Did Eli Manning Just Reopen Tom Brady's Old Super Bowl Wound With One Signed Jersey?

Eli Manning mailed Tom Brady a signed jersey.© Image via: X/@NFL
Eli Manning mailed Tom Brady a signed jersey, and the note scrawled on it landed like a sack. Manning kept it to two short sentences. Netflix had just released its Untold film on the New York Giants' 2008 Super Bowl upset, and Manning timed the gift to match. Brady posted the jersey on Instagram and answered in public. He is 49, retired and owner of seven championship rings. The New England Patriots arrived in Arizona unbeaten and left with a loss nobody saw coming. Eighteen years later, the scoreboard in his head still reads 17-14.
Tom Brady's Instagram Reply To Eli Manning
Eli Manning wrote, "Tom, congrats on the 18-1 season. One Giant loss." Bleacher Report says the two quarterbacks swapped signed jerseys, while other outlets describe only Manning's gift. Either way, Brady's response is what fans passed around.
He posted a photo of the jersey and added, "You were the MVP, but Tyree's helmet deserves half of it… and no… I'm still not over it."
Tom Brady says he still not over the loss to Eli Manning in the Super Bowl Eli:”Tom, congrats on the 16-1 season….1 Giant loss” Brady: “You were the MVP, but Tyree's helmet deserves half of it... and no... I'm still not over it” https://t.co/hjwSzUMiKj
— Shannonnn sharpes Burner (PARODY Account) (@shannonsharpeee) November 21, 2026
The caption credits Manning, who did win Super Bowl XLII MVP, and then shifts some of the weight onto David Tyree. On third-and-5, Manning slipped out of a collapsing pocket and threw deep. Tyree pinned the ball against his helmet while safety Rodney Harrison fought to knock it loose. Brady has had almost two decades to rewatch that snap. His post suggests he has.
Why Super Bowl XLII Still Bothers The New England Patriots
The stakes explain the sting. Brady threw 50 touchdown passes in 2007 and led New England to a 16-0 regular season. A 19-0 finish would have been a first in NFL history. The Patriots held a 14-10 edge in the fourth quarter in Glendale, Arizona.
Then the drive happened. Tyree made the catch, and Plaxico Burress hauled in the go-ahead touchdown with 39 seconds left. The Giants won 17-14.
The Untold series retells that finish for viewers who were in grade school when it aired. It also arrives when both quarterbacks are retired and highly visible voices, which gives a signed jersey far more reach than a private text ever would.
Manning did not stop at one win. He beat Brady again in Super Bowl XLVI, a 21-17 Giants victory after the 2011 season. Brady's Super Bowl record against Manning stands at 0-2.
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.