HBO's 'Harry Potter' Has the Perfect Opportunity to Fix the Movies' Biggest Mistake

Greer Riddell is a London-based film and television journalist writing about comedy, streaming and the evolving media industry in the UK and USA. She works at Collider, covering the latest in film, television and entertainment through interviews, features, reviews and industry coverage.
Her recent brand collaborations include HBO, Warner Bros., Netflix, Hulu, Sky, Disney+ and DC Studios. She has covered titles including Saturday Night Live UK, Rivals, Scrubs, Stuart Fails to Save the Universe, Ludwig, Supergirl and Stranger Things.
Her recent interviews include Florence Pugh, Mike Faist and Christopher Abbott for Netflix's East of Eden, Taika Waititi and Jenna Ortega for Klara and the Sun.
Sign in to your Collider account
One of the biggest advantages of HBO's Harry Potter adaptation over the original films is the amount of time it has to explore Hogwarts. A feature film has to prioritize the main storyline, meaning many details about the school's history, traditions, and everyday life were cut from Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone. The upcoming TV series can give these elements more attention, depicting Hogwarts not just as the setting for Harry's adventures but as an established institution with its own curriculum, residents, and history.
HBO's ‘Harry Potter’ Can Better Explore Hogwarts' Traditions and History
HBO has already offered glimpses of how the series will restore details from the books, including changes to Hogwarts' iconography. One example is Ravenclaw's crest design, which returns to the book-accurate eagle mascot and blue and bronze colors. Although these may seem like small details, the houses are central to Hogwarts' identity, and their distinct symbols and traditions help establish the school's history.
There are also several customs from the books that the films had little time to explore. When new students arrive at Hogwarts, for example, the Sorting Hat performs lengthy songs that describe the houses and their histories. The books also establish house points, common rooms, and dormitories as important parts of everyday school life. For many international audiences, particularly those unfamiliar with the British school system, the films made these details seem like magical inventions specific to Hogwarts. In reality, the school is modeled in part on traditional British private schools, with their established customs and institutional histories. The HBO series can make that connection clearer, presenting Hogwarts as a prestigious boarding school with traditions comparable to those of Eton or Wycombe Abbey, rather than treating every aspect of its organization as something exclusive to the wizarding world.
The series also has more time to explore Hogwarts' curriculum. The films showed a relatively small number of lessons, focusing on those that contributed to the main storyline. Audiences saw Professor Flitwick, played by Warwick Davis, in two very different costumes, Snape's (Alan Rickman) Potions lessons, and just one flying lesson with Madam Hooch (Zoe Wanamaker), which introduced Harry and the audience to Quidditch. However, the books feature a much wider range of subjects, teachers, and magical skills. An episodic format gives the adaptation room to show more of these classes and follow Harry and his classmates as they develop their abilities throughout the school year.
One omitted teacher who seems to be receiving more attention in the HBO adaptation is History of Magic Professor Binns, played by Richard Durden. Binns died while sitting at his desk but did not realize it, so he continued teaching as a ghost. Most students consider his lessons boring, but History of Magic provides important background on the wizarding world's past and makes Hogwarts seem much more like a real school, as there’s always going to be a class that is universally disliked!
HBO's ‘Harry Potter’ Can Introduce More of Hogwarts' Magical Residents
Beyond its traditions and school curriculum, Hogwarts is also home to magical residents and creatures who contribute to its everyday life. The films omitted several of these characters or only gave them passing mentions. Gryffindor's ghost, Nearly Headless Nick, appeared, and Ravenclaw’s Grey Lady was played by Trainspotting’s Kelly Macdonald. However, the books feature several other ghosts associated with the different houses — the Bloody Baron, Slytherin's house ghost, and the Fat Friar, who represents Hufflepuff. According to Variety, the HBO series will feature both, played by Andrew Brooke and Daniel Fearn respectively.
One of the most significant supernatural omissions from the Harry Potter films was Peeves the poltergeist. Unlike Hogwarts' ghosts, Peeves has a physical form and spends his time causing trouble throughout the castle, dropping heavy objects, smashing items, and disrupting lessons. He’s regularly supported by Fred and George Weasley, united in their hatred of the Ministry of Magic official Dolores Umbridge. Peeves was originally intended to appear in the films, with British comedian Rik Mayall (The Young Ones) filming scenes as the character; however, they were cut during editing. The HBO adaptation will finally bring Peeves to life, with comedian Peter Serafinowicz (The Tick) cast in the role. His inclusion, alongside the other Hogwarts ghosts, will give the series more opportunities to show the characters who continue to inhabit the castle outside of term time.
COLLIDERInteractive
The Hat awaits
Movies/Wizarding World/The Sorting
Collider · The Sorting Hat Awaits
Which Hogwarts House
Are You?
Eight questions · four houses · one sorting
Four houses, one destiny. The Sorting Hat has weighed thousands of students and now it is your turn. Answer honestly and find out where you belong at Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry. The four houses
Gryffindor
Slytherin
Hufflepuff
Ravenclaw
The Hat considers1 of 8
Question 1 of 8VALUES
01 What quality do you value most in yourself? Answer as honestly as you can. The Hat always knows.
Keys 1 to 4 or A to D · Enter to advance
The Hat considers2 of 8
Question 2 of 8CONFLICT
02 A friend is being treated unfairly. What do you do? How you protect other people says everything about you.
Keys 1 to 4 or A to D · Enter to advance
The Hat considers3 of 8
Question 3 of 8AMBITION
03 What does success look like to you? What you are working toward is what you are becoming.
Keys 1 to 4 or A to D · Enter to advance
The Hat considers4 of 8
Question 4 of 8FEAR
04 What is your greatest fear? Fear is the most honest thing about a person.
Keys 1 to 4 or A to D · Enter to advance
The Hat considers5 of 8
Question 5 of 8MORALITY
05 The rules say no. Your gut says go. What do you do? Every institution has rules. What you do with them is a choice.
Keys 1 to 4 or A to D · Enter to advance
The Hat considers6 of 8
Question 6 of 8FRIENDSHIP
06 What kind of friend are you? Who you are to the people you love is who you really are.
Keys 1 to 4 or A to D · Enter to advance
The Hat considers7 of 8
Question 7 of 8THE MIRROR
07 You look into the Mirror of Erised. What do you see? The mirror shows the deepest desire of your heart.
Keys 1 to 4 or A to D · Enter to advance
The Hat considers8 of 8
Question 8 of 8THE SORTING
08 The Hat pauses. It whispers: you could do well in any house. But what matters most to you, truly? This is the tiebreaker. The Hat always listens.
Keys 1 to 4 or A to D · Enter to advance
The Sorting Hat speaksYour house has been chosen
Gryffindor Gryffindor Tower · Scarlet and Gold Gryffindors do not act because they are fearless. They act because some things are worth being afraid for.
You have nerve. Not the reckless kind, but the deep and quiet sort that turns up even when you are terrified, and especially then. You stand up for people when looking away would be easier, and you go at what is right even when the odds are poor. That instinct has cost you before and you have never once decided it was not worth it. Why the Hat chose this
- You speak up in the room where it costs you something.
- You would rather be wrong and brave than right and silent.
- People come to you when something needs facing.
From the Collider file
- Dominic McLaughlin takes over as Harry in HBO's series, which arrives in 2027 after filming through 2025 and 2026.
- Daniel Radcliffe, Rupert Grint and Emma Watson were all cast in 2000, aged eleven, ten and ten.
- The Sorting Hat on screen was a practical puppet before any digital work went near it.
Nerve Acts first Stands up
Slytherin Slytherin Dungeon · Emerald and Silver At its best this is the house of people who refuse the limits other people set for them.
You are driven, sharp, and entirely clear-eyed about what you want and how to reach it. Slytherin has been misread for a long time, painted as the house of villains when what it really rewards is resourcefulness and the patience to play a long game. You know your own worth, you protect your own fiercely, and you have never needed anyone else's permission to aim high. Why the Hat chose this
- You think three moves ahead and say one of them out loud.
- You are loyal to a small circle and ruthless about the rest.
- Being underestimated has always suited you.
From the Collider file
- Alan Rickman knew Snape's ending from Rowling years before the films got there, and played it accordingly.
- Tom Felton read for Harry and for Ron before landing Draco.
- Paapa Essiedu takes the role of Snape in HBO's series.
Plays the long game Knows his worth Resourceful
Hufflepuff Hufflepuff Basement · Yellow and Black Not the safe house and not the leftover house. The house with the most heart.
You are the sort of person who makes a place better just by being in it. You turn up, you do the work, and you do not need glory or credit for any of it, because you do what is right on the grounds that it is right. Your loyalty does not waver when it is tested, which is the only time loyalty means anything at all. Hufflepuff has never been the consolation prize. Why the Hat chose this
- You are the one who remembers, and who follows through.
- You do the unglamorous part nobody volunteers for.
- Your word has never needed a backup.
From the Collider file
- Robert Pattinson played Cedric Diggory in Goblet of Fire a year before he was cast in Twilight.
- Eddie Redmayne's Newt Scamander put a Hufflepuff at the center of five Fantastic Beasts films.
- The common room sits beside the kitchens, which is the most Hufflepuff detail in the books.
Shows up Unwavering No credit needed
Ravenclaw Ravenclaw Tower · Blue and Bronze Not merely intelligence. The love of learning, and the rare nerve to say you do not know yet.
Your mind is your best thing and you have always known it. Ravenclaws are the questioners, the ones who cannot leave a puzzle alone and who find a good book better company than most rooms full of people. What marks the house out is not being clever, it is wanting to understand, and being willing to admit the gap. You see things with a clarity that other people find unsettling. Why the Hat chose this
- You would rather be corrected than comfortable.
- You notice the thing nobody else in the room noticed.
- You have never been able to leave a question alone.
From the Collider file
- Evanna Lynch was cast as Luna from an open call of roughly fifteen thousand girls, having written to Rowling as a fan.
- The tower door asks a riddle rather than a password, so a Ravenclaw can be locked out by thinking too slowly.
- Luna, Flitwick and Rowena Ravenclaw are all originals, which is rather the point of the house.
Asks the question Loves learning Sees clearly
The Hat's deliberation · your top three
1
2
3
Copied to your clipboard
Sorted byCOLLIDERCollider.com · The Fandom Desk
The series can also look beyond The Philosopher's Stone to introduce parts of Hogwarts that become important in the later books. In Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire, Hermione discovers the school kitchens and learns about the house-elves responsible for cooking, cleaning and maintaining the castle. This leads her to establish S.P.E.W., the Society for the Promotion of Elfish Welfare, to campaign for house-elves' rights and freedom. The storyline also introduces Winky, Mr. Crouch's former house-elf, who Harry and his friends meet after the Quidditch World Cup. Dobby eventually finds work in the Hogwarts kitchens, too. Including this subplot would show another part of how Hogwarts operates beyond the students and teachers. The house-elves carry out much of the work that keeps the school running, and their presence introduces wider questions about the wizarding world's social structure. It would also give Hermione's full personality room to develop, rather than cutting her screen time to prioritize Harry alone.
By including more of these details, HBO's Harry Potter can establish Hogwarts as an institution with its own ecosystem independent of Harry's adventures. The school existed long before Harry arrived and will continue long after he leaves. Its teachers, students, ghosts, house-elves, and traditions all contribute to its identity, and the upcoming series can finally depict Harry as only one part of Hogwarts' much larger legacy.
HBO's Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone is scheduled to premiere on December 25, with streaming available on HBO Max.
Harry Potter
- Release Date
- 2026 - 2026
- Network
- HBO Max
- Showrunner
- Francisca Gardiner
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.