Sentinels is an urgent call to action on bird flu, and capitalism gone wild. It’s also a joy to read
Highly pathogenic avian influenza (H5N1 bird flu) is the defining disease of our times, suggests Australian writer and journalist Michael Dulaney in his timely book Sentinels, on what happens when diseases spread between animals and humans.
Now impacting mainland Australian wildlife, the disease, which reached us in June, epitomises our callous neglect of nature, despite us being embedded in and reliant on it.
“Of all the pathogens I’ve learned about, this is the big one,” Dulaney writes.
Review: Sentinels by Michael Dulaney (Scribe Publications)
Over 700 bird flu events – which cover individual or multiple deaths of animals – have occurred in Australia so far. Greater crested terns, little penguins, common bottlenose dolphin, long-nosed fur seals, Australian sea lions, and many other bird and mammal species have all succumbed. It’s a sobering result of our missed chances to protect nature and prevent pathogens from jumping between non-human animals and people.
In his book, which was longlisted for this year’s Walkley Book Award and published just a few months after bird flu reached Australia, Dulaney thoughtfully discusses our impacts on and connections with non-human life. We continue to exploit species and plunder nature at an alarming scale and rate. It’s estimated humans exploit as much as 300 times more species than non-human predators.

The concept of a sentinel — the canary in the coal mine — draws from epidemiology, the study of disease. Dulaney’s thesis is that these sentinels are increasingly sickly, often dropping dead at disturbingly regular rates and in extraordinary numbers. It’s hard to dispute this.
A recent grisly example is the estimated death of more than 13,000 elephant seal pups, more than 75% of all pups born, on the sub-Antarctic Heard Island last summer, as their remote, isolated location and shielding from H5N1 bird flu were inevitably breached. Humans are destroying nature and the spillover of diseases that jump between species – including to and from humans – is increasing. Dulaney writes:
Researchers have counted around 200 new infectious diseases that have broken out more than 12,000 times over the past three decades On average, one new infectious disease jumps to humans every eight months.
He suggests this threat should be considered in the same way as other globally significant and existential threats, including climate change.
As a wildlife ecologist and conservation scientist, I echo his call to action.

A joy to read
Sentinels is composed of three parts and eight chapters. The first part is focused on wildlife, the second on agriculture and the third looks at the impacts of commerce, the wildlife trade and our treatment of fellow human beings.
One chilling passage describes how in California’s bulging prison population, one of five of the state’s cases of Valley fever (a disease caused by pathogenic fungi) was found among its prisoners between 2007 and 2011.
Dulaney’s writing is a joy. Easily consumed, complex ideas and information are made accessible to the reader. Sentinels is very well referenced too, including extensive peer-reviewed research. Case studies span China, the Andes, the Arctic, Indonesia, Australia and elsewhere. As a result, this book is undoubtedly globally relevant.
Dulaney also takes his readers to the front lines. There are stories of ecologists studying flying foxes in forests, and about the relevance of Hendra virus, which causes severe, often fatal disease in both infected horses and humans. It can pass from bats to horses, and has killed people working with horses.
Elsewhere, the book details people trying to protect endangered amphibians on Indonesian mountains, as Dulaney spends four days with Angga, a gifted wildlife tracker. “Sometimes, when Angga uncovers an exceptionally rare frog or snake species, his clients break down crying over finding something they have searched for their whole lives,” he writes.
There’s even discussion of the potential links between pigs, East Germany and the fall of communism.

The epilogue is perhaps the most powerful and vital section of the book. It brings together how what’s happening is not a case of misfortune, but a predictable, likely outcome of what we’re doing: the habitats we destroy, and the crowding of people and animals.
The science is clear. Our actions are stressing wildlife populations and in some cases, they bring wildlife and their diseases closer to us and the animals we farm and eat. It’s a recipe for disaster. The increasing reliance of flying foxes on urban environments to find food – and the Hendra virus risk this poses – is because we’ve destroyed large areas of forests and woodlands these animals relied upon.
Dulaney comes hard at capitalism, too, pointing to its commodification of nature. This will likely rankle some – but again, it’s hard to argue against. Even within the conservation community I’m part of, the value of species and ecosystems are often framed and described through the services they provide us, rather than their intrinsic value. The Australian government now has a Nature repair market, which includes the use of controversial offsets that allow for further environmental destruction.
Dulaney is clear about his ecological grief. “In the days prior to handling ducks, I’d watched distressing video compilations filmed by carers around the world who could do nothing but witness these slow deaths,” he writes about bird flu. In the chapter devoted to it, he writes:
I have come to believe that bird flu is the archetypal disease of this new age, the one that represents all of our failed efforts to address the growing threat of spillover – a disease that links farming, unrestrained industry, political intransigience, and environmental exploitation in a way that threatens hundreds of species, including our own. It scares me more than anything else.
His honesty and authenticity mean Sentinels rises above many science-based books I’ve read, which clumsily attempt to hide the authors’ personal views and values. We are not impartial automatons: we all have skin in this game, which concerns our only home. Dulaney makes the case for urgent and substantial change.
Hope, but no sugarcoating

Much of the book is confronting; Dulaney does not sugarcoat our predicament. But he offers hope – and makes the important point that tackling disease will also help address other crises, such as climate change, which are inextricably linked.
Sentinels covers a lot of ground. Given the complexities of disease ecology and the wicked problem of managing wildlife and societies to reduce our exposure to pandemics and better protect biodiversity, it’s unsurprising some issues aren’t covered in the depth I might desire. But in my view, this is more than compensated for by the broad knowledge and understanding readers will get from Dulaney’s book.
Sentinels is a vital read. I hope it reaches a diverse audience, including our political leaders, who need to confront the challenges it so thoughtfully describes. To protect ourselves, we must protect our ecosystems and the species that sustain them.
The ongoing demise of wildlife and the global rise of diseases and pandemics sound clarion calls we must urgently act upon. We must improve our relationship with nature.
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.