Win the Mall has an irresistible fantasy, but its format kept me watching

The fantasy of Netflix’s Win the Mall makes it immediately alluring, but it’s a clear format that really makes it work where other competitions have failed.
Who hasn’t wanted to have free rein of a real, empty mall, roller skating around, walking behind a counter to make your own smoothies, or drive the floor polisher, smear Lush products on your face, and lounge in a mattress store’s beds?
The glossy footage could be mistaken for a commercial as they frolic around a sparkling indoor mall, the CF Sherway Gardens in Toronto. The production installed LED walls and a few fake storefronts, such as a Guitar Center that confused poor Canadian shoppers.
Win the Mall grounds all aspects of the competition in the mall and uses the space well. Players meet to strategize in the food court and load massive shopping bags with merchandise in a challenge. (The show tries to pretend they’re staying overnight, rather than filming in the evenings, and it’s almost comical how the s.)
Despite the title, no one is actually winning this mall, or its stores, or their contents. While players are in Amazing Race-style pairs, the game they’re playing is a lot more cohesive and immediately engaging than the slog that was Wonka’s The Golden Ticket.
Each round begins with a team challenge, the Grand Opening. The winning pair gets prizes and the power to choose one team for the elimination challenge, the Closeout. That team picks their opposition, and the challenge losers get their credit card cut and leave.
The prizes are “stores,” which in reality means actual gifts, from KFC food to an SUV, and also becomes in-game dollars. Just like on Fox’s The Floor, they accumulate territory from their wins (the stores) and take the territory from teams they defeat.
This sounds more confusing that it is! It all comes together well in a game where people have power to affect their own trajectory, and also need to work with other teams.
What works best is that is that its challenges are creative combinations of phsyicality and strategy, and all grounded in mall life and shopping, from stuffing a car full of merch to becoming an actual claw in a claw machine.
Think Supermarket Sweep + Shop Til You Drop x 1 million. The production appears to have taken over an empty anchor store, using it for some challenge and other sets. But no one is Supermarket Sweeping here; going into actual stores to shop, there are special tags on special racks. (I cannot imagine the logistical challenge to plan this, never mind set all this up every night.)
The second episode introduces the Power Store, where players can buy prizes or signfiicant advantages with in-game cash earned from challenges. such as Maura Higgins’ $20,000 Hermès Birkin. The prizes are impressive and the advantages powerful and diabolical.
An episode-three game is a simple white elephant swap of boxes, with teams able to swap their box after asking other teams about what’s in their boxes.
Jaden tries not to reveal anything and his cheeks turn bright red before he makes a swap. In an interview, his teammate Luke tells him, in an interview later, “That’s not smart.” Jaden interrupts: “Can you let me finish my fucking thought?” Luke doesn’t: “This is not a good moment right now for you. Just let me explain it.”
These are the moments I found most interesting: disagreements between teammates. “Don’t tell anyone that. Not even the camera, not anyone,” a mom tells her daughter.
Most of the cast falls into the usually Netflix competition collection of pretty young influencers—so young I cannot believe they have the affection for malls that I do as an elder millennial. But they are entertaining.
Observe “Florida Boys” Haven (“a follower of Christ” trying to play a Netflix game like Jesus would) and Gibson (not—at least, not out loud) in every interview, where Gibson seems embarrassed to be sharing a continent with Haven. Asked about the performance of a team of older women in a challenge, this is how they answer:
Haven: “They look pretty mobile. They are moms, after all. They have a lot of, you know,m probably injuries and child-bearing. There’s a lot that goes into being a mom, so I’m surprised at how agile they are.”
Gibson: “I would have a different answer to that question.”
The self-awareness of perception is an interesting layer. Engineers Megan and Shavani, whose family just lost their house in a fire, talk to another team, and Megan says “we don’t want to be a sob story.”
One team is Hailey and Bailey, which is especially confusing because the host is Haley Baylee—influencer, model, and Let’s Marry Harry: The Reunion host. She gives far too much game information via ADR, which I’m always suspicious of. But she’s great when just reacting to what she’s doing, like appearing from behind massive LED walls. “Sorry, I know this is going on Netflix and I’m single,” she says after one dramatic entrance.
In the Power Store, she takes on a snooty salesperson character. “Not interested in that Rolex, but yes to that shirt?” she asks one person.
Some elements don’t work. A maze challenge in (fake) air ducts is really clever, but the editing tries so hard to pretend that the players are actually in the ceiling that the actual race is unclear, even with on-screen graphics. And I have no idea why Jonathan Van Ness—who was described by Queer Eye crew members as a “demeaning” “monster” who screamed and was “intense and scary” in a Rolling Stone story—shows up to do literally nothing for a fashion show challenge.
Yet for a first-season show and brand-new format, Win the Mall is solid and assured, and most of all, a competition fueled by the fantasy of having a mall all to ourselves.
All of reality blurred’s content is independently selected, including links to products or services. However, if you buy something after clicking an affiliate link, we may earn a commission. Learn more.
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.