Could a haredi traffic police unit help solve Israel's integration crisis? - opinion
It’s a natural human instinct to defend oneself against accusations, whether or not such accusations are justified. That’s what’s happening with the haredi (ultra-Orthodox) community. It’s wrong to generalize and declare that haredim don’t serve in the IDF. Some have, and some do. It’s equally wrong to say that they don’t do civilian National Service (Sherut Leumi). Again, some do, and some don’t. Of those who allegedly don’t, many perform community services within their own environment, but not under the banner of a state-run Zionist entity.
Instead of constantly castigating them, why not acknowledge their good deeds?
Such a gesture would put many in a better frame of mind.
Next, approach their spiritual leaders and suggest that while those of their followers who do good deeds within the community are to be commended, it would be appreciated if they could do a little more.
Just as the army is in dire need of additional soldiers, so is the police force.
Traffic police are seldom seen, which explains why traffic violations largely go unchecked.
The saving of a life is sacred in Judaism, and the lives of pedestrians are at risk every day.
If there was a national haredi police unit, it would free up non-haredi police to transfer to the army.
The haredi police division would not be under the direction of the National Security Ministry, but rather under whichever haredi legislator has either a ministerial portfolio or chairs a Knesset committee.
A way for haredim to contribute to Israeli society
Notwithstanding differences and rivalries among certain sectors of the haredi population, most genuinely do care for their fellow Jews. If it is pointed out to them that they can contribute to the saving of lives at minimal risk to their own lives, and their work schedules can be organized in such a manner as to allow time for Torah study, they may be more amenable to compromise, particularly because traffic violations also endanger the lives of haredim.
A haredi traffic unit would be charged with controlling and sometimes arresting jaywalkers, motorcyclists, bicyclists, scooter riders, and others who ignore traffic lights. Other candidates for arrest are car drivers who park on the sidewalk, forcing pedestrians to walk on the road, often in the face of oncoming traffic.
Empowering members of the haredi police force to arrest transgressors would give them a sense of importance, especially if their contributions to road safety are publicly recognized.
It’s not the ideal solution, but it is a step in the right direction.
The motorcyclists who most frequently break the rules are those engaged in food delivery services, because the whole idea is to deliver the order with the least delay. When the order consists of meals, they should still be hot at the time of delivery. To achieve this, motorcyclists ride on sidewalks, ignore traffic lights and crosswalks, and engage in illegal U-turns.
There are also other pedestrians who seem to be playing some form of Russian roulette by defiantly crossing the road on a red light.
A haredi traffic unit could make a considerable impact by having the authority to reduce or even stop such infringements.
It can be done if people care enough. For many years, it was permissible to smoke on public transport, including in airplanes. But once it was universally realized that this habit was detrimental to public health, laws were passed that ban smoking on public transport. It took some time for these laws to be observed, but public transport is now smoke-free. Additional regulations were passed, forbidding smoking at bus stops and on railway platforms, but these regulations have been more difficult to enforce.
Perhaps patrolling haredi traffic wardens might succeed in abolishing cigarettes in places where people wait for buses and trains.
If a haredi traffic police division is introduced, it could be a first step to other forms of National Service, and will lead to greater haredi integration into mainstream society and the workforce without sacrificing haredi values.
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.