Perak water deal not thoroughly discussed in Penang assembly, says Guan Eng

Air Putih assemblyman Lim Guan Eng has rejected Penang chief minister Chow Kon Yeow’s claim that the state’s RM24.6 billion bulk water supply agreement with Perak was discussed at two recent state assembly sittings.
Lim, a former chief minister, said the state government refused to disclose the full agreement, citing non-disclosure agreement (NDA) clauses.
“NDA clauses were the reason for rejecting my proposal that the full agreement be tabled for debate and approval by the Penang state assembly, given the large contract value of at least RM24.6 billion,” he said in a statement today.
Lim’s statement followed Chow’s accusation yesterday that Lim had misled the public about the deal inked between the Penang Water Supply Corporation (PBAPP) and Perak’s water and irrigation agency, Perbadanan Air dan Pengairan Perak, despite repeated explanations of the agreement.
Chow said the agreement received 98% of the votes cast at an extraordinary general meeting of PBA Holdings Bhd (PBAHB) on Nov 12 and was discussed extensively at two previous sittings of the Penang state assembly.
He said PBAPP also held briefings for state assemblymen and that the 40-year agreement included safeguards against supply shortfalls and allowed PBAPP to terminate it under certain circumstances.
Chow acknowledged the five dissenting independent directors of PBAHB who voiced concerns about the deal, saying their concerns focused on payment terms should Perak exercise its state interest clause or suspend water supplies for a prolonged period.
However, Lim said the dissenting directors stated during the meeting that PBAPP would still be liable for RM210 million annually if it received less than the contracted quantity of 300 million litres of treated water or, in the worst-case scenario, not a single drop.
“The role of the five dissenting independent directors, who are senior and experienced professionals, should not be so lightly dismissed.
“Can Chow state what kind of agreement requires a state government agency to continue making mandatory annual payments of RM210 million despite receiving nothing in return?” Lim asked.
Penang is expected to begin receiving water from Perak on March 31, 2032, with the option to increase purchases to 500 million litres daily to prevent future shortages as Penang’s population and industries grow.
Under the deal, the state must pay an annual capacity charge of RM210 million to keep the Perak water treatment facilities running, in addition to a treated water charge of RM1.70 per cubic metre (1,000 litres), which is subject to review every three years.
This means Penang will pay about RM396 million a year even if it buys only the minimum 300 million litres a day. The deal is expected to cost RM24.6 billion over 40 years, covering both water purchases and fixed charges for treatment capacity.
Subscribe to our newsletter and get news delivered to your mailbox.
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.