The Jerusalem PostSaudi Arabia says it intercepts three Houthi missiles targeting RiyadhInquirerAnti-narcotics agents nab 2 suspects, seize P4M in meth in Lanao del SurPunchMega churches face succession heat한겨레4년 만의 대중 무역흑자의 역설…반도체 빼면 적자 더 늘어ZDF heuteAktuelle Pressemitteilungen des ZDFCNN Türkİran'dan ABD’ye Irak hatırlatmasıThe Hollywood ReporterUnder Pressure From Struggling Members, SAG-AFTRA Vows to Advocate for Universal Healthcare매일경제170만명 홀린 ‘부캉이’ 이름값이 얼마길래…상표 출원 21건NU.nlVerstappen bijna in bandenstapel na incident met Russell in derde training VegasDeadline‘Yellowjackets’ Stars Melanie Lynskey & Christina Ricci On Misty’s Plot “To Save Themselves” From Shauna: “She’ll Be The Downfall Of Everybody”New Straits Times#SHOWBIZ: Adam Driver, Scarlett Johansson star in New York family crime drama 'Paper Tiger'The Sydney Morning Herald'Unnecessary': F1 rivals tangle in practice
The Daily Newsstand · Free, Always
Saturday, November 21, 2026

Sydney woman loses court fight over 3cm carport encroachment after its removal

Translate

Sydney woman took her neighbours to court over three structures encroaching on her land, including a carport post crossing the boundary by just 3cm; the Supreme Court dismissed her case after the structures were removed

PC: AI Generated

A Sydney woman took her neighbours to the Supreme Court of New South Wales over structures that extended onto her property, including a carport post that crossed the boundary by just 3 cm.

The dispute involved adjoining homes in Lane Cove North and also covered a carport gutter and a garage eave and gutter, each found to encroach by about 13 cm.According to a judgment published by the Supreme Court of New South Wales, the neighbours accepted a boundary determination and agreed to remove the structures before the proceedings began. The work took longer than the woman wanted and involved several surveys and further repairs.

The court later dismissed her summons and ordered each side to pay its own legal costs.

Sydney woman discovered three carport and garage encroachments on her land

The structures had been in place since 1984. The dispute began after the woman engaged C&A Surveyors in June 2022 to survey the shared boundary before building a new dividing fence between the two neighbouring homes.The survey identified the encroachments and recommended a redefinition survey. The neighbours obtained their own survey in November 2023, which they said showed no encroachment.

After correspondence between the parties, the woman applied for a formal boundary determination in August 2024.The Registrar-General issued the determination on 12 February 2025. It identified three encroachments: the neighbours’ garage eave and gutter extended approximately 13cm onto her land, the carport gutter crossed the boundary by about 13cm, and a carport post extended 3cm onto her property.

Why did the carport and garage removal work take longer than expected

The neighbours accepted the boundary determination and said they would remove the encroachments.

In March 2025, the woman asked them to complete the work within 14 days. One neighbour replied that he was overseas and that removal would take place as soon as possible after his return.A plumber removed the carport gutter and downpipe in early April, but other work remained. The neighbour explained that roofing had to be removed and the buildings’ integrity considered.He said a licensed builder had been consulted and engaged, but the remaining work could not be completed until the end of May 2025 because of the builder’s workload and the woman’s request for a check survey.The remaining structures were not removed by then, and the neighbour later said he was waiting for contractors to become available in the area for the remaining repairs.

Incorrect carport post work led to further proceedings

Finn Hawkins attended the property on 25 June 2025 to work on the carport posts but altered the wrong post. The woman began court proceedings in the Supreme Court on 7 July, seeking removal of the remaining structures as well as other orders concerning alleged trespass, entry onto her land and interference with survey marks.Those additional allegations were not adjudicated. Further work followed in September and October 2025 after the neighbours obtained another survey. That survey recorded no remaining encroachments, but the woman commissioned an independent inspection.A report in November identified some encroachments measuring between 1cm and 3cm. The neighbours arranged more work in March 2026 and again in May after a further inspection found one remaining encroachment.

The court dismissed the case and ordered both sides to pay costs

A joint inspection on 28 May 2026 was followed by a report confirming that the remaining encroaching structure had been removed.The substantive dispute was recorded as resolved on 17 July, leaving the question of legal costs for the court. The woman sought $56,649.37, including aggravated damages, or payment of her legal costs.

The neighbours offered $20,000 in exchange for her discontinuing the proceedings, but neither offer was accepted.Justice Pike found that the neighbours had accepted the boundary determination and had consistently intended to remove the structures. Although the work took longer than the woman wanted, the judge found no unreasonable conduct or capitulation. The summons was formally dismissed, with each side paying its own costs.Disclaimer: This article is based on the judgment by the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The Times of India has not independently verified the details of the property dispute, the claims made by either party, or the events described in the court proceedings.

View the original on Times of India →

KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.