A triumphant return to old-school pub culture for this beloved pokie-free boozer

There’s a place you can go where there’s no bouncer rope. No queue. No complicated dance to order a drink. No themed decor, no dress code. People are nice to you, the beers are cold and the food is delicious.

That place is the Carlisle Castle. The only rule? Respect the pub.

I like to think of this stalwart, established in 1876 on sleepy Albermarle Street, as one third of the holy trinity of Newtown pubs, along with the Courthouse and the Town Hall. I’ve loved it on a gloomy Sunday afternoon when it’s been empty except for the local soaks keeping the bar warm out the front. I’ve loved it as a refuge from the busier pubs, as a quiet place to drink a beer and eat a burger. I’ve loved it even when it’s felt less than entirely loved by the people running it.

The pub, which had been family-owned-and-run for the past 60 years, was recently sold to Universal Hotels, the same company behind Redfern’s tastefully renovated Bat & Ball Hotel. They’ve applied a similarly gentle touch here, meaning the pressed metal ceilings have stayed, as has the dining room that opens up into the outdoor courtyard. They’ve also made the side rooms, including the bottle shop and pool room, a little more welcoming. The original vibe is still here, but with a much warmer atmosphere. Now, it’s a serious tavern.

Restaurant reviews, news and the hottest openings served to your inbox.

Sign up

While everything I want to eat is sold out on my first visit (no Guinness pie, no seasonal special chicken Kyiv), there is an excellent black pudding and chorizo scotch egg, laid in the middle of a slick of sweet date ketchup. A massive chicken parmigiana covered in ham, melted cheese and Napoletana sauce served with a side of skin-on fries and mixed leaves definitely hits the mark. The rotating “Castle Cut” steak (on my visit, a chateaubriand) probably needs to come with a steak knife for the $50 price tag, but it has great depth of flavour and excellent pub-style pepper sauce.

Cocktail wise, there are negronis, fancy rum and colas (excellent), Tommy’s margaritas (fine) and Charlie Chaplins. The by-the-glass wine list is strong and all your favourite beers are on tap, including Young Henrys, Grifter and Philter. On weekdays, there’s a $7 house beer and wine happy hour from 4pm to 6pm.

I’ve been back a couple of times since the renovation and each time I’m in fresh awe of how busy the place is. Once upon a time, the skinny front bar would be occupied by locals and their dogs, reading the form guide and watching the footy, but it’s now elbow to elbow with people eating counter meals. At 7.30pm on a Wednesday, the pub is so full, we have to circle it several times to find a seat. Even at capacity, staff remain friendly and relaxed and happy to help.

And actually, it feels to me to be a return to what a pub can be if people get behind it: a real pokie-free community hub.

A lot has been said about the changing habits of people going out these days. It’s been a deep cultural shift, and it’s definitely an interesting new chapter for this old boozer. The median age has probably dropped a decade, and there’s a lot of energy in the room. I’m not surprised. Daily specials mean you could have a Wednesday-night martini and cheeseburger with fries for $35 (the ultimate grown-ups’ happy meal) or chuck a solo session on a Monday with a $20 schnitzel. There are $20 specials every weekday lunch.

This is a triumphant return to everything we know and love about the pub, executed with warmth, sympathy and a light touch. I’ll be back.

Three other legendary inner-west pubs to try

Courthouse Hotel

One of the greatest courtyards in Sydney to enjoy jugs of beer, nachos and easy conversation. Head inside to the pinball room and lose an afternoon. 

202 Australia Street, Newtown, thecourty.com.au

Golden Barley

It’s all about nabbing a spot in the fairy-lit garden out the back. Famous for their weekly Tuesday trivia, it’s also a choice spot for a Sunday roast and cheap jugs.  

165-169 Edgeware Road, Enmore, goldenbarleyhotel.com.au 

White Cockatoo 

The jewel of Petersham. The bistro menu and its legendary schnitzel get most of the attention, but there’s also the beautiful courtyard and free-entry raffle on a Friday. 

30 Terminus Street, Petersham, whitecockatoohotel.com.au

Good Food reviews are booked anonymously and paid independently. A restaurant can’t pay for a review or inclusion in the Good Food Guide.