Bengaluru man pays Rs 90,000 for holiday membership; NCDRC orders refund with 6% interest
![]()
AI Image Used For Representational Purpose Only
NEW DELHI/BENGALURU: A Bengaluru man who paid Rs 90,000 for a long-term holiday membership but sought to cancel it within six weeks without using any of its benefits is entitled to a refund, the National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission (NCDRC) has ruled.
The commission held that refusing to cancel the membership by citing a contractual 'no-refund' clause, despite the consumer having availed no facilities, amounted to unfair and unjust conduct.Dismissing a revision petition filed by Country Vacations and Country Club (India) Ltd, the NCDRC upheld an order of the Karnataka State Consumer Commission directing the companies to refund the membership fee with 6% annual interest and pay Rs 5,000 towards litigation costs.The complaint was filed by Sangeeth Bhadran, who received a promotional call from Country Vacations on December 2, 2013, offering holiday and vacation facilities and inviting him to visit its office. Five days later, Bhadran visited the company's Bengaluru office and signed a membership purchase agreement after being offered holiday benefits, accommodation facilities and discounts. He paid Rs 90,000 for the membership.
However, he later found that the benefits described during the promotional interaction did not match the actual terms and conditions of the agreement. He also alleged that he had been assured that maintenance charges would not apply to facilities he did not use. After examining the agreement, Bhadran sought cancellation and a refund of his money. Despite repeated emails, telephone calls and personal visits, the companies allegedly refused to cancel the membership or return the amount.He subsequently approached the III Additional Bangalore Urban District Consumer Forum, which dismissed his complaint, finding no deficiency in service or unfair trade practice. Bhadran challenged the decision before the Karnataka State Consumer Commission, which ruled in his favour and directed the companies to refund Rs 90,000 with 6% annual interest from the date of filing the complaint until payment. It also awarded him Rs 5,000 towards litigation costs.Country Vacations and Country Club then approached the NCDRC, arguing that Bhadran had voluntarily entered into the agreement after understanding its terms, including the non-refundable nature of the membership fee. The companies said membership cards and gift vouchers had been issued to him, but he had neither attempted to use the holiday facilities nor paid the mandatory annual maintenance charges. They denied any misrepresentation or deficiency in service and argued that he had failed to produce evidence to support his allegations.The NCDRC, however, observed that Bhadran's failure to use the membership facilities could not, by itself, absolve the companies of unfair conduct or validate one-sided contractual terms. It noted that he had been invited to the office, where the membership benefits were presented and the agreement signed on the same day. Within approximately one-and-a-half months, without availing any benefits, he sought to withdraw from the long-term arrangement.
The commission held that refusing a refund by relying on the 'no-refund' clause, while continuing to impose an annual maintenance liability under the agreement was 'patently unfair and unjust'.
It observed that the companies could perhaps have deducted a proportionate amount for the one-and-a-half-month period, along with reasonable administrative charges or an earnest amount, before returning the balance. The commission said retaining the entire membership fee despite the consumer having availed no benefits would result in unjust and disproportionate enrichment of the companies.Finding no jurisdictional or other error in the Karnataka State Consumer Commission's order, the NCDRC dismissed the revision petition.
The companies must now refund Bhadran's Rs 90,000 with 6% annual interest from the date of filing of the complaint until payment, besides paying Rs 5,000 towards litigation costs.
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.