Rugby brain injury lawsuits on brink of collapse over medical documents delay

After six years of interminable and expensive legal argument, the two lawsuits involving hundreds of brain-damaged rugby players appear to be on the brink of collapsing.
The lead counsel representing the players, Paul Downes KC, had conceded in June that the claimants were in the “last-chance saloon” after repeatedly missing court-mandated deadlines for the disclosure of documents to the defendants. Having done so again this October, they now appear to be somewhere out beyond it.
As the legal team representing World Rugby, the Rugby Football Union and the Welsh Rugby Union have argued, “there is no watering hole” in sight. The latest set of court hearings were supposed to mark a watershed in the case’s progression towards a trial beginning next October.
The sides were due to submit their shortlists of potential test cases to stand trial, but the defendants have argued that they are unable to complete the process because they still have not received the necessary medical documents from the claimants’ legal team, despite a series of court orders obliging the claimants to disclose them.
Instead, the hearings have been taken over by an argument over whether the cases now stand as struck out given the breach of the court orders. The claimants have already been granted relief from this sanction, but their legal team is now arguing that they need another extension until January in order to comply. The future of the case now rests on whether the two judges, Senior Master Cook and Mr Justice Cotter, are minded to give them what they are asking for.
KP Law, which is acting on behalf of the players, only took over the case in June. It had previously been handled by another firm, Rylands Garth, which is no longer involved. Downes has described the case as being in a “shambolic” state when KP Law took it on, and in court on Thursday he described Rylands Garth’s work as an “incredible failure”. KP Law has now provided an additional 2,000 documents relating to the medical testing and argue that “more has been achieved in the last 99 days than in the previous three years”.
In seeking an extension, there are still large gaps. It transpired in court that only 36 of the 385 players in the union case even had letters of diagnosis. “It seems remarkable that anyone has been onboarded without a letter of diagnosis,” said Justice Cotter. Downes also explained that Rylands Garth had no single universal database to show which documents had been provided and which had not, and that the firm had refused to share the files it did have with KP Law until “some sort of exit agreement” was reached. “I assume fees were mentioned.”
after newsletter promotion
Nonetheless Downes argued that the case can be brought back on track. “If it can be saved, it is my submission that it should be saved.”
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.