From reform champions to excuse makers: PH’s painful fall from grace


Pakatan Harapan can blame racial politics, a polarised electorate, and the growing strength of its political rivals all it wants, but after another bruising defeat in Melaka, perhaps it’s time the coalition look in the mirror.
Saturday’s results saw Barisan Nasional win 21 seats, and its ally, Perikatan Nasional, three. PH’s share was reduced to just four, one fewer than it secured in the 2021 polls.
It was another electoral setback following its poor showing in Johor and Negeri Sembilan.
Yet, if past experience is anything to go by, the coalition’s post-mortem could once again revolve around familiar explanations: racial politics, the Malay vote, and its inability to penetrate the rural constituencies.
There is no denying that race and religion influence voters here, but these factors cannot forever serve as convenient explanations for PH’s electoral shortcomings.
At what point does the coalition stop asking why voters are supposedly influenced by racial politics and start asking why those same voters are no longer convinced that PH deserves their support?
A coalition that has forgotten its promises
One of PH’s biggest problems is its reluctance to confront the gap between what it promised before entering government and what it has delivered.
The coalition came to power in 2018 promising institutional reforms, greater accountability, transparency, and a cleaner political culture. But eight years later, how much of that enthusiasm remains?
PH cannot expect support simply because it once represented an alternative to BN.
It has been in government since November 2022, with Anwar Ibrahim as prime minister and its components holding important ministerial positions. It has had the opportunity to deliver on its promises.
Instead, voters are often given explanations about why reforms cannot be implemented or why political compromises are necessary.
Where are the apologies for promises that have been abandoned or watered down? Where is the sustained effort to reconnect with communities that feel neglected, not just when elections approach but throughout the term?
Perhaps the biggest contradiction is how PH has moved away from the principles it once championed.
The coalition previously fought for fairer parliamentary allocations, arguing that public funds should not be used as a political weapon against opposition MPs. Now, it withdraws the allocations for errant MPs.
Whatever the political justification, the irony is difficult to ignore. A coalition that once criticised the previous government for practising political discrimination now finds itself defending similar questions about the distribution of public resources.
Voters did not support PH merely to see a change in who exercises political power. They wanted a change in how that power was exercised.
The influencer experiment is backfiring
Another questionable aspect of PH’s political strategy is its reliance on social media influencers and content creators.
There’s nothing wrong with embracing digital campaigning, particularly to reach the younger voters. But there’s a difference between using social media effectively and assuming trendy videos, scripted skits and supposedly relatable content will translate into political support.
During GE15, PH’s campaign focused heavily on policy discussions, institutional reform, and fighting corruption. Today, some of its social media campaigning appears to have lost that seriousness.
PH has increasingly been associated with content that feels forced, cringey and disconnected from the supporters it’s trying to engage. Even some PH supporters have criticised these efforts online.
Politicians aren’t entertainers. A young voter struggling with stagnant wages, rising living costs and housing affordability is unlikely to be persuaded simply because a politician can perform a trending dance or deliver a rehearsed punchline.
PH appears to be mistaking social media engagement for genuine political engagement.
Parliament is not a ‘mamak’ stall
The conduct of some PH MPs has also become increasingly difficult to defend.
Parliament should be where MPs debate policies, scrutinise legislation and raise the concerns of their constituents. While the opposition has MPs who rely on provocative rhetoric and attempts to bait government representatives, PH MPs should know better than to fall into the same trap.
The behaviour of certain representatives, including RSN Rayer (Jelutong) and Sany Hamzan (Hulu Langat), raises questions about whether they understand the difference between robust parliamentary debate and simply creating a commotion.
There’s nothing wrong with being vocal or combative, but there must be substance behind the noise.
Voters want to hear what their MPs are doing about public transport, unemployment, housing and healthcare. They don’t elect representatives to turn parliamentary proceedings into something resembling a heated argument at a mamak stall.
Candidate selection isn’t a social media experiment
The Melaka election also exposed weaknesses in PH’s candidate selection.
Giving younger candidates an opportunity is commendable, but youth alone should never be the qualification for public office. Candidates must be properly vetted and demonstrate an understanding of the communities they intend to represent.
One candidate who attracted attention for the wrong reasons was Mukhlisul Mubin Julasapiyah (Kuala Linggi), better known as Mukhlis Mubin. His campaign leaned heavily into a Gen Z identity, complete with the tagline, “This is how Gen Z works”.
A campaign video attracted mixed reactions after he claimed to have secured a waiver of a penalty exceeding RM70,000 imposed on the Melaka Barat Area Fishermen’s Association within a day.
Mukhlis said he approached Anwar’s political secretary, who brought the matter to Anwar in his capacity as finance minister, who subsequently approved the waiver.
While helping an association representing 278 fishermen was commendable, the episode raised questions about the use of political connections to secure preferential treatment.
Critics questioned whether this was cronyism rather than the institutional reforms PH had promised.
There were also questions about his candidacy, given that his father had contested Kuala Linggi five times without winning.
PH must ask whether it selected candidates based on their ability to win public confidence or simply because they fitted a particular campaign narrative. An assemblyman needs considerably more than attractive online content to represent an entire constituency.
The electorate doesn’t owe PH another chance
Another longstanding weakness is PH’s grassroots machinery. The coalition cannot expect to build relationships through occasional visits and staged community engagements.
BN and PAS spent decades building networks through local leaders, party branches and community organisations. That machinery does not suddenly appear two weeks before polling day.
PH must understand that political loyalty is built through consistency, not campaign-season appearances. Perhaps the most uncomfortable truth the coalition needs to accept is that voters don’t owe it their loyalty.
Those who supported PH in 2018 did so because they believed it could deliver a better Malaysia. They weren’t signing a lifetime commitment to a party.
Some voters may not have rejected its reform agenda. They may simply have become disillusioned with the people entrusted to implement it.
Melaka should be more than another electoral setback followed by post-mortem meetings and familiar explanations. PH needs to take a hard look at its leadership, candidates, grassroots machinery, parliamentary conduct and, most importantly, its record in government.
Race and religion will remain part of Malaysian politics. But blaming racial politics every time voters turn away is not political analysis. It is an admission that the coalition has run out of answers.
PH once asked Malaysians to believe that a different kind of politics was possible. Now it must prove that that vision still deserves belief.
The question is no longer why voters are abandoning PH but why PH keeps giving them reasons to do so.
The writer is a journalist at FMT’s English Desk.
This article represents the writer’s opinion and does not necessarily reflect FMT’s position.
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.