‘Differing views are normal’: EC responds to report on 14 objections, says key decisions were unanimous

The poll panel's response came amid a political row after an Indian Express report highlighting objections raised by two Election Commissioners over several decisions during the rollout of the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls.

The Election Commission of India on Wednesday defended its decision-making process, saying that differing views and observations within an institution are a normal part of deliberation before a final decision is taken.

The poll panel's response came amid a political row after an Indian Express report highlighting objections raised by two Election Commissioners over several decisions during the rollout of the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls

“Differing views and observations are a normal part of deliberation in any institution. They are a part of the decision-making process before a final decision is taken. Not only the three Commissioners, but every officer of the Commission is fully authorised to give his suggestions to the Commission for improving the electoral system,” the poll panel said.

The EC, in its eight-point official statement, said that focusing on specific internal notes and observations over a 10-month period, while leaving out the “much larger body” of approvals, decisions and initiatives, presents only “one part of the picture”.

The Indian Express report had claimed that the two Commissioners objected to the Election

Commission's steps 14 times in 10 months amid the rollout of Special Intensive Revision (SIR) exervcise. It stressed that not just the three Election Commissioners but every officer of the Commission is authorised to offer suggestions aimed at improving the electoral system.

The report trigerred a political row with Congress party saying that Gyanesh Kumar has no right to stay in office and must resign. Many of the leaders also called for Kumar's removal and impeachment.

Vote chori is a crime against Indian people: RaGa

Leader of Opposition in Lok Sabha, Rahul Gandhi alleged that the BJP, the RSS and the Election Commission which organised "vote chori" have committed an act of treason.

"Vote chori is a crime against the Indian people and a direct attack on our Constitution," Gandhi said.

"The BJP, RSS and EC who organised it have committed an act of treason. Justice will be served," the Leader of Opposition in the Lok Sabha said on X.

The poll panel also pointed to the breadth of its work in recent months, saying it had taken numerous decisions, issued instructions, introduced around 40 new initiatives and undertaken electoral reforms, including electoral-roll revision and SIR across the country.

'Outcome of unanimous decisions'

The EC also said all these decisions were the outcome of unanimous decisions of the full Commission over the past year.

Differing views and observations are a normal part of deliberation in any institution.

The Commission reiterated that it remains committed to carrying out its constitutional duties with “complete integrity”, while underlining its role in advancing India's democracy.

“The Election Commission of India remains fully committed to executing its constitutional duties with complete integrity, recognizing its vital role in advancing our democracy,” it said.

The objections by the two EC's, according to a report in The Indian Express, covered issues including the addition of new voters, deletion and restoration of names, changes to Form 6, and the functioning of technology used to manage electoral rolls.

TMC Rajya Sabha leader Derek O'Brien said on X, "Five months ago, 60 Rajya Sabha MPs (50 needed) wrote to Chairman RS moving Motion to remove CEC Gyanesh Kumar. After big news break today that two Election Commissioners objected to many of CEC's actions, it's time to bring out the RS Motion today. Impeach CEC to save democracy".

(With agency inputs)

About the Author

Gulam Jeelani is Political Desk Editor at LiveMint with over 16 years of experience covering national and international politics. Based in New Delhi, Jeelani delivers impactful political narratives through breaking stories, in-depth interviews, and analytical pieces at LiveMint since February 2024. The expertise in video production fuels his current responsibilities, which include curating content and conducting video interviews for an expanding digital audience.<br><br> Jeelani also travels during elections and key political events and has covered assembly elections in key states apart from national elections. He has previously worked with The Pioneer, Network18, India Today, News9Plus and Hindustan Times.<br><br> Jeelani’s tenure at LiveMint and previous experience at print and digital newsrooms have honed his skills in creating compelling text and video stories, explainers, and analysis that resonate with a diverse viewership.<br><br> Before moving to New Delhi in 2015, Jeelani was based in Uttar Pradesh, where he worked for five years as a reporter. In 2018, Jeelani was one of the two Indian journalists selected for the Alfred Friendly Fellowship in the US. There, he attended training workshops on reporting and data journalism, and he was attached to the Minneapolis Star Tribune in Minnesota, where he worked as a reporter.<br><br> Jeelani is a Bachelor's in Chemistry and holds a Masters Degree in journalism and mass communication from Aligarh Muslim University. Outside work, he enjoys poetry, cricket and movies.

^{Get Latest real-time updates}

Stay updated with the latest Trending, India, World and US news.

HomeNewsIndia‘Differing views are normal’: EC responds to report on 14 objections, says key decisions were unanimous