10 Sleeper Hit Movies That Are Perfect From Start to Finish
Jeremy has more than 2800 published articles on Collider to his name, and has been writing for the site since February 2022. He's an omnivore when it comes to his movie-watching diet, so will gladly watch and write about almost anything, from old Godzilla films to gangster flicks to samurai movies to classic musicals to the French New Wave to the MCU... well, maybe not the Disney+ shows.
His favorite directors include Martin Scorsese, Sergio Leone, Akira Kurosawa, Quentin Tarantino, Werner Herzog, John Woo, Bob Fosse, Fritz Lang, Guillermo del Toro, and Yoji Yamada. He's also very proud of the fact that he's seen every single Nicolas Cage movie released before 2022, even though doing so often felt like a tremendous waste of time. He's plagued by the question of whether or not The Room is genuinely terrible or some kind of accidental masterpiece, and has been for more than 12 years (and a similar number of viewings).
When he's not writing lists - and the occasional feature article - for Collider, he also likes to upload film reviews to his Letterboxd profile (username: Jeremy Urquhart) and Instagram account.
He has achieved his 2025 goal of reading all 13,467 novels written by Stephen King, and plans to spend the next year or two getting through the author's 82,756 short stories and 105,433 novellas.
Sign in to your Collider account
There are movies that look like they're going to be huge hits, and then they are, and that’s well and good and all. On the other end of things, there are some movies that feel like they’ve got a lot going for them, and sometimes they genuinely do, getting good reviews and everything, but then they don’t set the box office on fire, nor do they really pick up any kind of following more gradually (sorry, Furiosa: A Mad Max Saga… one day, you shall be loved, but that day did not occur in 2024; not even close).
To focus on the movies that overperformed, according to initial expectations, or maybe slowly picked up more attention and box office earnings over several weeks (or even months), there are a bunch below. These are sleeper hits in the sense that they did surprisingly well (turning a profit at the box office, and likely going even further when taking into account home releases and/or streaming earnings), and might not have looked like smash hits prior to release. And these sleeper hits are also hard to fault in terms of quality, with all of them being pretty much perfect within their respective genres.
10 'The Blair Witch Project' (1999)
An obligatory pick, The Blair Witch Project is one of the most noteworthy and obvious examples of a sleeper hit, really picking up momentum and driving buzz back in 1999, which is impressive, considering what a crowded year for cinema that one was. It came out of nowhere and built up a reputation for being a must-see movie, making almost a quarter of a billion dollars while being made for less than a million.
It also made use of viral marketing before it was cool, and while the internet itself was still a little while away from being absolutely everywhere and unavoidable, so that helped in the overall sense of momentum. And divorced from all that, as much as is possible, The Blair Witch Project is just a pretty great (and oftentimes genuinely intense) horror movie, so its placement here is well-earned on multiple fronts.
9 'Edge of Tomorrow' (2014)
While he’s a star, and everyone knows his name, whether they're a fan of him or not, not every Tom Cruise movie is a huge hit (his 2020s output is a testament to that, even if Top Gun: Maverick was a box office juggernaut). To go back a little while, and to look at something that wasn’t huge straight away, but picked up acclaim over time, here’s Edge of Tomorrow, which is like Groundhog Day, but with aliens and a lot more action.
It always had good reviews, but not enough people paid it enough attention at the time, maybe because there were quite a few other big movies in 2014 that got more attention. Calling it a “hit” is more of a stretch than with other movies in this ranking, but Edge of Tomorrow did eventually earn a bit over double its budget at the box office, and it’s held up well post-theatrical release, with rumblings about a sequel being ever-present, or at least brought up seemingly every year or two.
8 'The Fly' (1986)
The Fly might've had some anticipation (or buzzzzz) behind it because it was a remake, and that version from the 1950s… it’s not bad. But excitement around it in the lead-up to the release might not have been all that huge, because even if David Cronenberg and Jeff Goldblum are well-known now, they weren't really household names in their fields (director and actor, respectively), though The Fly did help boost both their profiles considerably.
It’s aged well, and is still one of the most impressive horror movies of all time on a technical and special effects front.
So, The Fly was probably disarming, and the sort of thing that would've been better than expected, because sure, it is “just” about a guy turning into a fly, but the execution makes it work so much better than you might anticipate, and it’s also hard to do justice to the film’s quality with words. It’s aged well, and is still one of the most impressive horror movies of all time on a technical and special effects front. As for its earnings, it qualified as a hit by earning $60 million worldwide, with a budget that’s estimated at being between $9 and $15 million (which is quite a range, but it earned somewhere between four and six times its budget, in any event).
7 'The Rocky Horror Picture Show' (1975)
In the 21st century, the film that might come to mind first when you hear the terms “midnight screening” or “interactive screening” is The Room, since that’s this century’s The Rocky Horror Picture Show. But calling that a hit is a bit uncertain, because it’s never been a critical success, and it’s also not really perfect, by any means. It’s perfectly awful, and very enjoyable on that front, but it’s not really good.
The Rocky Horror Picture Show is genuinely pretty great, though, even if it famously took a little while for that greatness to be properly appreciated. It was probably too weird to be an instant hit/smash/phenomenon, but it definitely found the cult audience it deserved, and it became huge in time, to the point where calling it a cult classic nowadays probably isn't accurate. Now, more than 50 years later, it’s just an unambiguous classic, really.
6 'Se7en' (1995)
30 years on from Se7en, you might find people eagerly anticipating a new David Fincher movie, but in 1995, probably not really. He’d done the third Alien movie before this, and some music videos, so he hadn’t done anything great as far as feature films went at this point. It was also instrumental in cementing Brad Pitt as a truly great actor, and boosted Morgan Freeman’s popularity, too (alongside 1994’s The Shawshank Redemption, which is probably also a sleeper hit to some extent).
The word of mouth for Se7en was good, probably helped by the fact that some genuinely surprising things happen in its final act, and if a movie has a twist everyone agrees is mind-blowing, then people are going to want to rush out and find out what that twist is before it gets spoiled. Beyond its unpredictability, Se7en has a lot to offer, and though it’s obviously great now, it being as good as it was would've been considerably more surprising in 1995.
5 'Obsession' (2025)
Yes, this is a ranking of all-time great movies that were also sleeper hits, and Obsession is still a fairly recent release, at the time of writing, but also, come on. This one did some remarkable numbers, to put it mildly, basically being the biggest low-budget horror movie since The Blair Witch Project. They were made for similar budgets, and then went on to make hundreds of millions at the box office.
The worldwide gross for Obsession is more than half a billion, and when you look at that budget of under one million, that’s obviously beyond impressive. It deserved the success, too, because it is absolutely one of the best (and most skin-crawling) horror movies released in recent memory, and the way it finds new things to do with the demonic possession sub-genre while very much appealing to Gen Z (and what they find scary) is impressive and honestly quite groundbreaking.
4 'District 9' (2009)
When District 9 was being marketed, the only thing it could really boast was some involvement by Peter Jackson, as he was a producer. But the director, Neill Blomkamp, hadn’t done a feature film before, and the star, Sharlto Copley, was also pretty much unknown. Now, neither are full-blown household names post-2009, but both have worked steadily and can count District 9 as responsible for that.
It is a masterful movie, and so surprisingly great, too, given it came out of nowhere and was an ambitious science fiction movie that wasn’t a remake, sequel, or something based on a pre-existing book. It had a modest budget of $30 million (it looked a lot more expensive, which is a testament to how much they did with that money), and went on to get a lot of positive buzz around it, including some significant Oscar nominations, all the while also impressively earning pretty much right on seven times its budget at the global box office.
3 'One Cut of the Dead' (2017)
The budget of One Cut of the Dead was estimated to be only about $25,000, and you can tell it’s low-budget when watching it for sure, but not in a bad way. Still, it doesn’t look or feel that low-budget, but the minimal costs here meant that its eventual worldwide box office earnings of almost $60 million were beyond monumental… crunch the math if you want, and that budget-to-box office ratio is immense.
It’s a bit like The Blair Witch Project in the sense that it’s got the found footage style thing going for it (that titular one cut), and then you can compare it to Se7en, of all things, in the sense that it’s got some mind-blowing reveals up its sleeve that are worth the price of admission alone. One Cut of the Dead is a charming and offbeat low-budget horror movie until it suddenly (but beautifully) transitions into something else, and the unpredictable ride offered is so creative and unusually moving while also being frequently hilarious.
2 'Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse' (2018)
With Spider-Man, any live-action movies are pretty much guaranteed to do well, and that feels especially so since the Tom Holland version of the character joined the MCU. Those Spider-Man movies are just hits, no “sleeper” or “sleeping” in sight, but Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse wasn’t as much of a guaranteed hit, and though it wasn’t ignored when first released, by any means, it took a little time to find as big an audience as it deserved.
The theatrical run was definitely successful, but there’s evidence that Into the Spider-Verse kept picking up steam after it left theaters, too, since when it got a sequel in 2023, that one (Across the Spider-Verse) performed a lot better at the box office (nearly $700 million versus the first’s worldwide gross of just under $400 million). The hype kept building, and allowed the follow-up to be an even bigger hit, if you're just looking at money (it’s certainly not like this for all blockbuster series or franchises, as the Star Wars sequel trilogy experienced box office gross declining with each movie, and the Avatar films have followed a similar downward trend).
Thanks to getting the kind of reviews it got, Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon was probably expected to do decently well financially, but it did exceed expectations, and part of its success does come down to how well it did in the U.S. And the U.S. isn't everything, sure, but Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon is worth talking about in the context of the U.S. box office because it wasn’t an English-language movie, but people still turned up in droves to see it.
In a post-Parasite world, maybe that’s less surprising, but in 2000, it was more novel, and definitely promising for international cinema overall, into the 21st century. And if any martial arts movie deserved to become an unexpected blockbuster, it’s probably Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon, since it’s really hard to fault, and it’s approachable, serving as a great gateway film into the wuxia sub-genre and also martial arts movies more generally.
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.