PunchPHOTOS: Tinubu grants interview to American political strategist Diana LondonThe Jerusalem PostDemocrat Peltola wins in Alaska, securing 56-44 US Senate majorityInquirerBaguio firefighters contain diesel spill after vehicle collision한겨레미·중·러 회담 앞두고, 우크라 ‘푸틴의 다리’ 끊어…“그 다리는 이제 끝났다”ZDF heuteAktuelle Pressemitteilungen des ZDFRapplerLIVE UPDATES: 49th ASEAN Summit in ManilaSözcüValizini alana kapısını açan 10 ülke: Biri Türkiye'nin yanı başındaDW EnglishAPEC summit: What Trump, Xi and Putin wantESPN CricinfoCA sets up 'independent forum' into Sandpapergate but will not re-litigate the incidentWirtualna PolskaBurza po wecie prezydenta. Pierwsza dama stawia sprawę jasno7sur7La petite Inass, retrouvée morte au bord d’une autoroute il y a 39 ans: les parents lourdement condamnésInteriaJoe Biden z podziwem o Polsce w nowej książce. Ujawnił kulisy tajnej wizyty
The Daily Newsstand · Free, Always
Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Guan Eng slams Chow, Zairil over RM210mil annual payment to Perak

Translate

DAP adviser Lim Guan Eng has slammed the Penang government over the state water company’s agreement to pay Perak RM210 million annually for 40 years, even if no treated water is supplied to Penang.

Lim accused Penang chief minister Chow Kon Yeow and state executive councillor Zairil Khir Johari of failing to explain the rationale behind this condition.

The Bagan MP said the arrangement was exposed by five independent directors of PBA Holdings Bhd (PBAH) during an extraordinary general meeting on Nov 12.

The five dissenting directors were Brian Tan, Lim Eng Huat, Nor Hatina Salleh, Lim Seang Lee and Raja Azmi Raja Nazuddin.

Lim said they objected to the Penang Water Supply Corporation’s (PBAPP) proposed purchase of treated water from Perak under the Northern Perak Water Supply Scheme.

“Chow and Zairil have disappointed the people of Penang by refusing to explain why PBAPP must still pay RM210 million annually for 40 years, or a total of RM8.4 billion, to Perak even if not a single drop of treated water is supplied to Penang.

“The five directors were concerned that PBAPP would remain liable for the annual capacity charges even if it received less than the contracted 300 million litres of treated water or, in the worst-case scenario, none at all,” he said in a statement.

Lim said the agreement, which is scheduled to take effect on March 31, 2032, would commit PBAPP to paying Perak at least RM24.6 billion over 40 years.

This comprises RM8.4 billion in fixed capacity charges and RM16.2 billion in supply charges.

He said the supply charges could increase as the initial tariff of RM1.70 per cubic metre was subject to upward revisions over the 40-year period, eventually reaching RM7.21 per cubic metre.

“The tariff charged to consumers could rise by another RM1 per cubic metre to account for other costs incurred by PBAPP.”

Lim said the tariff could exceed RM7.21 per cubic metre following a contractual review after 22 years.

While questioning the price of treated water purchased from Perak, Lim said the more pressing concern was the mandatory capacity payment, which PBAPP would have to make regardless of whether it received any water.

He described the arrangement as unequal and potentially undermining public confidence in the state government’s handling of the agreement.

Subscribe to our newsletter and get news delivered to your mailbox.

View the original on Free Malaysia Today →

KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.