The Jerusalem PostIsrael's strategic depth lies in its global Jewish Diaspora - opinionPunch‘Bamayi’ chant sparks violence as suspected thugs attack APC convoy in GombeInquirerAlmost P15M worth of marijuana bricks seized in Ifugao buy-bustDaily MaverickWHAT WE’RE WATCHING: VisionQuest — Marvel’s latest miniseries has big ideas, but not enough human feelingVariety‘Hanuman Ansh,’ ‘Pyre’ and Shah Rukh Khan Classics Lead International Film Festival of India’s Inflatable Cinema Lineup as NFDC, ESG Renew PictureTime PartnershipGIGAZINE濡れ場に合わせて映画館の座席が動く4DXならぬ4Dセックスが流行、「まるで3人で致したみたいだった」と鑑賞者は語るZDF heuteAktuelle Pressemitteilungen des ZDFNOSHoogste cyberadviseur Trump vertrekt na reeks technische storingenLenta.ruКиев обвинили в попытке сорвать переговоры в ШэньчжэнеScreen RantGTA 6: Should You Choose Saved Cash Or Say Nothing In "Buck Me"Antara NewsPrabowo, Putin hold one-on-one meeting on APEC sidelines in ShenzhenThe Sydney Morning HeraldHe stole our hearts in Severance. Now John Turturro is stealing our wallets
The Daily Newsstand · Free, Always
Friday, November 20, 2026

Residents’ association can’t force homeowners to become members, judge rules

Translate

A residents’ association cannot automatically impose membership on homeowners or compel them to pay retrospective security fees, a sessions court has ruled.

Judge Zuhrina Nor Hakim allowed a civil claim brought by homeowner Abdul Farid Abdul Kadir against Persatuan Penduduk Jalan Hijau Pelangi and its chairman, Saaidal Razalli Azzuhri.

In a decision delivered on Monday, Zuhrina also dismissed the counterclaim by the association and its chairman in its entirety.

The dispute arose from the association’s insistence that Farid was automatically a member and liable for outstanding security charges dating back to 2013, although he maintained that he had never voluntarily applied for membership.

Farid argued that membership required an application in accordance with the association’s constitution and could not be automatically imposed on homeowners.

He also disputed the demand for retrospective security payments for a period when he was living overseas and not occupying the property.

In his statement of claim, Farid said he returned to Malaysia in July 2020 and applied to join the association, offering RM1,410 towards membership and security services.

However, his application was rejected after the association insisted that he first settle outstanding charges accumulated over previous years.

The dispute also involved access arrangements at the Cahaya SPK residential development in Shah Alam.

Farid claimed that residents who did not pay security charges were required to leave their vehicles and operate the boom gate themselves, even when security guards were on duty.

He argued that this discriminated against non-members and interfered with their access to their properties.

Another issue was the legality of the guarded and gated arrangement, including guardhouses and automated boom gates allegedly erected on government land without approval from the Shah Alam City Council (MBSA).

Farid argued that the original arrangement established by the developer was a guarded community scheme, and that its subsequent conversion into a guarded and gated arrangement required compliance with the relevant local authority guidelines and procedures.

In allowing the claim on the balance of probabilities, Zuhrina granted the declarations sought in Farid’s statement of claim.

Among other things, she declared that the association could not automatically impose membership on homeowners without an application, compel residents to become members or demand retrospective fees as a condition of membership.

She also ruled that non-member residents could not be required to operate the boom gate themselves without assistance from security personnel, contrary to the applicable guarded community guidelines.

The defendants were ordered to provide Farid with an access card to enter through the guardhouse and boom gate within 30 days of the order.

The judge also ordered a refund or set-off of the RM1,410 Farid previously paid towards the disputed security charges. She further granted relief concerning threats to report the names of him and his wife to credit reporting agencies, including CTOS and CCRIS.

Zuhrina awarded Farid RM20,000 in general damages, with interest at 5% per annum from the date of judgment until full settlement.

The defendants were also ordered to pay RM7,000 in costs.

Colin Andrew Pereira and Edwina Ti represented Farid, while Shah Nurul Afzan Abdullah appeared for the defendants.

Subscribe to our newsletter and get news delivered to your mailbox.

View the original on Free Malaysia Today →

KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.