Indonesia's 20pct land rule clouds Malaysian planters

KUALA LUMPUR: Indonesian plantations owned by Malaysian companies face fresh regulatory uncertainty after the country introduced a new agrarian reform law.
The law could require businesses to set aside 20 per cent of their land for redistribution.
The key question hanging over the industry is whether the requirement will extend to existing plantation holdings.
This includes companies that have already complied with Indonesia's long-standing 20 per cent smallholder development obligation under the plasma scheme.
The lack of clarity over the law's scope and implementation has left plantation players awaiting further guidance from Indonesian authorities, with potentially significant implications for landholdings and future replanting activities.
IOI Corp Bhd group managing director and chief executive officer Datuk Lee Yeow Chor said industry players have yet to fully understand the legislation's scope due to a lack of further clarification from the authorities.
Speaking at the company's annual general meeting on Nov 4, Lee said Indonesia introduced a plasma scheme requiring plantation companies to allocate 20 per cent of their land for smallholder development about 15-20 years ago.
He said IOI Corp, which entered Indonesia's plantation sector in 2009, had complied with the existing requirement.
"All our plantations comply with that 20 per cent rule already," he said.
Lee said the new requirement could target older plantation companies that began operating before the plasma scheme was introduced.
He said these companies might need to surrender land to the government or smallholders when undertaking replanting activities.
Indonesia's parliament passed the Agrarian Reform Law on Sept 22 this year, establishing a broader framework to address land ownership concentration, land redistribution and agrarian conflicts.
CIMB Securities Sdn Bhd said a key provision affecting plantation companies is the introduction of limits on land ownership and control, including maximum landholding limits for business entities and their affiliates.
The firm said the law also provides for establishing a dedicated Agrarian Reform Implementing Institution under the president, responsible for planning, implementation, supervision and resolving agrarian conflicts.
"Based on publicly available reporting on the bill approved by parliament, holders of Hak Guna Usaha (HGU) and plantation business permits are subject to a provision requiring at least 20 per cent of the relevant land area to be provided for agrarian reform and land redistribution, while this land obligation may be replaced by profit sharing equivalent to 20 per cent," it said.
SD Guthrie Bhd said its Indonesian operations continue as normal as the group closely monitors developments surrounding the new legislation.
"SD Guthrie respects Indonesia's sovereign right to set its land and agrarian policy, and we operate there under valid land titles HGU and plantation permits, which are in line with prevailing laws and regulations," it said in an email reply to Business Times.
It said Indonesia's plantation regulatory framework had evolved from the traditional plasma model to the broader Facilitation of Community Plantation Development (FPKM) framework.
The framework allows alternative community development mechanisms, including economic programmes that provide equivalent benefits to surrounding communities.
SD Guthrie said it has progressively implemented a combination of plasma and FPKM initiatives to support local communities.
"The new Law on Agrarian Reform sets out broad principles. The actual thresholds calculation and implementation mechanism remain unknown and will depend on future implementing regulations," it said.
The group said it would not speculate on the potential impact on its assets, operations or earnings until further details become available.
It added that it is reviewing the law and engaging with the relevant authorities at the district, provincial and national levels.
Tradeview Capital fund manager Neoh Jia Man said the lack of implementation details makes it difficult to determine the potential implications for Malaysian plantation companies.
"We think it is too early to assess the impact of the new Agrarian Reform Law, as the law only sets out the framework and the details have yet to be revealed," he said.
Neoh said one of the main uncertainties is whether the new 20 per cent requirement would apply only to companies with outstanding plasma obligations or to all HGU holders.
He said companies that have not fulfilled their smallholder land allocation obligations could be required to do so within one year.
"If they fail, they must pay the equivalent of 20 per cent of profits to surrounding communities. However, it is unclear whether this applies only to companies with unmet plasma obligations or to all HGU holders," he said.
Other uncertainties include the maximum landholding limit, which has yet to be finalised, and compensation arrangements for existing landowners affected by the legislation.
Neoh said the worst-case scenario could significantly impact the upstream Indonesian operations of Malaysian plantation companies.
However, he does not expect any immediate impact on their financial results, given that implementing regulations are only due within a year.
MBSB Research similarly said the earnings impact could be material but would depend on how the legislation is implemented.
The firm cautioned that the reported 20 per cent redistribution requirement should not be interpreted as an automatic reduction in existing plantation landbanks.
It said Malaysian plantation companies have substantial exposure to Indonesia, with the country accounting for 57 per cent of Kuala Lumpur Kepong Bhd's (KLK) planted area, between 53 and 56 per cent of Genting Plantations Bhd's and 31.3 per cent of SD Guthrie's.
In comparison, IOI Corp has a relatively smaller Indonesian exposure of 12.4 per cent.
According to the companies' annual reports, KLK's Indonesian plantations covered 168,563 hectares out of a total planted area of 301,090 hectares, while SD Guthrie reported 174,586 hectares of planted oil palm in Indonesia in 2025.
Genting Plantations 2025 report shows that it has a landbank of about 64,100 hectares in Malaysia and about 179,100 hectares in Indonesia, including plasma schemes.
Other Malaysian groups with Indonesian plantation operations include United Plantations Bhd, which has 8,731 hectares of oil palm planted in Indonesia, alongside 1,378 hectares of plasma land.
United Malacca Bhd also has an Indonesian plantation operation, PT Lifere Agro Kapuas, in Central Kalimantan.
Its landbank, including plasma areas, stood at 24,607 hectares, of which 13,363 hectares were planted with oil palm as at April 30, 2025.
IOI Corp recorded 21,369 hectares of planted oil palm area in Indonesia, according to its 2026 report.
MBSB Research said Indonesia remains an important production and earnings base for Malaysian plantation companies despite the regulatory uncertainty.
The firm said replacing established Indonesian operations elsewhere would require substantial capital and several years.
It added that Indonesian estates could become increasingly important in supporting plantation output and cash flow as Malaysian plantation companies explore alternative uses for their domestic land, including industrial parks and solar farms.
"As planters pursue these new income streams, Indonesian estates remain a key pillar supporting plantation output and cash flow while the new businesses build scale," it said.
Neoh said Indonesia continues to offer advantages in land availability and lower labour costs compared with Malaysia.
However, he said companies with substantial Indonesian exposure should consider diversifying into other markets to reduce their dependence on a single regulatory environment.
"We think companies that tackle the regulatory requirements head-on will be better positioned in the market.
"That said, it is important not to rely too heavily on a single market with an unstable regulatory regime.
"Hence, diversifying into other markets could be a good move for those with high Indonesian exposure," he said.
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.