The Jerusalem Post‘A Talent for Murder’ is faithful to the spirit of Patricia Highsmith’s Ripley novels - reviewInquirerVillage official from Eastern Samar arrested in a buy-bust operationDaily MaverickPRINCES OF DARKNESS: Russell’s Branding — super-spread by the algorithm, taken down by the algorithmZDF heuteAktuelle Pressemitteilungen des ZDFSCMP ChinaSqueezed in the US, China’s CATL bets on Argentina’s battery storage boomMexico News DailyIn China, Mexico’s environment minister takes notes on its waste-to-energy circular economyABC News (Australia)Schools 'devastated' after education department ends VCE registrationNU.nlOranje wordt vernederd door Duitsland met grootste nederlaag in 67 jaarBBC Mundo5 países de la Unión Europea anuncian la creación de un centro de deportación de migrantes en RuandaNOS SportDuitsland zet Oranje met 5-0 hardhandig terug op aarde, grootste nederlaag sinds 1959Straits Times SportTop doubles player Patten criticises ATP chairman, CEO for absence from trophy presentationESPNWhat is wrong with the Chargers' offense this season? Assessing five major factors
The Daily Newsstand · Free, Always
Monday, November 16, 2026

Luxury apartment owners fight Brisbane council over noisy aircon

Translate

Luxury apartment owners in Brisbane's Fish Lane have taken Brisbane City Council to the Queensland Ombudsman over an excessively noisy air conditioner next door.

612 ABC has obtained council noise assessment documents showing the rooftop air-conditioning system at Melbourne Residences exceeded legal noise limits.

The documents show noise on the balcony exceeded the legal limit by 7 decibels, while indoors, with the door open, it exceeded it by 10 decibels.

The 10-decibel exceedence means the air conditioner produced 10 times the maximum limit laid out in the Queensland Environment Protection Act.

Apartment owners next door at Croft on Fish Lane lodged the complaint.

However, the council told complainants via email that it did not intend to enforce the noise regulations.

Documents on a table

Council documents show the air conditioner was non-compliant with Queensland's Environmental Protection Act. (612 ABC Brisbane: Kenji Sato)

"Please note that Council has discretion whether to act on non-compliant findings, after weighing up all relevant features," the email read.

"It is my opinion that using the Act to take enforcement is in direct conflict with the DA conditioned expectations for your building and is not a reasonable application of Council resources."

The council told residents they could keep their doors shut, which would reduce noise to below the maximum noise thresholds.

Neighbours lose their cool

Croft on Fish Lane resident Jarrad Wilson said neighbours were outraged by the council's response.

"We live in Queensland, there's a level of expectations you should be allowed to enjoy the outdoors,"

Mr Wilson said.

"We have some of the best weather in the world and the fact we're told we have to live inside with the doors shut, I don't think is an acceptable position."

The developer of the Melbourne Residences, Aria Property, did not respond to 612 ABC's requests for comment.

However, in an email, the developer told complainants that if the air conditioner was too noisy, they could sell up and move.

The developer told complainants that if they did not like the sound of rooftop air conditioners, they should not have moved next to one.

"If you had been provided with the view shots for your 'off the plan unit' at your floor level, you would have clearly known you would be overlooking the roof/plant of the building, and still decided to purchase," the email said.

"If the developer did not provide you with this information, that is something that you should raise with them.

"If you purchased off the plan 3+ years ago, I am sure your property has appreciated significantly."

A rooftop air conditioner

Melbourne Residences uses a rooftop HVAC system to cool and ventilate its building. (612 ABC Brisbane: Kenji Sato)

A Brisbane City Council spokesperson said they conducted an independent review, which ruled that enforcement action was not necessary.

"The independent review also found the noise measurements met expectations that apply to the Fish Lane apartments," the spokesperson said.

"Questions regarding the noise mitigation measures of the respective buildings should be directed towards the developers."

In a letter to complainants yesterday, the ombudsman's office said investigations were ongoing.

However, it said that under Queensland law, councils were not legally required to enforce noise laws even if they were being violated.

It said councils had full discretion over whether or not to act on noise law breaches.

"The [Environmental Protection] Act does not state that a local council must enforce compliance in individual cases," the letter said.

"Instead, the legislation grants councils the legal power and general function to administer noise rules while leaving specific enforcement decisions entirely to their discretion."

The ombudsman said it would provide a full response once investigations were finished.

View the original on ABC News (Australia) →

KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.