How Zelda: Ocarina Of Time Remake's Metacritic Score Compares To The N64 Original

Published Nov 4, 2026, 6:01 AM EST

Ewan is Deputy Editor for ScreenRant's gaming section. He still quite hasn’t gotten out of his mid 00’s emo phase, and knows more about The Legend of Zelda and Doctor Who than is probably healthy.

Ewan oversees the content operation of ScreenRant's gaming output, working with a talented team of writers and editors to cover everything from the latest GTA 6 news to the indie games you need on your radar. 

Former Editor of GAMINGbible, Ewan also has words at Kotaku, Den of Geek, NME, and UNILAD. He's appeared on various podcasts, including VGC's and BBC's Let's Talk About Tech. 

Sign in to your ScreenRant account

The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time remake officially releases tomorrow (November 5) and reviews have now gone live for the first Nintendo Switch 2-exclusive Zelda game. Overall, critics seem to agree that the remake is a pretty safe reimagining of a beloved game, one that is afraid to take any real risks or make any substantial changes.

It's not hard to see why, given that the original N64 version of Ocarina of Time remains the highest-rated video game of all time on Metacritic. But how does the Nintendo Switch 2 remake's Metacritic Score stack up against the OG?

Is Ocarina Of Time Remake Better Than The Original?

According to the Metacritic scores for both games, The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time on N64 remains the higher-scoring game. The original version has an incredible 99, which is unheard of by modern standards. By comparison, The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time for Nintendo Switch 2 has an amazing 96 at the time of writing, which makes it one of the highest-rated games of this year, but still pretty short of all-time status.

This isn't exactly surprising, and it doesn't automatically mean the N64 version is the "better" game, unless you put all your stock in Metacritic scores. Which, you know, you really shouldn't. By all accounts, the remake has tons of quality-of-life improvements, gorgeous new visuals, and can be played on the go. For my money, that makes it a superior experience, even if it hasn't broken new ground in the way the original game did.

It's also worth noting that as new reviews come in over the next few days, the remake's score could go up or down (probably down).

In our own 9/10 review, we called the game a loving remake that we wished would take just a few more risks.

"The Switch 2 remake preserves its legacy, though it resists change in ways that occasionally clash. Remakes are always a sticky subject: many fans want the game to be completely different, while others want it to be basically the same, but on a modern platform with easy access. There's no real solution to making a remake that satisfies everyone, but Ocarina of Time comes close. With some additional content and replay value, it could easily have been the definitive version. But it will "just" have to settle for being an incredible remake that's worth playing at least once. Ocarina of Time is arguably worth playing in any iteration, including Switch 2."

What Are Other Critics Saying About The Ocarina Of Time Remake?

This is a sentiment largely shared by critics elsewhere. Voxel awarded the game a 10/10, writing: "Nintendo’s approach to this remake is notably safe and restrained—featuring few changes—yet it succeeds brilliantly in crafting the best version of this classic we have ever seen. I am certain that for those playing it for the first time, it will be an incredible journey, while for those who have played it dozens of times, it will be a truly nostalgic adventure."

Meanwhile, GAMINGbible also awarded the game a 10/10: "The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time for the Nintendo 64 is an undisputed masterpiece, with the Nintendo Switch 2 remake being the sleeker, sexier new version with a few extra tricks up its sleeve. While I’d have still liked the remake to explore some of that cut content from the Nintendo 64 era, I’m more than satisfied with this upgraded port."