Ismail’s resignation proper, but accountability must follow


Barely a day after my previous article questioned the trustworthiness of Ismail Lasim and the 10 former state executive councillors who attempted to remove Tuanku Muhriz Tuanku Munawir as the Yang Dipertuan Besar of Negeri Sembilan, a surprising development emerged.
Out of nowhere came an official announcement from Barisan Nasional (BN) secretary-general Zambry Abdul Kadir confirming that Ismail had relinquished his position as menteri besar.
My immediate reaction was one of relief. To my mind, Ismail’s decision to step aside offers Negeri Sembilan an opportunity to begin afresh.
What transpired over the past few weeks has left a profound stain on the state’s political and cultural landscape. The attempt to challenge the position of the state ruler crossed a line that many Malaysians, regardless of political persuasion, would find difficult to forgive.
A resignation, therefore, presents a chance to reset relations between the state government and the royal institution, allowing both to move forward in a spirit of reconciliation and stability.
In that regard, Ismail’s departure can be viewed as a sacrifice, albeit one made after an exceptionally brief tenure as menteri besar. If his resignation helps restore public confidence and preserves harmony within the state, it is a step that deserves acknowledgment.
But resignation alone is not enough.
Ismail and the 10 exco members who stood with him in this sorry episode should also publicly distance themselves from any factions within the adat establishment that remain unrepentant for their misdeeds.
Silence on this matter would leave room for doubt. If genuine remorse exists, it must be expressed clearly and unambiguously. The people of Negeri Sembilan deserve assurance that such an extraordinary breach of loyalty and respect towards the Yang Dipertuan Besar will never be repeated.
And for all the relief that accompanies this apparent reset, several questions remain unanswered.
The most obvious is this: why only now? Also, why did Ismail not announce his resignation personally? Why was the news conveyed through the BN secretary-general rather than by the menteri besar himself?
More importantly, why was the decision announced before the audience that Ismail reportedly sought with Tuanku Muhriz following the submission of the recent letter withdrawing the initial attempt to depose the ruler?
These questions matter because timing often reveals as much as action itself.
Had Ismail met Tuanku Muhriz and received a less-than-positive response to his apology, resignation would have seemed a logical, and perhaps honourable, next step.
One could understand a menteri besar concluding that the trust necessary to govern had broken down beyond repair. Such a sequence of events would have carried a certain political and moral coherence.
Instead, the resignation announcement arrived first.
This unusual chronology invites speculation. Was the resignation entirely Ismail’s own initiative? Or was it encouraged, suggested, or perhaps even deemed necessary by others who believed the crisis had reached a point that required immediate intervention?
I do not pretend to know the answer. But it is difficult not to find the circumstances intriguing.
Political turmoil such as the one we have witnessed needs a moment when old wounds are set aside for the greater good. But genuine reconciliation requires clarity, transparency and accountability. It cannot rest solely on declarations of goodwill.
The public has every right to understand how such a serious conflict emerged in the first place, and why it concluded so abruptly.
This is particularly important because the affair has not projected an image of measured leadership.
Had forgiveness been sought earlier, much of the uncertainty could have been avoided. The rakyat would have been spared weeks of political tension and institutional embarrassment.
Instead, the process dragged on until the approach of the state assembly sitting, creating an impression, not of remorse, but of mounting political necessity.
Perception matters in public office.
Leaders are judged not only by the decisions they eventually make but by how quickly they recognise mistakes and act to correct them, even at their own expense. Delayed contrition, on the other hand, appears less like humility and more like calculation.
Nevertheless, what is done is done. The priority now must be the welfare of Negeri Sembilan and its people.
Political factions, personal ambitions and institutional rivalries should not be allowed to overshadow the larger responsibility of governance. The state requires stability, competent administration and a renewed commitment to serving the rakyat.
Most importantly, it requires a healthy and respectful relationship between the government and the palace.
Whatever one’s political views, the ruler remains an important symbol of continuity, legitimacy and moral stewardship within Negeri Sembilan’s unique constitutional and adat framework.
Hopefully, the next menteri besar will assume office with a deeper appreciation of these responsibilities.
Negeri Sembilan has endured an unnecessary and unfortunate chapter. Yet, every crisis carries within it an opportunity for renewal.
Lest we forget, political power is temporary while the trust of the rakyat and the integrity of institutions are far more enduring. If those entrusted with leadership can learn that lesson, perhaps some good may yet emerge from this troubling episode.
And with that hope, I pray that wisdom prevails, that public trust is restored and that Negeri Sembilan moves forward united, stable and stronger than before.
May God guide us all.
The views expressed are those of the writer and do not necessarily reflect those of FMT.
Subscribe to our newsletter and get news delivered to your mailbox.
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.