Umno’s political leverage weakens push for reform, say analysts

There is little pressure on Umno to reform if its ability to garner voter support remains more valuable to potential coalition partners than its record in government, analysts say.

Political analyst Syaza Shukri noted that stronger grassroots support would give the party the upper hand when negotiating for positions in government. This, she added, could enable the party to ignore demands for accountability over its past failures in government.
“At the end of the day, it would be parliamentary leverage,” she said when asked whether Umno’s previous performance in government would influence future Cabinet appointments.
Given that political cycles in Malaysia are short, with only three to five years between elections, instilling good governance for decades to come is low on the priority list, she added.
As it is, she pointed out, Umno had successfully deflected attempts to link it directly to institutional failures. Instead, she said, it had managed to attribute responsibility for these failures to individuals, while its core supporters appeared willing to overlook its role in these setbacks.
She also cautioned against dismissing institutional failures involving 1MDB, Tabung Haji and the littoral combat ship (LCS) project as “old issues”.
However, Syaza said, it should not be assumed that voters concerned about Umno’s credibility or track record would automatically cast their votes for Pakatan Harapan (PH).
These voters could similarly question PH’s credibility and trustworthiness, she added.
She said repeated attacks on Umno by its rivals could also be perceived as vengeful, potentially galvanising the party’s supporters to turn out in force to demonstrate their backing.
“That will complicate efforts to make governance failures an electoral test,” she added.
Worse than we think

For James Chin of the University of Tasmania, there is a gloomier prospect: Umno could regain power without having to change its internal culture. This is a real possibility if cooperation with PAS proves sufficient to consolidate Malay support.
Chin noted that the party had briefly regarded reform as necessary following its defeat in the 2018 general election because it wanted to return to power. However, political alliances had since emerged as a viable alternative.
“It is not possible for Umno to change,” he said.
Chin argued that the prospect of securing power through cooperation with PAS had weakened the incentive for substantive internal reform, while divisive political competition had left little room for meaningful accountability.
He also said cost-of-living pressures and competing demands on voters’ attention could push accountability further down their list of priorities, even if they remained concerned about governance failures.
Political influence alone is not enough

Awang Azman Pawi of Universiti Malaya offered a different perspective on the challenges facing Umno.
He pointed out that parliamentary strength should not be the sole measure of a party’s value to a coalition, nor should past failures permanently define its ability to govern.
“Cabinet appointments should certainly reflect competence, integrity and administrative experience rather than the number of parliamentary seats alone,” he said.
He argued that Umno could contribute institutional knowledge, administrative continuity and an understanding of grassroots development needs.
“In coalition politics, parliamentary strength matters, but governing capability is equally important.”
Awang Azman said political parties should be given the opportunity to change, provided they demonstrated stronger internal accountability and leadership characterised by integrity and professional competence.
For Syaza, however, Umno had already been given an opportunity to demonstrate such change through its participation in the federal administration under the unity government.
She said acknowledging its own shortcomings, rather than deflecting criticism by pointing to the failures of other parties, would be a starting point.
Subscribe to our newsletter and get news delivered to your mailbox.
KioskNews shows a cleaned-up reading view extracted from the publisher’s page — the original always lives on their site, not ours.