TOC All-Star Christmas 2 episode 2: Round two’s winners, losers, and Hunter

Food Network’s Tournament of Champions: All-Star Christmas continued with another three festive battles, including some Top Chef alumni facing off. So far, we’ve seen 12 of the 16 teams, so next week is the end of the first round.
There was no change from the first episode in the Randomizer, but we did have some new judges: Nancy Silverton, who was somehow available; Iron Chef Judy Joo; and Marcus Samuelsson.
As before, they scored each savory and sweet dishes separately: 25 for taste, 20 for randomizer use, and 5 for presentation, so a maximum of 100 points for each team.
Here’s what happened. Spoilers and Hunter Fieri jokes ahead.
Dale Talde and TJ Obias vs. Stephanie Izard and Damaris Philips

Festive family fun ► Dale and TJ were in fun print shirts; Stephanie and Damaris had candy cane aprons, green t-shirts, Christmas plaid pants, and reindeer antlers. Take notes, Malarkey and annoying protege in your non-holiday costumes!
The Randomizer’s gifts ► porterhouse steak, white chocolate, using the juicer, making it glazed, and pumpkin puree as the wild card
Holiday surprise ► Trauma bonding! Dale said he and TJ were now going to “trauma bond over some Christmas holidays.” But the trauma was in Damaris’s cake, which came out with “unique” texture—Stephanie used that word because she didn’t want to say anything mean. But the judges loved her recovery, turning it into deep fried croutons. “The best things come from something going wrong, and you make it a little better than it was going to be,” Stephanie said.
Judging ►
- 79: Dale’s pumpkin char siu with pumpkin fried rice (40), and TJ’s with white chocolate pumpkin mousse with oranges and a ginger snap crumble (39). Marcus raved over the fried rice, despite its proportions; Nancy loved TJ’s ginger snaps and Marcus thought the oranges were perfect, but Judy noted the mousse split.
- 82: Stephanie’s “Christmas steak feast” of a porterhouse bone with steak and tenderloin green bean salad (43), and Damaris’ fried pumpkin muffin crouton on white chocolate mousse and spiced pepitas (39). Judy called the dessert “sophisticated” and loved the croutons, which Marcus said should become part of holiday traditions—quite a recovery for Damaris.
Winners ► Stephanie and Damaris, and Stephanie was right: the failure created something amazing. Still, it was Stephanie’s steak that gave them the win. “You guys worked very well together,” said Hunter, not dressed as an elf, still bad at this.
Marcel Vigneron and Hung Huynh vs. Sara Bradley and Nini Nguyen
Festive family fun ► Marcel and Hung met in culinary school and are best friends, while Sara and Nini met on Top Chef—a competition Hung won. Nini said, “That’s great, but that was a long time ago.” SHADE!
The Randomizer’s gifts ► airline chicken breast and granny smith apples, using a handheld mixer, charring their food, and, in the gift, popcorn balls (switched from candy canes)
Holiday surprise ► Nini put her popcorn balls on the grill to char them, and they were on fire when she put them into a pot with cream. Now there’s a holiday party: firey balls!
Judging ►
- 88: Sara’s grilled chicken with charred corn polenta (46), and Nini’s charred apple butter inside popcorn rice pudding (42). Judy thought the chicken was “elevated” and Marcus couldn’t find any mistakes in the polenta. However, Marcus thought the granny smith apple was lost in the rice pudding.
- 78: Hung’s chicken breast with mashed potatoes and charred vegetables (39), and Marcel’s charcoal apple ice cream and burnt caramel corn (39). “Two good dishes,” Marcus said—which is not quite high praise, and the judging showed it. The chicken breast was dry; Nancy was turned off by the color of the ice cream; and Judy was missing the apple in the ice cream.
Winners ► Sara and Nini, which was so obvious to me I wrote this sentence during the commercial break before it was revealed. Marcel said “anybody’s game right now” after the judging, but that wasn’t the judging we heard. Perhaps the judges’ comments were more nuanced, or maybe the liquid nitrogen cloud affected Marcel’s brain.
Kevin Lee and Shota Nakajima vs Stephanie Boswell and Aarti Sequeria
Festive family fun ► “I’m so grateful to be hooked to her caboose,” Aarti said about Stephanie. And I’m so grateful for their incredible SUGAR and SPICE sweatshirts, which were much more entertaining than those twink drag queens on Drag Race season 15.
Aarti also said that, on TOC, they’re doing what we do at the holidays: cook with friends. But their holiday cooking is more of a nightmare, since they’re haunted by both the Randomizer and roving reporter Hunter Fieri.
The Randomizer’s gifts ► salmon and strawberries, using a panini press and making it whipped, with the gift of candy canes which was again swapped, this time for Jordan almonds.
Holiday surprise ► Tiffani Faison said this was the hardest randomizer yet, in part because of the Jordan almonds, which are actually hard—so hard they can break your teeth. Hunter, could you please demo and make yourself useful?
Judging ►
- 91: Kevin’s Jordan Almond crusted panini pressed salmon with almond romesco salmon skin gremolata (47), and Shota’s panini pressed honey butter toast with strawberry whip—and two tuiles (44). The salmon was overcooked for Marcus but the judges loved the creativity and elements, and seemed to love the dessert, too.
- 85: Aarti’s salmon shawarma and whipped hummus (42), and Stephanie’s Pain perdu with whipped ricotta and strawberry compote (43). Aarti’s salmon had the same overcooked note, but they loved her hummus. Marcus called Stephanie’s “a really high-end dessert.”
Winners ► Kevin and Shota, whose feedback was so good Aarti and Stephanie could hear them “jumping up and down next door,” Stephanie said. Could they hear Stephanie hitting Aarti with a pillow, which was their celebration? Alas, it was short-lived, as Aarti was crying backstage because of her lower score.
Kevin and Shota now have the record round-one score. “That’s pretty epic,” Hunter said. Agreed, as is Hunter using such advanced vocabulary.
All of reality blurred’s content is independently selected, including links to products or services. However, if you buy something after clicking an affiliate link, we may earn a commission. Learn more.
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.