Anger Index: Why Texas Tech, Tennessee and the Group of 6 should be mad
In the aftermath of the College Football Playoff committee's first set of rankings, there was a clear through-line that wasn't hard to decipher. The committee was putting all of its stock in top-tier wins.
That meant strength of schedule. That meant strength of conference. That meant strength of record. Never mind that all three of those things include the same metric to gauge degree of difficulty. Including so many metrics that measure opponent strength is like how Inuits have 100 different words for snow. Opponent strength is a really big deal in committee culture.
The result was that Alabama was ranked far higher than anyone outside that committee room believed it should be. Ditto Texas. Same for Oregon.
That approach also meant teams such as UCLA, Notre Dame and Wake Forest got the Rodney Dangerfield treatment because their schedules were bereft of big names.
To paraphrase the great Walter Sobchak in "The Big Lebowski," you can say what you will about the strength of schedule metric, dude, but at least it's an ethos, and that approach shows up loud and clear again this week. South Carolina, Oklahoma, Florida and Ole Miss are all ranked despite four losses.
There is a corollary to the committee's "big win" philosophy though, and it was none other than the coach of the defending national champs who pointed out the issue after last week's rankings were released.
Now, it could be that Curt Cignetti was just a tad perturbed that the committee dropped Indiana five spots during an open date with chair Hunter Yurachek explaining the decision by noting that Indiana's off week came "at a bad time." In fairness, it's hard for the Big Ten to match the grueling nature of an SEC open date.
The obvious counterpoint to Cignetti's quip is that he is ready to schedule a high school JV team as a nonconference opponent any time. Still, for all the fair critiques of Indiana's lackluster scheduling of "big games," his team has lost only three times in 39 games -- twice to Ohio State and once to Notre Dame. Those are, in committee parlance, "good losses."
But perhaps it's a case of "right message, wrong messenger," because Cignetti has a valid point about the committee overlooking "bad losses."
For example, the No. 1 team in the country is Georgia. The Bulldogs lost at home to unranked Auburn. That's bad.
Or consider Texas, which has four wins over current FPI top-20 opponents but also lost to mediocre Florida and Oklahoma. That's really bad.
And how about those Ducks? Losing to Oklahoma State and Illinois -- who themselves have lost to Tulsa, Iowa State, Duke and Purdue -- isn't just bad. Those losses stink like the inside of Pistol Pete's mascot head after a late-August home game.
Maybe South Carolina picking up its fourth loss against Arkansas wasn't a "bad loss" after all, and the committee has imbued Ryan Silverfield with all that aura he was missing three months ago.
If a big win matters a lot, shouldn't a bad loss also carry some stigma? Maybe not a death knell but at least something as problematic as having been Dabo Swinney's offensive coordinator, right?
Or, perhaps Cignetti is just pointing at the wrong end of the formula, and it's his team that offers the perfect validation for why the committee's approach is misguided.
A decade ago, the notion of an elite team losing to a bad opponent was nearly unheard of. If it happened, it was either a complete fluke or a sign of some otherwise ephemeral weakness that hadn't yet shown up in the standings. But the talent gap between "good" and "bad" has shrunk -- and the gap between "pretty good" and "average" is virtually nonexistent these days. The bell curve used to be wide and the middle with long tails for the elite and the terrible. Now? It's shaped like Trevor Lauck standing between a couple of slot receivers.
Besides, the playoff isn't a measure of whether a team can potentially lose to a bad opponent. The question is whether you're good enough to beat a truly good team, or, more to the point, three or four of them.
So what if Texas lost to Oklahoma? The Longhorns have shown they're also good enough to beat Ohio State, Tennessee, Ole Miss and LSU. Do that in the playoff, and you might be a national champion.
Except, of course, Ole Miss and LSU aren't going to make the playoff this season (probably). Ohio State is hanging by a thread. Tennessee, good as that win over Alabama is, is really just doing a nice impression of Iowa this season with a stout defense, a good power run game and a passing attack that has mustered only four touchdown passes over its past seven games.
None of that is to say those aren't still good wins. It's just that, like a sommelier feels about champagne, the committee has a tendency to believe "big wins" can only be grown in the SEC. Everything else is just a sparkling Big 12 team.
Consider the current ranking for toughest schedules: Eight of the top 10 are SEC schools. Why? Because to be strong, you need to play SEC schools.
Or look at ESPN's FPI metric, which is a measure of team quality (not a ranking of résumé): Texas A&M, at 4-6, checks in higher than Houston, Boise State or SMU, and 6-4 LSU checks in at No. 7, ahead of Indiana, Wake Forest, Utah and UCLA. Ten of the top 30 teams have four losses or more, and all 10 are from the SEC or Big Ten.
Play in the SEC or have brand name cachet from the Big Ten, you're "good." The only way for anyone else to be considered "good" is not to lose, and even then, they face criticism for a lack of "good" wins because the teams they beat ... lost.
Georgia's loss to Auburn can't be bad, because Auburn beat Georgia, which makes Auburn pretty good. Wake Forest's win over Louisville can't be good, because Louisville lost to Wake Forest, which makes Louisville mediocre at best.
If the committee isn't going to follow Cignetti's logic on "bad losses," we get it. But if bad losses are mitigated by a condensed power structure and more evenly distributed talent nationally, then the opposite has to be true, too. The supposed "good" teams aren't as good as they used to be, and the supposed pushovers might be a good bit tougher than we expected.
The bottom line is the committee's rationale has some merit. It is, believe it or not, borderline progressive. But it's a half-measure, when the reality that surrounds them demands a full accounting on both sides of the ledger.
The world has changed. Cignetti, after all, is the one who showed us the way.
On to this week's Anger Index.

1. Texas Tech Red Raiders (9-1, No. 12)
Let's do a little blind résumé, shall we?
Team A: SP+ No. 10, No. 11 strength of record, three wins vs. FPI top 40, worst loss to SP+ No. 60
Team B: SP+ No. 14, No. 12 strength of record, three wins vs. FPI top 40, worst loss to SP+ No. 68
There's not a ton separating them, but slight edge to Team A, right?
Well, what if we said Team B had the better win, but it came in controversial fashion. Also, Team B has one more loss than Team A. And Team A has looked completely different over the past three weeks with a new QB at the helm, putting up 139 points in the past three games?
OK, so Team A is the Red Raiders, who've found a spark with Tommy Castellanos at QB, and certainly look nothing like the team that lost at Cincinnati last month.
Team B is BYU, which plays in the same conference and has roughly the same schedule, save a win over Notre Dame. That win, of course, was tainted in part by a missed pass interference call and then an admitted mismanagement of the clock and, even in the best of readings, still saw the Cougars nearly blow a 21-10 halftime lead at home. They have also looked entirely mediocre since.
But, guess who's ranked higher? That'd be BYU. And if the playoff started today, BYU would be in, and Texas Tech would be out.
Somewhere, Cody Campbell has a cadre of interns working on legislation to stop this right now.
2. The Group of 6
To be fair to the committee, it's slim pickings at the bottom of the top 25 these days. If we consider "playoff contenders" to be power-conference schools with three or fewer losses and Group of 6 schools with one or fewer, then we can pen in every single name that qualifies and still not fill out a full top 25. Just 24 teams fit that bill -- the fewest of any year of the playoff era at this point and 10 less than this time last year.
So, what's a committee to do?
The AP voters made a choice. They dipped into the Group of 6, adding 9-1 Liberty and 8-2 Memphis to the top 25.
And, in years past, there's a good chance the committee might've done the same. Not now though. Not with a 24-team playoff on the horizon.
Now, the bottom of the top 25 is ... the lower-middle class of the SEC. Welcome, ugly Oklahoma. Welcome, the rotting husk of Florida. Have a seat, South Carolina. This committee not only doesn't punish teams for QB injuries now, it rewards them!
The bottom line is that the committee has made it clear there's no place in the top 25 for a Group of 6 team that hasn't proven its bona fides against at least one top-tier Power 4 foe, and since top-tier Power 4 foes have effectively zero incentive to schedule good Group of 6 opponents, the math simply doesn't math anymore.
3. Louisville Cardinals (7-3, No. 23)
What happened to bad losses not counting in the committee's eyes? Louisville has three Ls on the year, all by three points. Two are to ranked foes -- Ole Miss in Week 1 and Wake Forest. The third though? That's NC State, and yeah, that's bad. But it came at a time when the Wolfpack still had some life, and in a game when Louisville's ball security was akin to a toddler chasing Roomba.
So, Louisville is really behind a four-loss South Carolina team that just fell to Arkansas? Or a four-loss Oklahoma team that mustered 10 points in a loss to Michigan?
Even with that ugly loss, Louisville's strength of record (No. 27) is right in line with Arizona (No. 25) and Houston (No. 26), while the Cardinals' SP+ (No. 17) is well ahead of both. How about big wins? Louisville has three wins over FPI top 40 teams. Houston has one. Arizona has none.
Then there's this: Louisville's defense is not ideal. But offensively, the Cardinals are one of the most explosive teams in the country. They do something well. Really well. Elite, even. If we're talking fringe playoff teams, do we really want to add someone whose ceiling is low but floor is high? Or do we want a team that could actually make some noise if it's hitting on all cylinders?
4. Tennessee Volunteers (8-2, No. 9)
We've made the case before that the guy who's supposed to remind the committee about head-to-head steps out of the room to get an Oatmeal Pie from the vending machine each time Tennessee and Alabama are discussed. Two teams with the same record, separated by six spots in the rankings, despite the lower-ranked team having the head-to-head win is utterly nonsensical. But let's set that aside for just a moment and look at another set of blind résumés.
Team A: 8-2, two losses by combined six points to committee Nos. 22 and 24, best wins vs. committee Nos. 9 and 14 by a combined four points
Team B: 8-2, two losses by combined six points to committee Nos. 5 and 21, best wins vs. committee Nos. 3 and 16 by a combined 44 points
Again, it's awfully close, but the margin of victory against top-tier teams would seem to give Team B the edge, right?
Well, here's the rub: Team B is Tennessee, which lost to Team A, Texas.
But hold on ... didn't the committee decide that head-to-head doesn't matter when it comes to Tennessee?
Regardless, putting the Vols six places behind Alabama and four behind Texas feels like a massive oversight. More importantly, if the playoff started today, that placement would have Tennessee going on the road to play Indiana, while Texas would be hosting Boise State. Hardly a fair shake.
5. Missouri Tigers (6-4, unranked)
If the committee is going to rank four four-loss SEC teams, but not LSU, we get it. Everyone likes sticking it to Lane Kiffin.
But to ignore Missouri? The team who has squatter's rights to a spot somewhere between Nos. 19 and 24 because it has been there so long? That's just criminal.
Missouri beat Florida head-to-head. The Gators are ranked, Missouri is not.
Missouri beat Arkansas by 24. Arkansas just beat South Carolina by 28. How does that work out to the Gamecocks being ranked No. 21 and Missouri out altogether?
All four of Missouri's losses were to teams ranked at the time: Oklahoma, Florida, Ole Miss. South Carolina can't say that.
Moreover, we fear what leaving Missouri unranked does to the fragile ecosystem of our society. It's like a glitch in the Matrix. It's entirely possible this is the root cause of all these air travel delays.
Also angry this week: SMU Mustangs (7-3, unranked), Duke Blue Devils (7-3, unranked), Notre Dame Fighting Irish (9-1, No. 6 and jumped by Texas), Lane Kiffin, Auburn Tigers (6-4, unranked with a better SoR than five ranked teams).
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.