The weight of gold: Inside surfing star John Florence's Olympic-sized decision

• 

  Alyssa RoenigkNov 10, 2026, 08:00 AM ET

  Close

  Alyssa Roenigk is a senior writer for ESPN whose assignments have taken her to six continents and caused her to commit countless acts of recklessness. (Follow @alyroe on Twitter).

THREE-TIME WORLD surfing champion John Florence sits on the back deck of "Vela," his Gunboat 60 catamaran sailboat docked in Papeete on the northwest coast of Tahiti. It's an early morning in late September and his wife, Lauryn, is inside making breakfast for their 2-year-old son, Darwin, who has walked out onto the deck and sits directly in front of Florence, his white-blond hair wild from a solid night's sleep. Darwin was crawling when the couple started this journey a year and a half ago, so they added mesh doors to the companionways to protect him from tumbling off the deck and into the hulls. Now, the coverings are gone, and Mom and Dad keep a watchful eye.

Florence's history is palpable on this island. He can feel it in the rumble of the waves from shore. He can taste it in the salt drying on his lips. The memories come quickly: battling Kelly Slater at Teahuopo'o, the storied break just south of Papeete, in 2016; beating longtime rival Gabriel Medina in the semifinals in 2024, then losing to Medina's Brazilian countryman, Italo Ferreira, but leaving in the yellow jersey; lingering too long at the post-contest awards celebration and racing to make his flight home.

In this place, his heart is open. "When I woke up this morning, I would have said yes," says Florence, 34, during a video call from his laptop. "If you asked me two days ago, I probably would have said yes."

Darwin rubs his eyes with both fists, then casts his chin downward and stares at his dad over the tops of his eyes. He doesn't have the vocabulary yet, but his expression is begging, Close the silver box, Dad, and pay attention to me.

"Right now," Florence says, "I don't know if I would come back."

Nearly two years ago, Florence sailed away from the only life he'd known. Born in Honolulu and raised on Oahu's North Shore, he started surfing the island's famed Banzai Pipeline at 8. By 13, he was heralded as the next great Hawaiian champion. He won his first world title at 24 and is known as one of the most versatile and complete surfers of his generation.

But four months after securing the 2024 World Surf League championship, Florence announced he was taking a year off from the tour to sail around the world with Lauryn and their new baby. I'll be back in 2026, he said publicly. I'll be back in 2026, he told himself.

After accepting the WSL's wild card for the 2026 season, Florence began questioning his return. The decision he made next shocked surf fans and came easier than Florence cares to acknowledge. In February 2026, two months before the first event of the season, he announced he was deferring his return to the tour for another year. He sold the family's 48-foot sailboat, which he'd purchased from snowboarder Travis Rice, bought the 60-footer they're on today and kept going, spending the better part of the past two years at sea.

Darwin celebrated his second birthday on the boat. Lauryn baked a cake and found a few pieces of felt to fashion into a happy birthday sign. This summer, Darwin rode longboard waves with his mom and dad at a beach break on the Pacific side of Panama. He learned to snorkel floating above a reef in the Galápagos, his arms wrapped around his dad's neck.

Florence was still finding his way as an ocean sailor two years ago. Today, he captains and navigates Vela -- Spanish for "sail" -- through multiweek offshore passages and surfs uncrowded world-class breaks he'd never even seen in photographs.

Now, with the 2028 Los Angeles Olympics on the horizon and the WSL's Nov. 1 deadline to apply for a 2027 wild card approaching, Florence faces a decision both singular and universal: return to the tour full time in January and chase a fourth world title and a third Olympics or sail away from the potential of the next two years and continue the life he has built with his family. To qualify for the U.S. Olympic team, he must return to competition full time.

"It's not the winning I miss. It's not the losing. It's the process that goes into it," Florence says. "Putting my head down and going all-in on something, that's what I miss and that's what I would go back for.

"But I've started on this new path, and it's hard to take a step back and go back to the other path. I know what it takes to compete and win and give everything. It would take away a lot of little moments and I'm not sure I want to give up those moments. That's time I'll never get back."

BEFORE HE TALKS about a return, Florence wants people to understand why he left the tour.

"I don't want anyone to think that I took competing for granted," he says. "It was a huge part of my life. I loved it and I love it still. I have so much respect for the WSL and the competitors. But in this moment of my life, it felt like the right decision to be with my family doing what I love with a little more freedom."

It's early June, and Florence and his family are off the coast of Panama, roughly 1,000 nautical miles from the Bahamas, where they began this leg of the journey. Florence had never been to Panama before sailing through the canal, an hourslong journey through the locks that he calls "incredible and medieval, but efficient."

As he reminisces about the experience, something on the horizon catches his eye.

"Whoa," he says, his gaze darting upward. "That was a wave."

His eyes return to his laptop. "Sorry. We're going over this bank. It's a little shallower and there's a full swell. But ..."

He's quiet for a moment.

"It was not an easy decision," he says of informing the league of his initial choice to not compete in 2025. "I agonized for days."

He thinks back to his conversations with friends and family, to late nights spent trying to imagine spending another season as he had the year before, flying Lauryn and their new baby from contest to contest for stretches of the season and then leaving them home in Hawaii for weeks or months at a time.

Eventually, he realized he couldn't get into the headspace he needed to win. And if he wasn't showing up to contests to win, what was the point?

"My entire life was building up to the goal of competing on the world tour and winning a world title, and then I had 13 years of that, back-to-back. Everything was in service of winning a world title," he says. "I've never had the guts to separate myself from it. That was the hardest part, mentally, internally, accepting that I was going to go do something that wasn't this one thing I've been chasing my entire life."

Out at sea, he wouldn't be John John Florence, this almost mythical figure within the sport of surfing. He would be Lauryn's husband and Darwin's dad. Ahead was the chance to be a beginner again, as a sailor and a father. He wouldn't be walking away from surfing, just from competition. And it was only for one year, a chance to leave behind the boy surf fans had watched compete for decades and step fully into John Florence, a man free to follow his curiosity and discover what else he could become.

It was one thing to acknowledge all of that to himself. It was another to say it out loud, to inform his sponsors, the league and his fans that he needed a break. He felt as if he was letting down a lot of people. But he'd found something he wanted more. "Competition is amazing," Florence says. "But it's probably one of the more selfish things you can do. You have these blinders up and there's nothing else, just, 'I am here to win.' That didn't match with having a family. That didn't match with raising my son."

Florence had been planning to take a year or two off for nearly a decade, including after winning his second world title in 2017. But each time the deadline approached, he talked himself into returning for another season. Some years, he says, his surfing suffered because of it.

"I think it's one of the bigger reasons for a lot of my injuries," Florence says. He sustained midseason partial ACL tears in 2018 and 2019 and an MCL tear in 2022. "I'd get halfway through a year and to a point of not wanting to be there, just burnt out. And then I would get injured. There's such a connection between your mind and body. Sometimes your body goes, 'No. We're not doing this right now.'"

Kelly Slater, 54, credits taking a break after the 1998 season with extending his career by decades. The 11-time world champion returned to competition as a wild card at the Tahiti Pro this August, nine months after undergoing a left hip replacement. "I'd done seven years and my batteries were just burnt [in '98]. I wasn't motivated at all," says Slater, who retired from the tour full time in 2024, at 52. "I took three years off. After I came back, I competed for three times that amount." He won six world titles after that break.

It's a Sunday in September, a lay day for the Trestles Pro, and Slater is at a rented house in San Clemente, California. The Olympic surf competition will take place here at Lower Trestles in two years. The wave is a high-performance canvas for powerful, progressive surfers like Florence, who secured his third world title here in 2024. Slater says he thinks this time away could recharge Florence's competitive batteries as it once did his and set him up for success in 2028. He also says he believes another chance to add an Olympic medal to his CV is worth coming back for. Florence finished tied for ninth in both of his Olympic appearances.

"John hasn't done well in the Olympics. He's going to want to claim that territory," says Slater, who never made an Olympic team and has expressed interest in coaching in 2028. "If he could be an Olympic champion on top of being world champion, that's a long runway for his future. If I could trade a world title for a gold medal, I would."

FLORENCE LOOKS AROUND the table at three generations of Florences laughing and sharing stories with surfers they met in the Galápagos, new friends who invited them into their home. For several days in July, he and Lauryn and Darwin, his mom, Alex, and his younger brothers, Ivan and Nathan, and Nathan's wife, Mahina, have toured the islands. Although they all live in Oahu, this kind of family time is rare, and special.

"It was so lovely having everyone on the boat and cooking for them," Lauryn says later. "When we come home, you get into a routine of everyday life, putting yourself first, meeting with friends, working out. On the boat, it's what are we going to do together today? At home, and when he's on tour, we're more separated. We miss out on time as a family and John even more so."

Having his mom and brothers on the boat reminds Florence of the childhood he wants for Darwin. Alex raised three energetic boys largely on her own, which had a profound impact on Florence. "We were all really close," he says. "My mom traveled with us to Indo by herself. I can't even imagine." He wants Darwin to experience the kind the bond he has with his siblings. "I had so much fun growing up with brothers," he says. He and Lauryn plan to have more kids, and they're not sure how much longer they want to wait.

During the family's visit, the couple invited a licensed naturalist aboard Vela and followed a packed itinerary through the Galápagos National Park, moving from island to island to hike, snorkel and search for wildlife like marine iguanas and giant tortoises.

"We were diving around this one area -- Darwin goes on my back -- and he's dunking his head with his mask on and looking at all the big fish, the swimming iguanas, and he's just tripping out," Florence says. "Seeing him see that -- I mean, we were excited, but he was really excited. It was so cool."

John and Lauryn named Darwin for both the Australian city and the English naturalist, hoping to imbue their firstborn with a spirit of exploration and curiosity. They're seeing him grow into his name every day. "Watching his language get better, going surfing, fishing off the back of the boat, watching him interact with new kids -- seeing the world through his eyes is amazing," Florence says. "It's all new."

Florence is having a similar experience. He's traveling to places his tour schedule never would have allowed, learning new cultures, finding surf communities in places he didn't know existed. He's becoming a better sailor and problem solver. "I'm always trying to learn," he says. "That's what I've enjoyed so much about this trip, being in a beginner's mindset."

As with surfing, it's often the toughest moments at sea that have reminded Florence how much he enjoys the process more than the result. Last year, while sailing from Hawaii to Fiji, one of Vela's two rudders broke. Florence and his crew had to change course and navigate strong winds to reach a place where it could be repaired. He learned more in those days than in the weeks of smooth sailing that preceded them.

Life on the world tour also was like that. "Surfing a heat is like a life scenario," Florence says. "The emotions are up and down, and you have to stabilize and make good decisions. We've had some scary moments on the boat. Those are the times you feel like you're really far out there and committed. You're constantly problem solving, trying to figure out how to get to where you're going safely."

This year's trip started in earnest in March. Lauryn's parents flew from their home in Australia to Florida, to watch Darwin and help provision the boat. For ocean crossings longer than five days, Lauryn and Darwin go ashore while Florence and a couple of friends take turns standing watch aboard Vela. Before the crossing from the Galápagos to Tahiti, Lauryn and Darwin spent more than 24 hours traveling home to Hawaii. She'll head back to Hawaii in October, the day before Florence's 34th birthday, ahead of his final crossing of the year to New Zealand. When they're apart, she tracks the boat's progress on an app.

"I won't lie. Life on the boat can get lonely," Lauryn says. "There are so many boys around, sometimes I just want to talk to a girl. As parents, you don't get time off. You're on all the time. I can't imagine having a beauty routine or working out. I turn into a boat person. But, look at where we are. Look at what we get to do."

In the Galápagos, Florence and his brothers surfed waves they might never experience again. A week after the family dinner, they sailed their longest crossing to date: 3,200 nautical miles to the Marquesas Islands in French Polynesia. It took them 12 days.

"I always get into these places, and I feel like I haven't seen it all," Florence says. "There's just not enough time. You can spend years in some of these islands. It's so hard to leave and keep moving on."

That same reluctance to leave shaped Florence's decision last year, as the start of the 2026 season approached. Florence brooded over late-night conversations with Lauryn. He'd planned to take only one year off, and he'd already accepted the WSL's wild card. "But we got into such a good rhythm, and it was really hard to leave that," he says. "It felt like one of those things where you're like, 'Why? This is working so well. This feels so good. Why would I leave this?'" He withdrew from the 2026 tour and kept sailing.

This summer, though, something began to shift. His agent asked the WSL for a wild card into the Tahiti Pro in August. "It's always been a dream of mine to sail up to an event, surf the contest, win it, and then sail away," Florence says.

The spot instead went to Slater, whose company, Outerknown, sponsored the event. Slater says he saw the online chatter before the contest, talk that the wild card should have gone to someone younger or a local. But his second-round performance, he says, "was proof the wild card was not wasted on me." He beat three-time world champ Gabe Medina, one of the best ever at Chopes, with a near-perfect heat many have called one of the best Teahupo'o performances of all time.

"I really wanted to do that event and the timing was perfect," Florence says. "But it's cool what Kelly did. He showed up and just destroyed Gabe."

The WSL offered Florence a wild card into the next event, the Fiji Pro in late August, but sailing there would have taken him too far off of his planned course toward French Polynesia, so he turned it down. Missing the Tahiti event made Florence realize how much he wanted to compete. He could imagine himself back in the mindset he needed to win.

Then came another realization. USA Surfing had released its qualification process for LA28, and although the criteria had yet to be finalized, one requirement was clear: To be eligible for the U.S. Olympic team, Florence would need to compete full time on the WSL tour in 2027 and 2028.

"I know this is probably my last chance," Florence says of the Olympics. "That's why this decision is so hard."

After the Fiji event, Florence requested a wild card through his agent to surf the Pipeline Masters in Oahu in December, which returns as the WSL's season finale. The WSL will announce its wild cards at the end of November. If he's offered a spot, the contest could be either a way to ease back into full-time competition, or a one-off in his favorite event at his home break.

"As long as I've known him, John's never done anything halfway," says Florence's agent and longtime friend, Brandon Wasserman. "For John, it's all within, feeling that he didn't leave anything on the table. Fame and money don't drive John. What drives him is, 'I think I could win the Olympics, and it would be special to win a gold medal for myself, my family, Hawaii and my country and my son.'"

Then, Wasserman says, Florence would ask everyone in his orbit to help him turn over every rock to achieve that goal.

Florence doesn't spend too much time online, but he knows what's happening on tour. He sees four Brazilians in the top five, watches consequential heats and reads posts speculating about whether he'll return. He says he considers many of the same questions surf fans debate in online forums.

Lauryn says she focuses on the comments she reads on her husband's Instagram posts showing him surfing barrels so perfect they look as if they were created with artificial intelligence and spending time with his family. "They say, 'Stay off tour. I love watching you with your family. You're so happy,'" she says.

Even those closest to Florence have no idea what he will ultimately decide. So, while the surf world waits, so does his family.

IN MANY WAYS, returning to the tour is the easy choice. Competition is his comfort zone. Florence has been competing nearly year-round since he was a kid. He knows what awaits him on the other side of that choice. It's a rhythm he will slide into easily. Staying at sea with his wife and an adventurous toddler is the unknown. On paper, it's the harder choice. But that's what makes it so appealing. It's where he sees the greatest opportunity for growth.

"John's a student of life, a student of the world," Lauryn says. "He's always trying to better himself. He's so humble and such a good dad. He wants to be present and that's the driving force behind this decision."

Florence says he knows there is privilege in this problem. He isn't deciding whether to return to work to pay his bills or provide for his family. His sponsors supported his decision to step away. He continues to surf, produce content and work with Florence X, the performance-apparel company he co-founded, as its product innovator and test pilot.

The choice in front of him is more personal: What does he believe is best for himself and his family? "I love what I'm doing now. I think it balances well, and I don't think the tour balances with having a family," Florence says in September. "I know a lot of people travel with their families, but to win, you have to be so focused on what you're doing. I think about the tour and how so much of my attention would be on myself. It's really hard to wrap my head around. But I think about it every night."

There is a version of the next two years in which Florence returns to competition and gives everything he has to the pursuit of another Olympics. And there is another in which Darwin grows up on Vela, surfing and snorkeling and fishing off the back of the boat, while the Olympics happen thousands of miles away.

"An Olympic medal would be a huge deal," Florence says. "But more than the medal, the goal of it is pretty cool because it's such a different way of competing. The Olympics puts a lot of energy into a single moment. I mean, we're talking about it now, and it's a couple years out. That's what makes the Olympics so special."

Florence says he knows what that pursuit would demand of him. "If and when I compete, I want to win. I want to destroy people in heats," he says. That means giving up midday dance parties on the boat with Lauryn and Darwin, missing birthdays and so many firsts. And what if, after he reconnects with the competitor he left at Trestles two years ago, he finds it's even harder to walk away the next time?

He says his family and friends, especially Lauryn, will support whatever he decides. Their counsel will help shape that choice. But ultimately the decision is his alone.

"I have a feeling he might choose not to go back [to the tour]," Lauryn says. It's late October and she and Darwin are in Hawaii planning what they'll wear for Halloween. "But this is probably his last moment to compete for a world title and the Olympics. John is such an indecisive person. He will deliberate this until the last second and sometimes, he surprises me."

In late September, Florence said he suspected his decision might come down to something as simple as how he feels when he wakes up on Nov. 1. He'll be more than a week into the crossing from Tahiti to New Zealand, and he'll have a lot of time to meditate on what he will do.

A perfect day on the water might convince him he'd be crazy to leave this life. Rain and rough seas might send him running back to the tour.

"Knowing me, I will push this to the last four minutes," Florence says. "I'll be like, 'Yes, no, yes, no, yes,' all the way to the final second. And then I'll freak out and make a decision."

HE WAKES TO freezing cold on Nov. 1. When Florence and his crewmates on this crossing -- his longtime cinematographer Erik Knutson and sailor Jack Davidson -- left Tahiti on Oct. 22, four days after his 34th birthday, the air was warm and humid. They sailed west, the sun rising later each morning, and waited for a weather window before heading south toward New Zealand, their final destination of the year.

"This was our most challenging crossing of the year," he says. "There were only three of us on the boat and the crossing was about 2,200 [nautical] miles. We dealt with a lot of different types of weather." They crossed the international date line during their nearly two-week trip.

"When you're heading straight west, the sun rises a little later every morning," he says. "You have a watch time that's locked at a certain point each morning, and by the end of the trip, your watch time is at a different part of the day. When we started heading south, you feel it getting colder and colder. Then you wake up one morning and it's freezing and you're in a whole different climate."

Florence is relaying all of this in a series of voice notes he recorded three days later, after arriving in Whangarei, the northernmost city in New Zealand, and spending hours clearing customs. He sounds exhausted. He has had little sleep over the past few days, since he texted his agent and his family to inform them that he would not apply for a season wild card for 2027.

Florence had plenty of time to reflect while standing watch during this crossing: on the family's first year at sea, when they were all just figuring things out, and on this year, when so much started to click. "I try to take things in three-year blocks," he says. Throughout his career, he has looked at winning a world title much the same way. "The third year becomes ultra fun because you've learned a lot of little tricks and you're off and running."

The first two years are the process. He wants to see what the third might bring. He doesn't want to rob himself and his family of that chance.

"We need more time," he says. "There's a lot of momentum with what I'm doing now."

It's quiet in the background, the occasional chirping bird the only sound other than Florence's voice. He speaks deliberately, weighing his words.

"But me choosing to do this isn't choosing never to compete again," he says. "I'm hopefully going to be in the Pipe event [in December] with a wild card. And then [for 2028], I don't know. I have a huge amount of respect for the athletes and the tour. If you don't want to be there, if your heart and mind isn't 110% into it, then you shouldn't be there. It's hard on the people around you. I don't want to take a spot if my mind isn't 100% there."

Now there are no immovable goals. He'd like to sail around the world, but he also wants to spend more time in the places he has fallen in love with over the past two years. He wants to continue to explore and find new waves. "Sailing brings together all my love for the ocean and I'm learning to be on the ocean in a different way," he says. "But I'm still surfing and becoming a better surfer. I'm building projects around what we're doing and I'm doing it with my family. All these things in my life are pointing me in one direction."