Why organisational transformation fails: The human factor

KODAK was once synonymous with photography. Interestingly, the company had developed one of the earliest digital cameras in 1975, yet it struggled to adapt as digital photography transformed the industry.
Although Kodak invested in digital imaging and introduced digital products, it struggled to develop a sustainable business model as the market shifted away from traditional film photography.
Its dependence on the traditional film business and difficulty in reshaping its business model contributed to its eventual decline.
Kodak's experience illustrates an important lesson about organisational transformation. Recognising the need for change is not the same as being able to implement it.
An organisation may have the technology, resources and even a sound strategy, but still struggle to transform itself.
This underscores an important point: organisational transformation rarely fails simply because the strategy is wrong. More often organisations underestimate the human, managerial and cultural changes needed to make the strategy work.
Employees may resist unfamiliar ways of working, managers may be reluctant to relinquish authority, and established organisational cultures may continue to reinforce old habits.
Leaders may speak about empowerment, collaboration and innovation while continuing to centralise decisions.
Employees notice the contradiction, Leaders must therefore lead by example.
Microsoft, under Satya Nadella, sought to move away from entrenched culture of internal competition towards greater collaboration and a growth mindset.
This illustrates that transformation requires changes in leadership behaviour and organisation culture and not merely a new corporate strategy.
Another challenge arises when middle managers become an obstacle to transformation.
Middle managers are often expected to implement transformation while continuing to meet existing targets.
They may feel threatened by new structures, reduced authority or unfamiliar responsibilities. Consequently, they may slow down or resist implementation.
Nokia provides an example. During its struggle to respond to the rise of smartphones, the company experienced a culture of fear that affected communication between senior and middle management.
Middle managers who feared the reactions from senior management were reluctant to communicate negative news upwards.
As a result, problems were concealed, and senior management developed an overly optimistic picture of Nokia's position and its ability to compete Consequently, Nokia struggled to respond effectively to the changing market and gradually lost its competitive edge to rivals such as Apple and Samsung.
A 2016 study by Timo O. Vuori and Quy Huy found that fear within Nokia's management affected communication, with middle managers reluctant to convey bad news to senior leaders.
This contributed to the company's inability to respond effectively to the smartphone challenge.
A further reason organisational transformation fails is that organisations attempt to change their structures without changing the underlying culture.
The merger between Germany's Daimler-Benz and America's Chrysler in 1998 provides a good example.
The two organisations had very different organisational cultures. Daimler-Benz was generally associated with a more formal and hierarchical management style, while Chrysler was generally regarded as having a more informal and flexible working culture.
These are broad characterisations of their respective management approaches, rather than descriptions of every part of the two organisations.
Despite the merger, the two companies struggled to integrate their different management approaches. Tensions emerged, and in 2007, Daimler sold its Chrysler division, effectively ending the merger.
The lesson is that changing the corporate structure does not automatically change organisational culture. Unless management addresses differences in values, working practices and attitudes, even major restructuring or merger can fail.
Poor communication is another factor that can undermine transformation by creating uncertainty.
Employees need to understand why an organisation is changing, what the changes mean for their jobs and how they are expected to contribute.
When management announces major changes without explaining them properly, employees may become confused, anxious and resistant.
Rumours can spread, morale may decline and implementation becomes difficult.
J.C. Penny provides a useful example. In 2012 its newly appointed CEO Ron Johnson introduced a major transformation of the American retailer.
He replaced the familiar system of frequent discounts and coupons with an everyday low-pricing strategy and introduced changes to the store layout and merchandise.
However, the new approach was not well received by many of its core customers, and the pricing system proved confusing.
Employees also faced the challenge of implementing a radically different retailing approach. Customers became uncertain about the new pricing policy, and many stopped shopping at its stores.
Sales fell sharply, and the company recorded a net loss of about US$985 million in 2012. Johnson was dismissed in April 2013, after just 17 months as a CEO.
The company's difficulties had several contributing causes, including its pricing changes, declining sales and the challenge of implementing a broad retail transformation.
The case demonstrates that a demonstration cannot succeed simply because the management believes that the new direction is right.
People must understand the change, see its value and know how to respond to it.Even when employees understand the need for change, they may not be equipped to implement it.
Organisations may introduce new technology, systems and working practices, expecting employees to adapt quickly.
However, employees cannot be expected to deliver results if they are not given adequate training, resources and authority.
Management may announce an ambitious transformation, but frontline employees are left struggling to put it into practice.
Target's expansion into Canada provides an example. In 2013, the US retail chain opened stores in Canada, but its rapid expansion was accompanied by serious supply-chain and inventory management problems.
Stores in Canada had empty shelves or incorrect stock levels. The expansion was launched before the inventory and supply-chains were functioning reliably, with inaccurate product information and weakness in the systems used to manage stock and distribution.
The company struggled to correct these operational problems and eventually closed all 133 of its Canadian stores in 2015.
While some organisations struggle to sustain transformation, Lego demonstrates how consistent leadership commitment can turn an organisation around.
In 2004, the Danish toy manufacturer was facing serious financial difficulties after expanding into too many areas and losing focus on its core business.
Under CEO Jørgen Vig Knudstorp, the company embarked on a sustained turnaround, selling non-core businesses, simplifying its product lines, improving operational efficiency and refocusing on its iconic building bricks.
Rather than treating transformation as a short-term cost-cutting exercise, management maintained its focus on the changes over several years.
Lego gradually restored profitability and re-established itself as one of the world's leading toy manufacturers.
Its experience demonstrates that successful transformation requires consistent leadership commitment, strategic discipline and the patience to make changes stick.
Organisational transformation is not simply about introducing a new strategy, restructuring departments or investing in technology. It requires a fundamental change in how people think, work and make decisions.
Leaders must communicate the purpose of change, address resistance, empower employees and ensure that managers at every level are committed to the new direction.
As the examples of Nokia, J.C. Penney, Target and Lego demonstrate, a strategy can succeed or fail depending on how effectively it is translated into action.
Ultimately, transformation is not measured by what an organisation announces, but by what it manages to change and sustain.
* The writer holds an MBA from the University of Strathclyde, United Kingdom, awarded under the British Chevening Scholarship programme. With extensive experience in the financial markets and management education, he also served at a prominent think tank. The views expressed are his own and do not necessarily reflect those of Business Times
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.