Son dies weeks after insurance policy revival, LIC to pay Rs 9 lakh to father after 3 years

A father was denied a Rs 9 lakh Life Insurance Corporation of India (LIC) claim after his adopted son died within two months of his life insurance policy being revived. LIC rejected the claim, alleging that the son had concealed a disease and that the adoption was not legally established. A Telangana Consumer Commission, however, directed the LIC to pay the Rs 9 lakh sum assured along with the accidental benefit, holding that the insurer had failed to prove deliberate concealment and could not question the adoption after accepting the details while reviving the policy.
The Ranga Reddy District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission president Chitneni Latha Kumari and members D Madhavi Latha and Kathyayani Khandavilli were hearing a complaint by Gummi Chandrapal Reddy seeking payment of his deceased adopted son’s Rs 9 lakh life insurance claim, along with the accidental benefit, compensation and litigation costs, after LIC rejected the claim alleging concealment of a pre-existing disease and lack of valid adoption documents.
“In absence of any cogent legally valid documentary evidence by the Opposite Parties (LIC and its officials) that the deceased knowingly suppressed the said disease of Pemphis Vulgaris, we hold that Opposite Parties are not allowed to denied the valid claim made by the complainant…Opposite Parties are not justified in rejecting the claim made by the complainant on the above said grounds as it collected the premium and revived the lapsed policy on August 31, 2020. And, during subsistence of valid policy
period, policy holder expired. Hence, the action of Opposite Parties amounts to deficiency in service,” the commission said on October 29.
The case began after LIC rejected Reddy’s claim following his adopted son G Satish Reddy’s death on October 20, 2020. The insurer alleged that Satish had concealed a skin disease, Pemphigus Vulgaris, while seeking revival of the policy and questioned the adoption over lack of valid documents. The 35-year LIC New Jeevan Anand policy, taken on August 27, 2019, carried a Rs 9 lakh sum assured and an additional accidental benefit of Rs 9 lakh. After rejecting the claim on March 15, 2022, LIC faced a consumer complaint filed by Reddy on March 31, 2023, seeking the insurance amount, accidental benefit and compensation.
Why LIC rejected claim
The policy had lapsed due to non-payment of premiums and was revived after the deceased submitted a proposal on August 17, 2020. LIC rejected the death claim on March 15, 2022, alleging that he had failed to disclose Pemphigus Vulgaris, an autoimmune disease of skin, in his declaration of good health.
LIC relied on an Osmania General Hospital discharge summary dated October 13, 2020, which recorded symptoms of the disease for approximately two months. It argued that disclosure would have prompted further medical tests and could have led it to decline revival.
The insurer also questioned the adoption, saying Chandrapal Reddy had not produced legally valid documents. It relied on a February 3, 2022, letter in which the deceased had reportedly stated that no legally valid adoption documents existed.
What commission found
The hospital case sheet recorded that the deceased was admitted on October 13, 2020. It also referred to a September hospital visit, when he reportedly stayed for two hours before leaving against medical advice.
Story continues below this ad
The commission said these records did not establish previous hospitalisation for the same ailment in August 2020, when he submitted the revival proposal. Without evidence that he knew about the disease, LIC could not presume deliberate concealment. It also noted that the insurer had an opportunity to enquire into his medical condition before reviving the policy.
On adoption, the commission noted that the proposal form identified Reddy as the deceased’s father. LIC had accepted the proposal, collected the premium and revived the policy without demanding adoption documents. It could not later rely on their absence to reject the claim after accepting the declared relationship.
It distinguished the judgments cited by LIC, which involved evidence of non-disclosure shortly before policies were issued. The commission held that the insurer had failed to establish deliberate concealment and that repudiating the claim amounted to deficiency in service.
Allowing the complaint in part, the commission directed the insurer and its branch manager to jointly and severally pay Reddy the Rs 9 lakh sum assured along with the accidental benefit. It also awarded Rs 20,000 as compensation and Rs 20,000 towards litigation costs.
Story continues below this ad
Takeaway
Insurance companies cannot reject death claims merely by alleging non-disclosure of a pre-existing disease without evidence that the insured knew about the condition and deliberately concealed it. They also cannot accept declared relationship details, issue or revive a policy and later question the relationship to deny a claim.
Aggrieved consumers may contact the consumer helpline in their respective states (Telangana: 0771-2582902) or call the National Consumer Helpline at 1915 for assistance.
Don’t miss out on these stories:
Re 1 refund sent to wallet instead of bank account, retailer ordered to pay Rs 7,500
Airline changes paid seats last minute, passenger wins Rs 34,000 consumer relief
Story continues below this ad
Vehicle seized over loan default, SBI told to pay woman Rs 1.11 lakh after 23 years
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.