InquirerHernandez debunks claim House is hatching ‘no-el’ planThe Jerusalem PostEuropean Commission targeted in cyberattack lasting 10 days, sensitive personal data at riskPunchVIDEO: South Africans protest Nigerians calling Pretoria community ‘Little Lagos’Daily MaverickECD CRIMINALISED: Orange Farm crèche principal convicted over missing permit only City of Joburg could unlockSky TG24Berlino, Witkoff e Kushner alla Cancelleria di MerzBollywood HungamaBIG BREAKING: Ramayana ticket prices SLASHED from November 20; here's how much you'll have to pay for 2D, 3D and IMAX versionsZDF heuteAktuelle Pressemitteilungen des ZDFCBS NewsTrump says Iran may be working on biological weaponsNOS'Nederlandse ambassade in Kyiv beschadigd door drone-inslag'BBC عربيتصاعد المخاوف بين عرب إسرائيل بعد إحراق مسجد وحادثة دهسTagesschauLiveticker zu Gipfeln: ++ Kushner und Witkoff in Berlin angekommen ++Global NewsFormer top Mountie to be sentenced for assault on teen in B.C. court
The Daily Newsstand · Free, Always
Thursday, November 19, 2026

Big change to TIPPING in restaurants in South Africa

Translate

South Africans dining out do not have to pay an automatically added 10% service charge simply because it appears on a restaurant bill, following an important consumer rights ruling against a Pretoria restaurant.

The National Consumer Tribunal found that Tribeca Standard, a restaurant at Lynnwood Bridge in Pretoria, had engaged in prohibited conduct by automatically adding a 10% service charge to customers’ bills.

The restaurant described the charge as discretionary and told diners they could ask for it to be removed if they were unhappy with the service.

READ | Major fried chicken chain from Korea opens its first store in South Africa

However, the Tribunal ruled that customers should not have to challenge an automatically added charge to avoid paying it.

Speaking to Stephen Grootes on The Money Show, consumer rights expert Wendy Knowler explained why the decision matters for restaurants and diners across the country.

Restaurant added 10% to every bill

Tribeca Standard’s menu stated that a discretionary 10% charge would be added to customers’ bills.

Diners were told to notify management if the service was not up to standard, with the restaurant promising to remove the charge.

However, the fee was automatically applied to all bills, with the restaurant confirming that approximately 200 service-charge transactions were processed daily.

The National Consumer Commission considered this a systemic practice rather than an isolated incident.

Knowler said customers were increasingly encountering service charges that were added automatically, sometimes without being clearly communicated before the bill arrived.

She explained that many diners simply look at the final amount and may not realise that a service fee has already been included before adding their own tip.

Why the Tribunal ruled against the restaurant

The restaurant defended its policy by arguing that the charge was disclosed on its menu, was discretionary and could be removed at a customer’s request.

It also said the money was paid to waiters as tips and that no customer had complained about being refused a request to remove the charge.

However, Knowler said the central issue was that consumers could not be compelled to pay more than the displayed price.

Section 23 of the Consumer Protection Act (CPA) prohibits suppliers from requiring consumers to pay more than the displayed price for goods or services.

The Tribunal also found that the restaurant’s approach effectively required customers to pay extra for good service or negotiate a lower bill if the service was poor.

Knowler said consumers already have a legal right to good-quality service.

A genuinely voluntary gratuity is one that a customer freely chooses to pay. It is not an amount automatically added to a bill and removed only if the customer challenges it.

The Tribunal clarified that restaurants are not prohibited from charging for additional services. However, they must specify what those services entail and display the full price upfront so customers can decide whether to accept the offer before ordering.

Restaurant escapes R1 million fine

The National Consumer Commission asked the Tribunal to impose a R1 million administrative fine on Tribeca Standard.

However, the restaurant was not fined.

The Tribunal declared the conduct prohibited but decided that imposing a financial penalty was not in the interests of justice.

Knowler explained that several factors worked in the restaurant’s favour.

These included that there was no evidence of bad faith, that the service charges had genuinely been paid to waiters and that the restaurant had not profited from the arrangement.

No specific financial loss was presented to the Tribunal.

The restaurant also cooperated with the investigation and removed the disputed wording from its menu.

Knowler contrasted the outcome with an earlier case involving a Gauteng restaurant group, which was fined R1 million in 2024 after the Tribunal found that it had charged undisclosed service fees and failed to cooperate with proceedings.

Can restaurants still charge a 10% service fee for large tables?

The discussion also considered whether restaurants should be allowed to add service charges to larger bookings.

Knowler acknowledged that a waiter may spend much of an evening attending to a single table of eight or 10 people.

Restaurants can decide whether to accept large bookings and can charge for additional services, provided the charges are properly disclosed and customers agree to them before ordering.

However, she said blanket charges applied to every bill, including those for a single diner, were particularly problematic.

Customers should also be told clearly when a service fee has already been included rather than discovering it when the bill arrives.

What should you do if a restaurant adds 10% to your bill?

Knowler advised diners to check their bills before adding an additional tip.

If a service charge appears that they did not agree to, they can ask for it to be removed.

Importantly, customers do not have to complain about the quality of the service to justify refusing an unwanted charge.

If a restaurant refuses to remove the fee, consumers can report the matter to the National Consumer Commission.

The ruling does not mean restaurants can never charge for additional services. It reinforces the importance of transparent pricing and allowing customers to make an informed decision before ordering.

For South African diners, the message is clear: a tip is voluntary, and a restaurant cannot simply make an automatically added charge compulsory by describing it as discretionary.

Have you noticed an increase in restaurants automatically adding a tip to your bill?

View the original on The South African · Lifestyle →

KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.