BJP-led state vs BJP-led Centre: Inside Maharashtra’s U-turn on its FSSAI case

The Maharashtra government Saturday withdrew its challenge in the Bombay High Court against the Centre’s food regulator. The Food and Drugs Administration (FDA), which brought the case, did not walk away from it. It was told to.
The petition had set up an unusual contest: a BJP-led state government in court against a BJP-led Centre. It named the Union Health Ministry and the Food Safety and Standards Authority of India (FSSAI), accused the regulator of usurping the state’s powers and asked the High Court to strike down Central regulations. No other state, including those ruled by the Opposition, has mounted such a challenge in recent years.
Letters reviewed by The Indian Express show the FDA went to court only after the Mahayuti government cleared the case in writing and, according to the FDA’s own proposal, after the state’s Advocate General directed that it be filed. Eight weeks later, the same department that gave the go-ahead cancelled it via a three-paragraph letter that records no reason.
On Saturday, the state’s lawyer told a bench of Chief Justice Mahesh Chandra Tripathi and Justice Advait M Sethna that it wanted to withdraw the plea. The bench disposed it as withdrawn, five days before it was to be heard on November 26.
Asked why the petition was withdrawn, state FDA Commissioner Tukaram Mundhe said it was done “as per government directive”.
The paper trail begins on July 28. With Mundhe’s approval, the then Joint Commissioner (Food) Santosh Kamble wrote to the Additional Chief Secretary of the FDA department, seeking permission to file a writ petition. The idea was not the FDA’s alone. Kamble’s letter says Advocate General Milind Sathe, appearing for the state in a similar case brought by a Thane-based NGO, first asked an FDA officer present in court to file a separate petition, and on July 20 directed that the Food Safety Commissioner file it on the state’s behalf.
Mantralaya agreed. On August 31, the Law and Judiciary Department wrote to the Government Pleader at the High Court that the “Medical Education and Drugs Department desires to file Writ Petition” challenging the Central licensing authority and Central Food Safety Officer posts, and asked the pleader to take the necessary steps. On September 2, the medical education department wrote to Mundhe. It told the FDA to secure the Advocate General’s “Availability & Willingness” to argue the case, have the Joint Commissioner file the petition and report back once it was filed.
Story continues below this ad
The petition was filed in September. And then came the U-turn.
On October 28, a desk officer in the medical education department wrote to Mundhe that the earlier instructions stood cancelled until further orders, and that no further action should be taken on them. A day later, the law department wrote to the Government Pleader that the department “desires to withdraw the above Writ Petition”.
On November 6, Mundhe was told to coordinate with the pleader, complete the withdrawal immediately and send a full report. On Saturday, that was done.
None of the three letters says why. Nor do they show at what level either decision was taken. The FDA and medical education portfolios are held by ministers of the NCP, a BJP ally in the Mahayuti. The law department is with Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis.
Story continues below this ad
Senior state officials denied that the decision was based on any Centre-state issue. The reason, they said, was procedure. “There have been Supreme Court judgments where the states and Centre are told to cooperate instead of contesting against each other. The procedure in such disputes is that the issue is placed before the Chief Secretary for an amicable solution. This was not done and hence the withdrawal was directed,” a senior official said.
“After the withdrawal, a letter was sent to all departments to reiterate that this is the procedure and petitions within the governments should be avoided,” the official said.
The file shows the proposal had passed through the department’s Additional Chief Secretary, the law department and the Advocate General before the petition was filed.
Within the FDA, the view is different. A senior official said the challenge was needed because of a “parallel administrative mechanism” contrary to the Food Safety and Standards Act, 2006. A second official said the matter has “become a Central-federal issue” although it is essentially a constitutional one.
Story continues below this ad
Kamble’s July letter sets out the grievance. The 2006 Act, it says, gives enforcement and licensing to the state’s Food Safety Commissioner and the officers the Commissioner appoints. The FSSAI created Central licensing authorities through 2011 regulations and Central Food Safety Officers and analysts through 2018 regulations. Its online licensing portal, launched in 2020, moved most licences in the state under the Central authority.
Through letters in 2021 and again in May 2023, FSSAI barred state food safety officers from enforcing the law at Centrally-licensed businesses. The state’s requests for a review went unanswered, the letter says, and the bar is hampering its ability to protect public health and consumers.
The reversal came as Mundhe, who took charge earlier this year, led a crackdown that has seen licences of restaurants, sweet shops and dairies suspended across the state.
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.