‘Practical Magic 2’ should have stuck with the original spell book

The sequel sacrifices some whimsy in favor of a more genuinely spooky undertone that doesn’t quite fit

Getting a sequel greenlit nearly 30 years after the original movie floundered upon its release likely required a stroke of magic.

1998’s Practical Magic, led by Sandra Bullock and Nicole Kidman as the Owens family witches, eventually became a cult classic, finding its footing with a home video release and subsequently, streaming services and social media.

So 28 years later, the original stars are back, the midnight margaritas return and even the iconic coastal Massachusetts home at the heart of the first film was rebuilt for the ultimate punch of nostalgia. Enough time has passed since the original movie that its ’90s wardrobe is back in style.

Nicole Kidman, left, and Sandra Bullock in a scene from Practical Magic 2.

Photo: AP

But Practical Magic 2 abandons some of the original’s best elements, including the campy fun that helped it find an unlikely second life.

The first movie was a blend of Death Becomes Her and Halloweentown, but the sequel sacrifices some of that whimsy in favor of a more genuinely spooky undertone that doesn’t quite fit. Where a pentagram in the original is forged with whipped cream, it’s done with fire in the sequel.

We pick up shortly after the 1998 film ended, with the Owens sisters seeing the curse that has afflicted their family of witches for generations playing out yet again. Sally (Bullock) becomes a widow once more after her second husband meets an untimely demise, as do all men who fall in love with an Owens woman.

Lee Pace, left, and Sandra Bullock in a scene from Practical Magic 2.

Photo: AP

She forces her sister Gillian (Kidman) and her aunts Jet and Franny (Dianne Wiest and Stockard Channing) to swear they won’t tell her two young daughters of their magical abilities or the curse, and casts a spell to make them forget about their witchy childhoods. Fast forward to when those young girls (a terrific Joey King and an underutilized Maisie Williams) are adults taking an interest in romance, and chaos ensues.

Sally’s daughter Kylie (King) propels the at times meandering plot forward through her mission to undo the Owens family curse after her boyfriend, Gideon (Xolo Mariduena), slips into a coma. Sally and Gillian follow her to England to try to keep her safe from dark magic.

This is where the spooky-playful energy of the original is swapped out for a more spooky-creepy tone. Perhaps more eerie elements come with the territory of a major studio’s release during the ever-expanding Halloween season. But Practical Magic 2 lacks the moments of pure fun — like Bullock asking PTA moms to form a coven or Kidman telling neighbors to hang onto their husbands when she’s back in town — that made the original film’s darker moments more admissible.

There are still charming, tender moments in the film, propelled by its strong performances. Bullock and Kidman serve up the comedic high points while the emotional heft is deftly carried by Channing, Wiest and King.

Lee Pace delivers as the charming British scholar of witchcraft and magic who helps Sally and Gillian in their quest to save Kylie, while also serving as a love interest for the romance-resistant Sally.

But the movie’s strongest bond is between Bullock and Kidman, who are good friends offscreen. Their connection to each other, and with director Susanne Bier, who has worked with each of them, keeps the lengthy sequel afloat.

Like the original, the sequel has a strong soundtrack and score that help to carry the story through its back-and-forth between lighter and darker moments. Don’t worry, Stevie Nicks is back. As is Harry Nilsson’s Coconut.