Donovan’s Deep Dives: Party loyalty tests the blue-white alliance
Cross-party endorsements are exposing tensions within the KMT and TPP, even as electoral interests keep them working together ahead of the local elections
By Courtney Donovan Smith 石東文 / Staff Columnist
Mirror Media ran an interview on Monday with Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) Chair Cheng Li-wun (鄭麗文) that was remarkable on many levels, but especially on relations with the Taiwan People’s Party (TPP), where she said the election results will impact relations with the smaller party.
The interview had some surprisingly defeatist undertones, as if she was laying the groundwork for deflecting blame for electoral losses.
Cheng’s comments overall on the TPP were mixed: she was positive about their cooperation during last year’s recall vote against KMT lawmakers, but added that her first priority is to maximize the KMT’s own vote share before considering what form of cooperation it should pursue with friendly political parties. In recent weeks, however, the alliance has produced some embarrassing incidents of defiance against her within her own party.
Chinese Nationalist Party Chair Cheng Li-wun, center, campaigns for Wu Hsu-chih, fourth right, the party’s mayoral candidate for Jhubei City.
Photo: Huang Mei-chu, Taipei Times
STILL LARGELY STRONG
When assessing the current state of their alliance, it is important to view it on two separate tracks: legislative and electoral.
Their legislative cooperation is still going strong, but their electoral alliance is more varied. As Cheng noted in the interview, how individual candidates interact with the TPP is based on their own electoral calculations; the party’s central headquarters respects each campaign team’s judgment.
Taipei Mayor Chiang Wan-an, front center kneeling Taiwan People’s Party Chair Huang Kuo-chang, back center and Internet celebrity Holger Chen, back left, on Nov. 15 campaign in Taipei.
Photo: Lin Cheng-kung, Taipei Times
Mostly, those local KMT campaign teams are working with the TPP to varying degrees. There are some inevitable tensions over specific city and county council races. They are multi-member districts, so there is room for both parties, but there are concerns on both sides in some races they are taking votes from each other to the benefit of the DPP. Mostly, these tensions remain largely under control.
In some places, the cooperation is quite strong, including in New Taipei City, Taichung and Kaohsiung. Taichung’s outgoing Mayor Lu Shiow-yen (盧秀燕), for example, has made significant efforts to reach out to the TPP and their supporters. Broadly speaking, their alliance has held fairly strong across the nation.
One exception is Taipei, where the KMT campaign this summer imposed rules on campaigning for TPP city council candidates. Most importantly, these rules applied to incumbent Mayor Chiang Wan-an (蔣萬安).
KMT AND TPP CHAIRS FACE DEFIANCE
Since early in the race where the KMT candidates struggled for votes, such as in Kaohsiung, it has been a popular choice to invite TPP founder Ko Wen-je (柯文哲) and Chair Huang Kuo-chang (黃國昌) to campaign with them. Now that the KMT is under pressure in areas they previously had expected to be easy wins, they are desperate to appeal to TPP supporters.
Chiang Wan-an has been practically begging his predecessor as Taipei mayor, Ko, to campaign with him. Ko puckishly invited Chiang to join his rally in support of the TPP’s Jhubei City (竹北) mayoral candidate, Andy Chiu (邱臣遠). The Jhubei race, of course, has seen a massive breakdown between the KMT and TPP over their mayoral candidates.
Then KMT television personality Jaw Shaw-kong (趙少康) and some other politicians then started openly campaigning for Chiu over their own party’s candidate, Wu Hsu-chih (吳旭智). Talk of stripping Jaw of his party membership spread, to which he replied with typical bravado in a go-ahead, bring it on sort of way.
Chiang made a strategic choice and sent Chiu a video message expressing his good wishes. His own race was too tight to spend the time in Jhubei, but he clearly calculated that he needs TPP supporters’ votes to shore up his own race, and if that meant slapping Cheng in the face and selling the KMT’s Jhubei candidate down the river, so be it.
As a bonus, his action may have made it impossible for the KMT to discipline Jaw, who has an outsized influence on KMT politics.
He also brought the TPP’s Taipei City council candidates on stage at a major rally, and toured with party Chair Huang and controversial media personality Holger Chen (陳之漢). Negotiations are underway for Ko to join Chiang at some event, but it remains unconfirmed. Chiang has done everything he can to win over Ko’s support.
It is not just Cheng who has suffered embarrassment and defiance due to the alliance; Huang has as well.
The TPP’s only party nominee for a county or city chief position is Chang Chi-kai (張?楷) in Chiayi City. However, he recently expressed hope to have his KMT membership renewed. He hoped to be a member of both parties, which the TPP originally allowed, but KMT party rules prohibit membership in another party.
Then former TPP secretary-general Hsieh Li-kung (謝立功) voiced support for DPP Keelung mayoral candidate Tung Tzu-wei (童子瑋) in a major breach of their alliance with the KMT. Huang tartly responded by emphasizing that Hsieh was well aware of the party’s rules regarding such behavior.
As discussed in my previous column, a poor election result could threaten Cheng’s leadership and create an opening for Lu Shiow-yen. That would also matter for relations with the TPP: Lu has cultivated friendly ties with the party, while Cheng has explicitly left its future cooperation with the KMT open to review after the vote.
Regardless, in the short term it is likely their alliance in the legislature will continue.
Donovan’s Deep Dives is a regular column by Courtney Donovan Smith (石東文) who writes in-depth analysis on everything about Taiwan’s political scene and geopolitics. Donovan is also the central Taiwan correspondent at ICRT FM100 Radio News, co-publisher of Compass Magazine, co-founder Taiwan Report (report.tw) and former chair of the Taichung American Chamber of Commerce. Follow him on X: @donovan_smith.
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.