Sandpaper gate: What the coaches knew

Like an unputdownable whodunit, there are accounts and more accounts, versions and interpretations, suspects, speculations and theories. There are exhibits, allegations and counter-allegations, and involves a divided house. Who is speaking the truth, and whose truth is the real truth? What the coaches have spoken so far
Until Cameron Bancroft alleged his involvement, that is he was aware that his team was using sandpaper, he was barely in the limelight. He had resigned on moral grounds after the fourth Test of the series. “It’s the right time to step away,” Lehmann said in a press conference. “I’m ultimately responsible for the culture of the team and I’ve been thinking about my position for a while,” he said, stifling tears and choking for words. He then drifted away from the limelight, before Bancroft wrote in a confessional piece in Sydney Morning Herald: “Saker and Lehmann were certainly present, although I cannot speak for every word shared,” Bancroft wrote.
Lehmann allegedly told reserve batter Peter Handscomb after Bancroft was caught red-handed:“Get the f—ing sandpaper off Bangers now”. “In my opinion, if he didn’t know he wouldn’t have said that,” Bancroft wrote.
The former coach, who repeatedly denied any knowledge of the use of sandpaper and whose claims were validated by CA’s investigation, stormed out of the commentary box during the third ODI between England and Australia on Wednesday. The allegations … I’ve got to sit back. It’s only just come to light,” Lehmann said. “So I just need to sit back and process all that and work through each allegation. That’s what I will be doing over the next few days.”
“I need to have a really good read of it don’t I? What’s transpired, speaking to people, and just making sure I’m saying what I want to say and answer the questions you want to ask,” he added.
David Saker, bowling coach
Bancroft accused him of instructing him “to do more with the sandpaper on the ball to get it to swing” during lunch on the third day of the Cape Town Test. He also allegedly told then captain Steve Smith and Bancroft to lie about the incident. According to Bancroft, Saker was present at the Port Elizabeth meeting with Lehmann where Warner raised the idea of using sandpaper. “I received wraps and encouragement from members of the playing and coaching staff, especially David Saker,” Bancroft wrote. Usman Khawaja wrote in his autobiography that Saker apparently told Bancroft: “It’s wet out there – we just need more of it’,” Khawaja wrote of the coach, who he does not name.
Saker has dwelled on the scandal just once. “There were a lot of people to blame. It could have been me to blame, it could have been someone else. It could have been stopped and it wasn’t, which is unfortunate,” Saker said in 2021 after Bancroft’s claims in an interview to the Guardian.
Story continues below this ad
“You could point your finger at me, you could point your finger at ‘Boof’ [ Lehmann], could you point it at other people, of course you could. We all know that we made a monumental mistake. The gravity wasn’t as plain until it all came out,” he said.
Graeme Hick, batting coach
Both Bancroft and Khawaja claimed that the former England batsmen knew they were using sandpaper. Hick, though, has vehemently denied it. “I have seen the various statements around the coaches and I’m very disappointed with the broad nature of them,” Hick told Sydney Morning Herald. “Khawaja puts it simply: ‘It was all of us. Not the batters, not the bowlers, not the staff. All of us.’ To me what Khawaja is implying here is absolutely false.
He added: “I will say in true honesty that I did not hear or know anything!My first knowledge of all this was, like many, when it appeared on the big screen in Cape Town as I was sat on the outside balcony at the time,” he said.
Brad Haddin, the fielding coach
Khawaja mentioned that Haddin, the mainstay wicket-keeper in the post-Adam Gilchrist era, knew about the team using sandpaper. He has barely spoken about the issue. The only time he spoke was in 2018, after Lehmann blamed the team’s culture. “The independent review got done, everyone gets to have their say openly and honestly, and that’s what you want. “From our point of view, we’re moving forward. It’s been six months since South Africa. A lot of water has gone under the bridge,” said Haddin, who later became an assistant coach during Lehman’s successor Justin Langer’s time. “We’ve got to start rebuilding the cricket team to start winning games for Australia and get a cricket team that Australia can be proud of.”
Story continues below this ad
He hit the path of self righteousness, saying the means to win should be fair. “No matter what sport you play, you always want to win. But there’s a right and a wrong way to do it,” he said.
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.