This year, the Greens have reshaped British politics. Now we need party systems to match that influence | Caroline Lucas

In the aftermath of some difficult weeks for the Greens, one encouraging response has particularly stood out for me: the widespread agreement across progressive politics that the UK is better for having a strong Green party. One that will hold other parties to account for their delivery on social and environmental justice and that will put issues on the political agenda that other parties won’t.
From Rosebank to wealth taxes and ending arms sales to Israel, Greens are stretching the Overton window so that the gap narrows between what’s necessary and what’s currently deemed politically acceptable. As we increasingly win more council seats, assembly members, mayors and MPs we are able, at all levels of government, to help restore the natural world, tackle climate breakdown and challenge the economic framework of neoliberalism that has governed us for too long, help restore the natural world and tackle climate breakdown.
As the pollster Luke Tryl from More in Common has observed, Green influence on the political landscape, including Andy Burnham’s conference speech, “has been outsized”. That influence includes creating the conditions for Burnham to become prime minister. To put it bluntly, if there had been no Zack Polanski leadership, and no Hannah Spencer win in the Gorton and Denton byelection, we would probably still be stuck with Keir Starmer. It was the Greens as much as anyone who forced Labour MPs to conclude they needed a more radical offer.
Burnham’s talk of reversing 40 years of neoliberalism and his pledge to establish a national commission on electoral reform are to be welcomed. But we need more radical action and more urgent delivery. Take last month’s budget of incrementalism and resounding failure to tax the super-rich – it’s now 41 years of neoliberalism we need to reverse. Moreover, Burnham’s greenlighting of fossil-fuel drilling at Jackdaw, his slashing of the warm homes plan to fund defence and likely watering down of targets for electric vehicles show that the Green party is needed more than ever – and that we have our work cut out for us.
And that’s what has made the fallout from the Greens’ “Zionism is racism” conference motion all the more damaging. I have made my personal view clear: it was never going to be possible to define such a contested term with such variable meanings, that itself historically arose from widespread racism in Russia and eastern Europe, in just a few words in a conference motion. The attempt has been dangerous and divisive, and takes the focus away from the appalling genocide in Gaza, rather than bringing opportunities to do what’s needed to isolate and constrain the Israeli government. But the prime minister’s call for a different kind of politics, “problem-solving, not point-scoring”, has not got off to a good start after his top-down edict to Labour councillors to end joint working with local Greens unless they renounced the motion.
This has led to the ending of many of our power-sharing agreements around the country, a move opposed by most Labour and Green councillors alike. It is also a move that will only hurt local residents, particularly if it paves the way for Reform UK or Conservative councillors to take over. This hardly fits with Burnham’s support for devolution and local autonomy.
Within all progressive parties and across them, we need to be modelling better ways of doing politics, particularly since the political system is likely to remain fragmented. The most recent YouGov poll puts five parties in double digits with Labour ahead, but only on 27% of the vote. As we anticipate a world of proportional representation and multiparty government, we’re going to have to learn how to deal with differences in a less binary and confrontational way. It cannot be right that progressive parties would rather risk Reform gaining power than find ways to work effectively together.
For we Greens, the challenge is also to make our internal structures fit for purpose, and in line with the scale of our new membership and the importance of the role the party now plays on the national stage. I welcome the fact that the leadership has established a working group to look at examples from across the world of how progressive parties with mass memberships develop effective policy, and to put forward proposals for models that could work well for our party.
The truth is that systems that might have served the party well when it had a membership of just a few tens of thousands and a handful of elected representatives simply aren’t up to the job for a party of several hundred thousand members. With over a thousand Greens now holding office, decisions need to be made more efficiently and policy developed more effectively. This was a foreseeable challenge. Indeed in the period when I was co-leader, some eight years ago, I was one of the instigators of the last review that sought – with only partial success – to make positive democratic changes. But it is now a more urgent one.
after newsletter promotion
So let’s try to model disagreement well. If means shape ends then both Labour and the Greens need to show how to do politics differently, not least to fend off the threat of a united right. The motion and the debate around it won’t just go away and nor should it. It needs to be resolved, but in ways that grow trust, respect and mutual understanding.
-
Caroline Lucas is co-chair of the cross-party campaign group Compass and a former Green MP
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.