The Daily Newsstand · Free, Always
Saturday, November 21, 2026

Why is Hulu’s The Circle so bad? 3 reasons

Translate

The same week that The Traitors: New Blood ended its meager first season on NBC, production company Studio Lambert has another of its competition series launching a new season in a new home.

The Circle season eight is on Hulu, ported over from Netflix, which cancelled/abandoned it after four years. How would the change refresh the show? Would it

And just like with NBC’s Traitors, Studio Lambert has given us a clunky version of a format they’ve perfected. It’s an excellent illustration of the effect a show’s home—and its current executives, and their current priorities—have on a show’s creative.

Everything about Hulu’s version is a shadow of its former self. Even The Circle’s vibrant theme song is now muted and sad.

After 15 minutes of the Hulu version, I switched over to Netflix to watch the start of The Circle season 1 to see if I was misremembering or idealizing. Nope. Netflix’s version is immediately cheesy, opening with some stagey shots of the cast in their apartments, but is visually arresting and .

Was I remembering the show wrong? I went back to my January 2020 review of season one,

Maybe the format just ran its course over seven seasons. After all, season five switched to a dating/singles theme, which is never a good sign, and season six added an AI bot.

And it’s worth remembering that Netflix’s version followed two seasons of the show airing in the UK, so it wasn’t starting from zero—but it did remove the real-time, viewer participation format that Hulu just brought back.

I cannot imagine watching three hours of this for the next three weeks—because I wasn’t compelled to make it through the first three hours. Here are the three major problems that stood out to me as I watched:

The cast is a Disney ad

The first five minutes are consumed by Vanderpump Rules Lisa Vanderpump who’s not even on the show, but her Vanderpump Villa employee Dominic DeAngelis is catfishing as her.

That makes it just feels like a promo, whereas the original two catfish were 1) designed to intentionally prevent judgment and 2) so poorly conceived it ended up with a straight man flirting with other straight men who are seeing his actual girlfriend’s picture.

We also have Hulu trying to bleed every last drop from Secret Lives of Mormon Wives with Layla Taylor and give some Disney synergy with DWTS pro Sasha Farber and Bachelor Nation’s Hannah Brown.

And that’s before Derek Hough shows up to host a challenge on a show that already has a host. No.

The Circle doesn’t need celebrities. The idea is that the players don’t know if the other players are being honest about themselves or just playing the game. But with a bunch of reality celebrities who need screen time, they overshadow the regular players, in the game and in the show.

“Hannah Brown? What are you guys doing to me?” one of the non-celeb players says. The answer: Making the show about them rather than what used to make The Circle interesting, alas.

Its new host, oof

New host Tinx is the food on an AI-generated menu: such a bizarre misfire I cannot believe anyone thought was a good idea. Like those hideous menus, did anyone even look at the end product?

Replacing an experienced comedian, Michelle Beauteu, with a TikToker feels like a decision to pander to the audience. That’s nothing new; remember when Tim Tebow attempted to host a CBS competition?

Tinx’s voiceover both tries to hard and sounds like the show accidentally left in temporary voiceover done by an editor that the host was supposed to dub. (That’s very common, so the editors can get the pacing right and the host just says what’s been scripted.)

This may not be her fault. Tinx may be be getting bad producing. And Netflix’s The Circle host Michelle Buteau wasn’t hosting and narrating in real time.

Then again, Love Island narrator Iain Sterling does two seasons of Love Island simultaneously. And Michelle Buteau brought a thousand times more warmth and personality to The Circle, which was evident from the first second she was on screen. Her commentary and judgement of the players had the kind of winking nod that enhanced the show. Tinx just interrupts it.

So far, being in real time has added nothing

Besides celebrity players, Hulu’s The Circle changed to a Love Island and Big Brother format: being produced and airing in near real time.

The only reason to do that is to allow viewers to have influence on the game. We can debate whether that’s a good idea (rarely, don’t @ me), but so far it’s delivered nothing.

Hulu is producing a show in real time, putting pressure on all parts of the production, and has so far used that to:

  1. Let viewers pick “Doug” or “Steven” for Layla and Kate’s persona
  2. Let viewers pick “Cyrus” or “Doug” for Suave’s new clone persona

Clones and pairs of catfish and Lisa Vanderpump and a fake dog are just too many hats on what’s already a hat: a game where people talk through screens, connecting and doubting. Sorry, Hulu’s The Circle, you’re blocked.

All of reality blurred’s content is independently selected, including links to products or services. However, if you buy something after clicking an affiliate link, we may earn a commission. Learn more.

View the original on Reality Blurred →

KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.