Has Josh Allen Already Left Peyton Manning Behind In One Of The NFL's Biggest Records?

Josh Allen passed Peyton Manning for the most touchdowns in a player's first 10 NFL seasons.© Image via: X/@NFL
Peyton Manning needed 160 games to reach 322 touchdowns in his first 10 NFL seasons. Josh Allen got there in 137, finishing with a one-yard touchdown run in the first quarter of Buffalo's 31-12 win over the New York Jets on Sunday. The Buffalo Bills quarterback now sits at 323, one clear of Manning. Bills great Jim Kelly answered with a short Instagram note. The bigger story is how Allen got there, and how much room he has left. Buffalo is 8-1 with eight games to play.
Buffalo Bills Quarterback Josh Allen Beats Peyton Manning's Pace By A Third Of A Touchdown Per Game
Allen has averaged 2.36 touchdowns per game over his career. Manning averaged 2.01 with the Indianapolis Colts. Stretch that across a 17-game season and Allen finishes roughly six touchdowns ahead.
His total splits into 232 touchdown passes, 89 rushing touchdowns and two receiving scores. That means 91 of his 323 came without a throw, about 28 percent. Manning's record was built mostly through the air, so Allen has broken it with a different kind of stat line.
WOW: #JETS HC AARON GLENN CALLED OUT THE #NFL REFS FOR THEIR DOUBLE STANDARD WHEN IT COMES TO JOSH ALLEN. “IF THAT WAS JOSH ALLEN, EVERY FLAG ON THE FIELD WOULD BE THROWN.” THIS IS DAMNNING. https://t.co/qp9XxZiNWc
— MLFootball (@MLFootball) November 15, 2026
The ground game is not a one-year burst either. Allen has now run for at least 10 touchdowns in four straight seasons, and he has already hit that number again in 2026.
Jim Kelly's Instagram Message To Josh Allen Hints At Another Bills Record Falling Soon
Kelly posted to his Instagram story after the win. It read, "Well done, 17!"
The note landed because of who sent it. Kelly led Buffalo to four consecutive Super Bowls from 1990 through 1993, and fans still measure Bills quarterbacks against that run. Allen, a former NFL MVP from the 2024 season, is the first one in years to make that comparison feel fair.
There is a second chase hiding in the numbers. Kelly threw 237 touchdown passes for the Bills. Allen has 232. He averages about 1.7 touchdown passes per game, so with eight regular-season games left, he could pass Kelly's total before the calendar flips to December.
Next up is a Week 11 home date with the Miami Dolphins. If Allen throws multiple touchdowns there, he gets within a game or two of Kelly. If he adds another on the ground, the gap behind Manning grows again.
Allen has the rest of this season and all of 2027 to keep stretching the record. Right now, he is the only quarterback in NFL history to have done this much, this quickly.
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.