Bashing the childless is unworthy
On Tuesday last week, musician Lo Ta-yu (羅大佑) gave a radio interview in which he not only criticized President William Lai (賴清德) and Premier Cho Jung-tai (卓榮泰), but said that former president Tsai Ing-wen’s (蔡英文), Vice President Hsiao Bi-khim’s (蕭美琴) and former Kaohsiung mayor Chen Chu’s (陳菊) lack of children suggested they did not care about the next generation.
Controversy ensued, particularly following Taipei Mayor Chiang Wan-an’s (蔣萬安) response to reporters’ questions the next day, in which he described Lo’s comments as “enlightening” and “a wake-up call,” praising Lo’s integrity as a cultural figure.
Of course, it cannot be said from this alone that Chiang agreed with everything Lo had to say. Chiang was primarily responding to questions about Lo’s criticism of Lai and Cho. Nevertheless, a debate about attitudes toward having children was sparked, and Chiang’s emphatic endorsements makes it necessary for him to clarify which of Lo’s points he actually agrees with. Criticizing those in power is a fundamental right in any democratic society. Is suggesting that whether female politicians have children is a measure of their sense of public responsibility praiseworthy, or is it an outdated way of thinking?
Whether politicians care about the next generation should be judged by their records in areas such as education policy, social welfare, environmental protection, fiscal sustainability and national security.
By Lo’s logic, are we to believe that people without children cannot care about Taiwan’s future? Are unmarried people, or those who are otherwise unable to or choose not to have children somehow less concerned with their public responsibilities? This is not just a shaky line of reasoning; it risks turning female politicians’ personal family choices into political ammunition.
Tsai, Hsiao and Chen’s political positions, policy decisions and governance records are all open to public scrutiny, but whether they have children has no bearing on their public service work. Political commentary should be based on evidence and policy, and someone’s personal family circumstances should not be turned into a moral judgement. We must be particularly vigilant when these remarks are directed primarily at female politicians, which feeds into stereotypical expectations about the role of women as childbearers.
So, what position should Chiang take on such a controversy? The mayor of Taipei is responsible not only for urban development, but for promoting gender equality, supporting families and implementing policies that reflect the needs of a diverse society.
Taipei residents come from a wide range of family backgrounds: some are married with children; some live alone; and others choose not to have children at all.
The government should protect people’s freedom to make different life choices, and not build up public values around one particular family model. If Chiang wishes to praise Lo’s interview comments so highly, he should be precise about what exactly he is endorsing.
Lo’s music career deserves respect, and he is entitled to express his views on politics. However, artistic achievement and the soundness of political arguments are two separate matters. Chiang has every right to praise Lo’s criticism of the government, but he should avoid giving the impression that he supports linking family choices with public responsibility in political disputes. Taiwanese society should be long past judging a person’s public worth by their marital status or family structure. Female politicians should not be made to defend themselves on caring about the next generation simply because they have no children; this is something that is instead demonstrated through concrete policies and achievements in governance.
If public debate is to be genuinely “enlightening,” it must return to questions of policy, facts and public responsibility, rather than dress up antiquated ideas in the language of cultural integrity.
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.