Laura Poitras Turns Lens on ICE’s ‘Paramilitary Occupation’ of Minneapolis in ‘They’re Here’

Oscar-winning documentarian Laura Poitras is acutely aware of the importance of the weight of words when describing issues of great sensitivity. Her work has dealt with Edward Snowden’s NSA whistleblowing, the Sackler family’s role in the opioid crisis, and Iraq under U.S. occupation, among other burning sociopolitical issues of the 21st century. With “They’re Here,” the lauded director turns her lens on the U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement.
Co-directed with Rachel Lauren Muller, “They’re Here” combines footage captured by the filmmakers with material provided by activists on the ground in Minneapolis during violent ICE raids in the aftermath of the killing of Alex Pretti and Renée Good. In the short film, images of a victim barricading himself in the trunk of a car to get to work give way to a volunteer resistance organization tracking ICE raids through a citizen-fed counter-surveillance software system. In the film, words like “war zone” are used to describe what it felt like to be in Minneapolis in January of this year.
Speaking with Variety out of IDFA, Poitras says language has been “really important in all of my work.” “We have to reject the euphemisms of the government to describe things. This was a paramilitary occupation of an American city that created an effective war zone.”
“My co-director, Rachel Lauren Mueller, lives in the neighborhood that we filmed, so she can talk about the fact that there are helicopters hovering, tanks and people being executed in broad daylight,” she adds. “We need to use the word execution, use the word abduction, kidnapping, occupation, paramilitary force. Because those are the actual English words that describe what’s happening. When you use words like deportation, you’re capitulating to the government’s narrative, which I don’t think we should ever do.”
Poitras was also interested in the idea of citizens using their phones and available technology at hand to counter-surveil ICE, which she believes to be a “very effective form of resistance.” “State powers need to know that they’re being watched, that they can’t do this violence in secrecy with total impunity. There will be accountability. There has to be accountability.” Citizens, the filmmaker says, know “that this is a paramilitary occupation of the United States happening with absolutely no accountability,” and their footage is a way to “have a record that can be used both as a deterrent and as evidence and to tell the truth.”
“As a political statement, it’s important to say that the master’s tools will never dismantle the master’s house,” she adds. “There’s only so much we can do. But there is something that’s powerful about documenting and counter-surveilling what the state is doing and making sure that they know that they’re also being watched and make them nervous about that.”
“They’re Here” is permeated by a sustained sense of dread, borrowing from genre to amplify both the loud, anxiety-inducing frenzy of the raids and the dystopian images of lined-up people slowly marched into freight planes from the same airport where thousands of Americans jet off to holidays. The visual language was inspired by films like Alfonso Cuarón’s “Children of Men” and RaMell Ross’ “Nickel Boys.”
“We very much wanted to use the tools of cinema to capture the sense of horror that was unfolding and to create that uncanny distance of a reality that is unfolding as we speak,” she says. “We’re seeing so much violence, and we don’t want to repeat it. How can we denormalize it and put the audience in a perspective of both fear and terror, but also a critical distance where you understand how profoundly abnormal what’s happening in the United States is right now?”
When asked if witnessing the citizen-led efforts in Minneapolis fed a sense of hope, Poitras says she doesn’t know if “hope is the right word given the state of the world,” but that she believes resistance “does have an impact.”
Addressing the Democrats’ recent success in the U.S. midterm elections, she note, “These victories of the progressive movement in the U.S. didn’t happen overnight because of some charismatic people. Yes, of course, there are great candidates, but it was years and decades of work laying the foundation without visible results and with many defeats. When you see these successes, you realize, ok, this is a moment. There are tipping points and tables are turned and nobody can surrender our democracies.”
On top of presenting “They’re Here” at IDFA and being on the festival jury, Poitras hosted an awards screening and Q&A for Lance Oppenheim and Nathan Fielder’s doc-phenomenon “You Can See Everything” while on the ground at the Dutch festival.
“It’s totally, 100% a documentary,” she says, quickly rebuffing any idea that the majorly successful film could be anything but. “It’s dealing with ethical questions of documentary and lifting the fourth wall. Plus, it’s fantastic drama. There’s this chess match, this psychological thriller between Nathan Fielder, Elizabeth Holmes and Billy Evans that is just fascinating.”
The director pointedly says she wants to “reject any ideas that documentary filmmakers are going to reject this film because everybody loves to talk about the film.” “Everybody is so excited about both what it is doing in terms of the genre and pushing boundaries, and also it’s a fantastic success. There is also love for both of these filmmakers.”
“What’s so beautiful to watch is that it’s not a film that’s going to give you answers,” she continues. “It will provoke endless questions instead, and that is such a fantastic story device. I also think it makes us all think about everything we look at anytime we see reality on camera. And what is reality?”
Poitras believes the film is going to be “taught in every film school because of how much it teaches us about documentary filmmaking.” She is also “thrilled” for Oppenheim and Fielder’s success and the film’s gigantic box office, which looks en route to surpassing $100 million globally before the end of the month. “We consider them part of our community, not other. To have this success is just great.”
“I think it’s a lock for a Best Picture nomination, and it deserves it,” she concludes.
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.