Fading Beauden Barrett a symbol of rabble All Blacks’ joyless decline | Gerard Meagher

If their punishment last week was to be told in no uncertain terms that they had let the country down, what awaits the All Blacks after this? Public humiliation? Exile? A firing squad at dawn? That New Zealand followed head coach Dave Rennie’s rebuke with their worst Twickenham performance of the professional era and a record defeat by England suggests such criticism monumentally backfired.
Perhaps it is wise to remember it is only a game, Dave. For what made the very best All Blacks sides so impressive was that they always looked like they were having fun. That they would showcase the most mesmerising skills and do so with a smile on their faces took the breath away and added to the allure. This rabble did not look like they were having much fun out there.
With hindsight, it is clear what Rennie was trying to do, but his comments say much about the All Blacks’ problems. As the NRL grows in popularity, rugby union is just not the religion it once was. When Rennie apologises he does so to an increasingly apathetic New Zealand public.
Those of us here at Twickenham 12 months ago wondered if New Zealand’s dismal performance was an aberration. Never before had the All Blacks been so insipid and it was a defeat that cost Scott Robertson his job. This was a good deal worse. If you want to hit the All Blacks where it hurts, you question their ball handling skills. Here, they were shocking, hesitant in possession. Rabbits in headlights.

There are mitigating factors and plenty of them. England were utterly inspired, producing their best performance of the Steve Borthwick era. We are nearing the end of a gruelling season and there is no doubt that Rugby’s Greatest Rivalry was the year’s No1 priority for New Zealand. A colossal series took its toll.
They have half a team, including their talisman Ardie Savea, on the injury list, and at the time of writing, they could still end up winning this competition. If they are to bounce back next weekend, however, they must make marked improvements in the space of a week that were beyond them in the buildup to this defeat.
There is often talk about the aura around the All Blacks and question whether it is slipping. Truth be told, it disappeared long ago. At this stage, let’s avoid too much hyperbole. New Zealand will lick their wounds and regroup. They will welcome their injured cohort back for next year’s Rugby Championship and will be a formidable force at next year’s World Cup. But they do not instil fear like they did a decade ago and have slipped to fifth in the world, their joint-lowest ranking.
Credit must go to England. They came into this match with their tails up and can be a dangerous proposition when that is the case. When they hit their stride under Borthwick they are suffocating and they soon had the All Blacks gasping for air. The All Blacks could not live with their line speed.
The first time New Zealand managed to put the ball through the hands, Will Jordan inexplicably dropped it. In the first half their lineout wasn’t great, in the second, it went to pieces. Damian McKenzie’s place-kicking was dreadful and a lethargy seemed to engulf the fly-half’s teammates. They were combative to the end at the breakdown but physically outgunned, thoroughly outclassed by England’s dazzling backs.
Poor old Beauden Barrett. This was supposed to be his day – a celebration of reaching 150 caps, becoming only the fourth man to do so. He was afforded his own entrance on to the field, knelt down to rub the turf, as is his trademark. The first time he touched the ball was to kick the restart after Henry Slade’s opening try.
after newsletter promotion
Thereafter, he was a bystander for the most part and at the age of 35, next weekend may be the last time he graces the Twickenham turf. This goes down as his 12th match against England, a third defeat and by far the most comprehensive. He made his debut in a 60-0 win over Ireland in 2012, was world player of the year in 2016 and 2017 but his powers are waning.
Barrett reinvented the game when in his pomp but in many ways he is a microcosm of the All Blacks’ decline. The timelines certainly align.
For all that he has lost, his sense of timing is not one of them, however, bursting on to Cam Roigard’s offload to provide a delightfully nostalgic glimpse of his heyday. When Damian McKenzie converted, New Zealand were back to within 12 points with around 25 minutes remaining. Perhaps the most damning thing is that you never sensed that a comeback was realistic. Any belief had been battered out of the All Blacks by that stage. It may take a while to get it back.
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.