Lawyer denies teacher's 17-year-old sexual assault victim was a child
Lawyers for a Hunter Valley teacher who sexually abused a 17-year-old schoolboy have argued she should avoid jail because he was not a child.
In April, Zoe Jade Hodges, 31, pleaded guilty to two counts of having sexual intercourse with a person under her special care.
She is awaiting sentencing in Newcastle District Court by Judge Milko Kumar.
Today during sentencing submissions, defence barrister April Francis asked Judge Kumar to take into account that the student was 17 at the time of offending.
Ms Francis argued against imprisonment, on the basis that the student was not a child.
"It's not a sexual offence against a child — it's an offence of a special care relationship."
Crown prosecutor Emily Winborne rejected the defence argument and said Hodges's actions were a crime and no penalty other than full-time jail would be appropriate.
Former NSW teacher Zoe Jade Hodges pleaded guilty to two child sex offences. (Supplied: Facebook)
"It is the crown's submission that the relationship was inherently one that arose from a power imbalance," Ms Winborne said.
"The power imbalance existed by virtue of the offender's position as a teacher."
The defence said Hodges was best placed to serve a sentence in the community.
Warned about inappropriate behaviour
During submissions, Ms Winborne told the court Hodges was warned about inappropriate behaviour before sexually abusing the student.
Ms Winborne said Hodges offended after being warned by superiors at the school where she once taught.
"The offender was counselled following rumours being spread about her inappropriate relationships with male students,"
the crown prosecutor said.
"The offender was clearly on notice as to the illegality of any relationship."
The offending happened in the Lower Hunter in July and August 2023.
Borderline personality
Defence barrister April Francis tabled a report by expert forensic psychologist Patrick Sheehan that said Hodges met the criteria of borderline personality disorder.
The report said a "personality disturbance" caused Hodges to sexually abuse the schoolboy.
Ms Winborne rejected that, noting she had held down employment and functioned in the community.
Zoe Jade Hodges was charged in December 2023. (Supplied: Facebook)
Mr Sheehan, who has spent 20 years working with convicted sex offenders and assessed Hodges, was cross-examined today.
He said Hodges met at least five of the diagnostic criteria, including impulsivity and fearing abandonment that warranted a diagnosis of borderline personality disorder.
"Some things jumped off the page and her sexual behaviour could be an example of sexual impulsivity of recklessness of risk taking behaviour,"
the psychologist said.
Ms Winborne said the behaviour was a crime and the diagnosis was flawed, noting Hodges had held down jobs and functioned in the community.
The psychologist stood behind his diagnosis, saying Hodges met the criteria with a mindset that she had a need to feel better and was impulsive in her actions.
"Often horribly in work I do, it is often young vulnerable people who meet that need for them," he said.
Zoe Jade Hodges sexually abused the boy in 2023. (Supplied: Facebook)
The crown alleges Hodges exaggerated alleged conditions and the report must be treated with caution as the psychologist had only read the agreed police facts and not viewed her police interview.
The court heard the crown has applied to have Hodges placed on the child protection register.
Judge Kumar adjourned sentencing to next Thursday, to allow for Hodges to get an assessment to determine if she is suitable for a sentence to be served in the community.
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.