Melaka setback shows PH has learnt little from past polls, analysts say [WATCH]

MELAKA: BENEATH Barisan Nasional and Perikatan Nasional's sweeping victory in the Melaka election lies a familiar setback for Pakatan Harapan, which appears to have learnt little from its poor performances in Johor and Negri Sembilan earlier this year.
The Melaka polls reduced PH's representation in the state assembly from five seats to four. DAP retained all four constituencies it contested while PKR and Amanah were wiped out.
DAP held on to Ayer Keroh, Kesidang, Kota Laksamana and Bandar Hilir.
PKR, which fielded 10 candidates, failed to win a single seat. Its losses included two candidates with close ties to PH chairman Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim — his political secretary, Datuk Azman Abidin, in Paya Rumput and Prime Minister's Office officer Farzana Hayani Nasir in Klebang.
Melaka PH chairman Adly Zahari's defeat in Bukit Katil, after two terms as its assemblyman, dealt a blow to Amanah, which failed to win any of the seven seats it contested.
The party's attempt to woo Gen Z voters by fielding its youngest candidate, Muhammad Mukhlisul Mubin Julaisapiyah, in Kuala Linggi, also fell flat. Unlike BN's Datuk Mohd Noor Helmy Abdul Halem, who converted his online popularity into votes to retain Duyong, Mukhlisul lost to Datuk Rosli Abdullah by 4,883 votes.
PH's difficulties were evident throughout the campaign. It struggled with a convincing narrative for voters despite the federal government's achievements.
Its mixed messaging did little to help. While some leaders spoke of wresting control of the state government, others framed the election as an opportunity to increase PH's representation and strengthen its position as the opposition.
The low-key launch of its manifesto, announced at a short notice to the media and without the presence of key leaders, further reflected a campaign that lacked momentum.
Melaka DAP chairman Khoo Poay Tiong, however, was quick to attribute the defeat to identity politics employed by BN and PN.
Political analysts said the results pointed to deeper weaknesses within PH, including its failure to translate electoral lessons from previous state elections into a more effective strategy ahead of the 16th General Election.
Ilham Centre executive director Hisommudin Bakar said PH needed to reassess its position as a governing coalition and develop a more compelling narrative that could capture voters.
He said the results of four state elections in Sabah, Johor, Negri Sembilan and Melaka should provide the basis for the coalition to reorganise itself before the next general election.
"PH has sufficient data at its disposal but needs to translate the findings into strategies to improve its electoral showing."
Hisommudin said PH also needed to broaden its appeal among Malay voters without losing the support of Chinese and Indian communities.
He said young voters were generally more open-minded and less attached to parties, making it difficult to secure their support without building meaningful connections.
"No party in the state election managed to establish a close connection with them that would translate into votes. They are driven by the fear of missing out and tend to follow trends. They are naturally drawn to groups that appear more dominant."
Universiti Malaya senior political science lecturer Dr Mohammad Tawfik Yaakub said PH did not do enough to win over Malay voters.
"PH needs to move beyond defensive political narratives and develop a more convincing approach to address Malay concerns, particularly economic security, employment, education and the interests of the Malay Muslim community within a multiracial society.
"Blaming identity politics alone will not help the coalition win support from Malay voters."
Tawfik said PH had also struggled to present a credible alternative to the BN-PN alliance, adding that Adly's defeat showed that even a strong candidate could not overcome weaknesses in the campaign strategy.
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.