The Daily Newsstand · Free, Always
Saturday, November 21, 2026

The GE16 tightrope: will BN stick with PN or pivot back to PH?

Translate

Fresh off a string of dominant state election victories in 2026, Barisan Nasional (BN) finds itself in the enviable position of having the political upper hand ahead of the 16th general election (GE16).

Yet, as attention shifts from state assemblies to the battle for Putrajaya, a critical question looms over the nation’s political landscape: can BN and Perikatan Nasional (PN) successfully divide parliamentary seats for GE16, or will irreconcilable demands push BN back into the arms of Pakatan Harapan (PH)?

On paper, a BN-PN federal pact appears to be the logical next step.

The two coalitions recently demonstrated the potency of their combined Malay-majority appeal by sweeping the Negeri Sembilan and Melaka state elections on Aug 1 and Nov 14.

However, just a day after the Melaka victory, BN chairman Ahmad Zahid Hamidi poured cold water on assumptions of an automatic federal alliance, saying BN has no current plans to extend its state-level cooperation with PN to GE16.

Behind Zahid’s caution lies a mathematical and territorial impasse that threatens to derail parliamentary seat negotiations before they even begin.

The primary obstacle is the clash over seat allocation formulas. According to political analysts, PAS-led PN is expected to insist on an “incumbency formula”, whereby each party defends the parliamentary seats it won in the 2022 general election (GE15).

While such a rule sounds straightforward, it would be devastating for BN. In GE15, PN captured 73 federal seats compared to BN’s 30.

Accepting incumbency as the baseline would force Umno to surrender dozens of its traditional Malay-majority constituencies across Perak, Pahang, Kedah, Perlis, Kelantan, Terengganu, Selangor and Melaka.

Early friction is already visible on the ground. In Perak’s Padang Rengas constituency, former four-term Umno MP Nazri Aziz signalled his desire to reclaim the seat, only for incumbent PN MP Azahari Hasan to publicly rule out stepping aside.

Multiply that dispute across 40 or 50 rural constituencies, and the fragility of a BN-PN federal pact becomes immediately clear.

Furthermore, BN enters these negotiations with vastly different leverage than it had in 2022. A solo landslide victory in Johor in July 2026 – where BN won 48 of 56 state seats while PN was completely wiped out with just 5.45% of the popular vote – proved that Umno has regained significant strength in the south.

In Johor, where BN holds nine parliamentary seats to PN’s two, BN has strong grounds to demand the lion’s share of the state’s 26 federal seats. At the same time, internal pressure within both coalitions leaves little room for compromise.

BN components like MIC have urged the leadership to abandon strict incumbency rules so that non-Umno partners are not sidelined, while BN reportedly aims to contest at least 115 federal seats to lead the next federal government.

If PN refuses to accommodate BN’s demand for more parliamentary seats, Zahid has ensured that he has an escape route: continuing or deepening his coalition’s cooperation with PH.

From a purely territorial standpoint, a BN-PH electoral pact offers far less friction than a deal with PN. Because PH’s electoral strength is concentrated in urban and mixed-ethnic constituencies, there is minimal overlap with Umno’s rural Malay heartland seats.

Rather than fighting over the same traditional Malay constituencies, BN and PH could divide the electoral map along geographic and demographic lines, allowing BN to contest the large slate of rural seats it desires without yielding ground to PAS and its allies.

Additionally, BN and PH already share an established working relationship as formal partners in the federal unity government, a tie Zahid notably reaffirmed even while celebrating BN’s victory with PN in Melaka.

Beyond coalition deals, BN’s dominant solo performance in Johor leaves open the possibility of contesting GE16 independently in select regions without fielding candidates in all 222 seats.

However, pivoting back to PH carries severe electoral risks for BN. The primary motivation behind BN’s state-level cooperation with PN was to eliminate three-cornered fights and prevent the splitting of Malay votes.

Walking away from PN to align with PH in GE16 would almost certainly trigger fierce three-way battles across Peninsular Malaysia, allowing PH to capitalise on divided Malay support.

Moreover, constantly shifting between PH and PN could create the perception that Umno prioritises short-term seat calculations over a consistent ideological direction, especially as identity-based politics recently favoured the BN-PN formula in peninsula state polls.

When weighing these competing realities, the most probable outcome is that BN will ultimately return to cooperating with PH for GE16 – or pursue a hybrid strategy anchored by a PH pact – rather than forge a full federal alliance with PN.

For Umno, politics is fundamentally about survival and relevance, and a coalition deal that locks it out of dozens of its traditional Malay heartland seats is a non-starter.

PAS and its allies have little incentive to surrender hard-won parliamentary constituencies to revive their chief rival for the Malay vote, making a comprehensive BN-PN seat compromise virtually impossible.

By contrast, PH offers BN the exact political oxygen it needs: a clear, uncontested runway to rebuild in rural Malay constituencies while PH secures urban and mixed seats.

While returning to PH risks splitting the Malay vote, BN’s commanding 2026 state victories suggest it now possesses the momentum to weather three-cornered fights – something it could never achieve while confined to the junior-partner status PN would inevitably impose.

Moaz Nair is an FMT reader.

The views expressed are those of the writer and do not necessarily reflect those of FMT.

Subscribe to our newsletter and get news delivered to your mailbox.

View the original on Free Malaysia Today →

KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.