027 ODI World Cup. | Photo Credit: (L-R) CREIMAS for BCCI, AP

infoIcon

Despite often being bunched together, Rohit Sharma (left) and Virat Kohli (right) find themselves in different positions heading into the 2027 ODI World Cup. | Photo Credit: (L-R) CREIMAS for BCCI, AP

There is a peculiar situation unfolding in Indian cricket as it begins to look towards the 2027 ODI World Cup. Virat Kohli and Rohit Sharma, two of its most accomplished batters, have already stepped away from Test and T20I cricket. Their international future is now tied entirely to one format and, more specifically, to one tournament.

Rohit will turn 40 before the World Cup begins in October 2027, while Kohli will be 38. BCCI president Mithun Manhas has said selection should be determined by fitness and performance rather than age, and has pointed to the value of having senior players such as Rohit, Kohli and Hardik Pandya around Shubman Gill. It is a persuasive argument. Moving away from both would cost India not just runs but the knowledge accumulated over years of high-pressure international cricket. A young captain could benefit from having players who understand the demands of an ICC tournament.

The question is whether that experience is worth the space it occupies.

Kohli and Rohit offer different things. Kohli remains the archetypal ODI accumulator, capable of controlling tempo, building partnerships and managing a chase, and his presence at No. 3 gives the order a stability that is difficult to manufacture. Rohit is a more disruptive force at the top, and his ability to take on the new ball and dictate the PowerPlay has been central to India’s ODI approach in recent years. In fact, it was the cornerstone of the team’s dream run to the final of the 2023 World Cup at home.

Rohit’s numbers in 2026 are more complicated than his recent struggles suggest. Against opponents other than New Zealand, he has scored 543 runs in nine innings at an average of 60.33, with two centuries and two half-centuries. Against New Zealand, he has managed just 91 runs in seven innings — four away from home — at an average of 13, with 23 his highest score. In the series that just ended, he averaged 7.5, his lowest in a bilateral series of at least four innings since 2012, when he managed 2.5 against Sri Lanka. The disparity suggests a vulnerability against a particular kind of opposition in a particular set of conditions.

One poor series should not, in isolation, diminish what Rohit has achieved over the past year. Since the end of the 2025 Champions Trophy, he has scored 982 runs at an average of 46.76. But there is another way of looking at his contribution. Between the 2023 World Cup and the last Champions Trophy, Rohit struck at 133.68 in the first 10 overs of ODIs, giving India an attacking advantage few openers could match. That ability to combine aggression with consistency was central to his value at the top. The question is whether he can still provide that kind of start, particularly against quality new-ball bowling on surfaces that offer seam movement.

That said, even Kohli was not spared in New Zealand. His 86 was the highest aggregate by an Indian batter in the series, yet it came at an average of 21.5, his second-lowest in a bilateral series of at least four innings, behind only the 18 against England in 2014. Both slumps may be nothing more than form, but they do not carry the same weight. Kohli, who last played an ODI in South Africa in 2022, averages close to 75 there, with three centuries and five half-centuries.

Rohit, who missed that tour with a hamstring injury, last played an ODI there in 2018 and averages below 20 with a single century. Should he make the squad, he will be playing ODI cricket there after eight years or more, and the challenge will be to show that his attacking game can deliver in conditions that have rarely rewarded him.

ALSO READ: Why Suryakumar Yadav, not Rohit Sharma, is the right choice for Mumbai Indians captaincy in IPL 2027

The New Zealand series also offered some clues about why the two have struggled, though for different reasons. Rohit appeared uncomfortable against the in-between length, often caught between committing forward and moving back. Against bowlers such as Kyle Jamieson and Matt Henry, the combination of bounce and movement exposed the uncertainty in his initial footwork. His problem was not simply the pace of the bowling but the difficulty of getting into position to play it.

Kohli’s dismissals pointed to a different concern. He was repeatedly drawn into playing at deliveries outside off stump, sometimes before he had spent enough time at the crease to judge the conditions. His dismissal to Matthew Fisher in the final ODI, reaching for a short delivery outside off and edging behind, was a familiar sight. New Zealand exposed two different vulnerabilities, but neither series should be treated as a definitive verdict on what they might produce in South Africa.

Their cases, therefore, need to be judged independently. Kohli’s role at No. 3 is different, though it does not insulate him from the new-ball examination if an opener falls early. His ability to absorb pressure, rebuild an innings and control a chase, combined with his excellent record in South Africa, gives India a stronger basis to persist with him.

Rohit’s value is more closely tied to his ability to dominate the PowerPlay. If that advantage is no longer as pronounced, and his record in South Africa offers little reassurance, India has a more difficult question to answer about its opening combination. If Kohli keeps producing runs and Rohit struggles against the new ball, India should not feel compelled to keep both for the sake of continuity. Equally, if Rohit rediscovers consistency and continues to provide the kind of starts few openers can replicate, his age should not count against him.

Yet the verdict cannot be left to the last moment, because India’s succession planning is already complicated. Yashasvi Jaiswal is an obvious candidate to open, but he has not been given a sustained run in the ODI side. Since making his debut in February 2025, he has played only six matches and scored 285 runs, including two hundreds. Persisting with Rohit offers continuity, but it also postpones the chance to test whether a younger opener can do the job.

The schedule does little to ease that. Having just finished a five-match series in New Zealand, India hosts Sri Lanka for three matches in December, then Zimbabwe in January. A five-Test series against Australia follows before the IPL, and a 50-over Asia Cup in Bangladesh, proposed for June 18 to July 4, could offer another block of ODI cricket.

There is also a tour of West Indies in July, with a six-match series in South Africa also being reported, though it is yet to be officially confirmed. New Zealand has offered valuable overseas exposure, but it is no substitute for the pace, bounce and new-ball behaviour of South Africa. Runs at home or in Bangladesh won’t tell India everything it needs to know, particularly about Rohit. If the South Africa series goes ahead, it could be India’s most important assignment before the tournament.

That presents a timing dilemma. Seeing Rohit and Kohli at another World Cup is an appealing prospect, given what they have contributed. But the uncomfortable truth is that India’s options may already be narrowing. With less than a year to go and few matches that resemble South African conditions, the window to blood a new opener, and to see him tested against the new ball in the right conditions, is closing fast. Backing Rohit is no longer just a question of loyalty or form. It may be the only gamble India still has time to take.

Published on Nov 17, 2026

Latest on Sportstar

  1. Live Blog 2026-11-17T14:33:06+05:30

    Singapore vs Brazil LIVE Score: Real-time updates from the SGP v BRA friendly; Brazil 7 - 0 Singapore; Vinicius hat-trick;
  2. Pakistan was informed 7 months in advance about India hosting Asian Champions Trophy, says FIH chief
  3. Live Blog 2026-11-17T15:46:13+05:30

    IPL 2027 रिटेंशन लिस्ट LIVE अपडेट्स: धोनी ने संन्यास लिया; शमी और कुरेन डेडलाइन के आखिरी दिन हुए बड़े ट्रेड का हिस्सा बने; जल्द ही और घोषणाएं होंगी
View the original on Sportstar →

KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.