Man wins Rs 1.26 crore from consumer court after builder fails to deliver his flat
![]()
AI generated image used for representative purpose
NEW DELHI: The national consumer commission has directed a Nagpur-based real estate developer to refund over Rs 1.26 crore to a homebuyer for failing to deliver a flat within the promised period.
The commission ordered developer to pay 9 percent annual interest on the refundable amount from the respective dates of payment until realisation.It also directed the company to pay Rs 1 lakh towards litigation expenses.In its November 18, 2026, order, the commission said the developer could not escape its liability to refund the money paid by the buyer merely because it had subsequently settled his housing loan with Canara Bank.
Builder fails to deliver flat despite receiving over Rs 1.82 crore
According to the commission order, Pratap Premchand Agarwal had booked a flat in the Wisteria Tower of the Enrico Heights project in Somalwada, Nagpur, on November 21, 2011, by paying Rs 11 lakh.An allotment confirmation was executed on September 20, 2012, for the 2,573 sq ft flat, with two parking slots, at a total consideration of Rs 1,70,74,500. After receiving Rs 60,00,350, the developer executed an agreement for construction and sale on April 12, 2013.
A tripartite agreement involving Canara Bank was signed on December 30, 2014, for the housing loan.The complainant alleged that despite receiving substantial payments, the developer failed to complete the project and deliver the flat in a habitable condition. Although the company offered possession on July 18, 2019, he found the flat incomplete and unfit for occupation during an inspection on August 12, 2019.
He also raised concerns about the flat's area and promised amenities.He sought a refund of Rs 1,82,55,626 and compensation of Rs 2,49,49,392, calculated at 24 percent annual interest up to September 2019.The developer disputed the allegations and claimed that the complainant had defaulted on his housing loan, leading to recovery proceedings by Canara Bank under the SARFAESI Act. It also said it had paid Rs 1,31,20,000 to the bank to settle the loan and prevent the flat from being auctioned.
Why commission ordered refund to homebuyer
The bench comprising presiding member Justice Sudip Ahluwalia and member Dr Sadhna Shanker noted that the agreement required construction to be completed within 30 months, by October 12, 2015. Even considering the developer's claimed grace period up to April 12, 2016, possession was offered only on July 18, 2019.The commission said the developer had not established that the delay was justified or that the flat was legally and actually ready for occupation.
It also noted that no valid Completion Certificate or Occupation Certificate had been placed on record.The bench further held that the developer's payment of Rs 1.31 crore to Canara Bank could not be deducted from the buyer's refund, as it was made towards the company's own obligation under the tripartite agreement.“The said payment was made to the Bank and not to the Complainant. It cannot, therefore, be treated as a refund or reimbursement of the amounts which the Complainant had himself paid towards the Flat.
The fact that the loan account stood closed by reason of the said payment does not, by itself, extinguish the Complainant's independent claim for refund of the amounts contributed by him,” the commission said.It noted that the complainant had paid Rs 75,39,882 directly to the developer and Rs 51,04,483.97 through EMIs to Canara Bank, taking his total contribution to Rs 1,26,44,365.97.
The commission said 24 percent annual interest sought by the complainant was excessive and held that 9 percent annual interest would be reasonable.
Final order
The commission partly allowed the complaint and directed Universal Drinks Pvt Ltd to:
- Refund Rs 1,26,44,365.97, representing the amount paid directly to the developer and through housing loan EMIs.
- Pay 9 percent annual interest on the refundable amount from the respective dates of payment until realisation.
- Pay Rs 1 lakh towards litigation expenses.
The company has been directed to comply within eight weeks of the order, failing which the refundable amount will carry 12 percent annual interest during the period of default.
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.