Readers reply: when does a reasonable train route become unreasonable?

I recently made a return trip to Edinburgh from London on which both legs of the journey were either significantly delayed or cancelled. At Waverley station, a message over the public address system told us we could travel by any “reasonable” route, but what does that mean? What counts as reasonable and what doesn’t? And who decides? Grant, by email
Send new questions to nq@theguardian.com.
Readers reply
When does a reasonable train route become unreasonable? When it’s no longer on track. Sagarmatha1953
I’ll guess that an Edinburgh to London route that involves a two-week stopover in Paris will not be considered “reasonable”. DeclineToState
Surely just any route in a roughly straight line to where you are going? The only catch would be when you’ve bought a split ticket using specific companies. My daughter recently had a cancelled train travelling from Glasgow to Leeds, but because it was a split ticket via Carlisle, anything on the east coast line was out of the question. On the plus side, she’d paid a small amount extra for some insurance and got £50 back for a £20 ticket (student railcard, before anyone gets excited by the price). She also found that, contrary to my expectations, the staff in the information desk at Glasgow station were incredibly helpful, so that’s probably a good place to start. Esollec
Since flying tends to be cheaper than trains, on this journey it would in theory be reasonable, but I doubt they’d consider it so. Plus the cost to the environment may not be thought reasonable. LorLala
The public address system told us we could travel by any “reasonable” route, but what does that mean? I suspect when it comes to making a claim for a delayed or cancelled journey, it means you have a battle on your hands. salamandertome
It would be reasonable to go from Edinburgh to London via Glasgow. It would be unreasonable to go via Glasgow and Plymouth. thenewschmoo
Of course. But there are more nuanced journeys, aren’t there. These are extremes. But there is a line that will differentiate reasonable and unreasonable, and I guess the letter-writer wants to know how that is determined and by whom. lexicon_mistress
There’s a set of routing guides that covers most situations: for instance, if you want to go between London and Edinburgh you can go via Glasgow, via Sheffield, via Leeds, via Doncaster, etc. This is always allowed if you have an Any Permitted Route ticket. If you have a ticket which specifies an operator or a route, then it may be acceptable to take a different route. You’d need to check with staff. TheNewNo2
I don’t want to research train routes myself – I want an employee of the railway company to be on hand to advise me. This is why I always go by car, although Edinburgh to London is a bit of a stretch. Goldgreen
An actual person on hand to give actual advice? What a quaint concept these days … Kevcoe
There are rules, obviously. A direct train is always reasonable, however circuitous the route. As is a route up to three miles longer than the shortest possible route. Passing through the same station twice isn’t generally reasonable, apart from a specific list of “easements” where it makes sense to take a fast train that passes through your final destination shortly before stopping at major hub or terminus. You might think that any route that is faster than the shortest route is also reasonable, but this isn’t automatic. Strictly speaking, you need to check the manual, as other answers have said. During significant disruption (when it is announced that other companies are accepting tickets), staff apply their discretion, which was a bit of a lottery. Until last month, when we got the right to travel by any route suggested by the National Rail journey planner. MickeyFinn
An extra three miles doesn’t give options anywhere except major cities! zxcv11
It reads more like a chance or community chest card joke, so I’m not sure they are being serious. Luxembourgpro
Absolutely true, although I agree it sounds like parody. It’s called the Common Routing Point Rule. The National Routing Guide glossary (quoted below) is very clear on this point. MickeyFinn
When a journey is between stations that have one or more common routeing points, the permitted journey takes the route of shortest distance or any route no more than 3 miles longer, whether or not they pass through the common routeing point. Also permitted are journeys that use direct trains to and from the common routeing point.
A reasonable train route becomes unreasonable when the fare is too high. I always check for split-ticketing options and go the long way round if it’s cheaper, and not too much further. Much more reasonable! Rattandy
I reckon you’d have a reasonable case as long as you’re heading in the right general direction. Grumpyoldgit999
I’d say the quickest alternative route by train, assuming at least five minutes leeway each time you change trains, is the reasonable route. Anything other than that and they could argue that your ticket isn’t valid. That’s if they check the ticket – which they often don’t, particularly when staff are having to deal with disruption. RobertMeyerFunnell
The question-setter almost certainly has a ticket issued by a specific train company – LNER for the east coast mainline or Avanti for the west coast line. Normally, you have to travel on the line that you bought a ticket for, but if that’s disrupted you can use the other one. If everyone went on the faster east coast route then it would be overloaded, so it’s reasonable to spread the passengers across both east and west coast lines. It would be unreasonable if Edinburgh passengers tried to cut back to the east using the Settle or Transpennine lines, as then I would never get a seat. Randomusername222
If the people making that announcement can’t tell you, how are you supposed to know? It is their cock-up – they should come up with solutions. The only way you can get a small win is if you find a route that gets you closer to your actual destination. So for London, say your final destination is in the west, find an alternative that lands you at Paddington instead of the original Euston? catchytitled
The announcement clearly can’t cover all the stations that all passengers were heading to. Not everyone hoping to get on a train in Edinburgh is heading for London. Edgeley
In my experience, actually expecting a train to turn up at all isn’t considered “reasonable” by many of the staff, who know their precious railway would operate far more efficiently without all those pesky passengers. They may not be able to direct you to a platform but they can quote chapter and verse of the section of microscopic small print confirming your ticket isn’t valid before 11.30pm except on Tuesdays in June when Capricorn is in Uranus. Willie_Eckerslike
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.