Best bets for Miami-Notre Dame: All the keys to star-studded matchup in South Bend

• 

  Pamela MaldonadoNov 4, 2026, 07:00 AM ET

  Close

  Pamela Maldonado is a sports betting analyst for ESPN.

Last season, Miami beat Notre Dame on a late field goal then edged the Irish for the final at-large playoff spot. Now they meet as AP top-five teams for just the second time, joining the 1988 matchup that Notre Dame won 31-30.

Darian Mensah, Malachi Toney and CJ Carr bring three of the five shortest Heisman odds onto the same field. The Hurricanes have scored at least 30 points in every game with their two Heisman hopefuls, but Notre Dame presents a tougher defensive test.

Can the Hurricanes keep rolling or will the Irish hand them a setback? Here's a betting outlook for the rematch.

Odds by DraftKings and subject to change.

No. 1 Miami at No. 4 Notre Dame -6
Saturday, 7:30 p.m. ET, NBC

Records: Miami 8-0, 0-0 vs. AP Top 25; Notre Dame 7-1, 0-1 vs. AP Top 25

Money line: Miami (+170); Notre Dame (-205)
Over/Under: 57.5 (O-110, U-110)

Notre Dame has the edge; Miami has the answers to keep it close

I like Notre Dame to win, though Miami is good enough to make laying six points uncomfortable, especially if Mensah gets the protection he needs.

Mensah has been excellent on the road, so I'm not expecting the setting to suddenly become a problem. He has Toney at receiver, he can make throws beyond the quick passing game, and he doesn't give possessions away. Notre Dame's defense should make things harder, though: The Irish cover better and tackle more reliably.

I'm more concerned about Miami's rushing offense. Running backs Javian Mallory and Mark Fletcher Jr. have been less productive away from home and now they face a defense that can meet them early and finish the tackle. They're capable of creating yards themselves, but that gets harder against Notre Dame. If the runs aren't helping, then more is put on Mensah (and his arm) to carry the load.

Miami can create a pressure problem for Carr. His yards per attempt drop from 8.9 with a clean pocket to 5.5 under pressure. Miami's pass rush can certainly disrupt Notre Dame without needing its coverage to hold up all night.

That makes running backs Nolan James Jr. and Jonaz Walton important. Miami is tough against the run, but its tackling has been shaky. A few extra yards after contact could help keep the offense in line.

The other side of this is Miami finishes drives: The Hurricanes score touchdowns on 81% of their red zone trips compared to 67% for Notre Dame. That's a real reason this could stay close.

I trust Notre Dame's defense more overall, and Miami's coverage gives Carr opportunities. I like the Irish at home, but I also expect Miami to make them earn it.

Prediction: UNDER 57.5

The scoring averages make 57.5 look reachable, but the under comes down to making these offenses work for their points. Both defenses allow successful runs on only about a third of attempts and limit explosive runs that turn a normal possession into a quick score. There should be fewer easy scoring opportunities. Both teams run on roughly half their plays. If they stick with that approach, they're using clock against the strength of the opposing defense. They could move the ball and still spend several minutes getting into scoring position.

Notre Dame also slows things down when leading after halftime. If the Irish get ahead, I expect them to use the run game to shorten what's left rather than keep trading possessions with Miami.

Miami's game against North Carolina is a reason to question the under. We can't dismiss 73 points as a fluke when both quarterbacks played well and neither team punted more than once. The distinction is what Notre Dame can do to Miami's scoring. North Carolina allowed Mensah to complete 22 of 29 passes for three touchdowns. Notre Dame brings much stronger coverage and tackling, so Miami faces a harder path to matching those 38 points.

But UNC also exposed Miami's pass defense, and Carr could take advantage of that. That's why the under depends more on Notre Dame limiting Miami than on both defenses controlling the game.

Basically, Miami just played a shootout, but Notre Dame has a better chance of interrupting that offense.